Thursday, May 28, 2020

Constant Reminders of Death

            In Tolkien’s world there are many traditions and roles that men and hobbits participate and play in their respective societies that serve as constant reminders that death looms right around the corner. Hobbits and men share many similarities, and this should be unsurprising as Hobbits potentially are descended from men as it appears that no Valar took part in their direct creation and Tolkien does not provide any other strong basis for their emergence in Arda. Both of these mortal races have their members play pivotal roles in the events of the Tolkien’s trilogy, making mortals play the parts of heroes that would shape the Fourth Age rather than the immortal elves. The prevalence of birthdays in the world of men and hobbits and the ubiquitous need for healers in the world of men serve as constant reminders of death for both the reader and the world of Tolkien. Tolkien interweaves death as a constant threat for the mortal races, where even the Hobbits experience pain and affliction leading to their torment and possible deaths under Sharkey.
            The characterization of birthdays as constant reminders of death can even be seen in our modern world and throughout history in various cultures. In times when infant and childhood mortality rates were much higher, the first to first few birthdays would be considered very important, signs of a healthy child who was able to survive the beginning trials of life. Birthdays such as these are often thought of as great celebrations of life; however, they are also reminders of those who did not make it to through those beginning years. The Lord of the Rings begins with Bilbo’s 111th birthday, a symbol of unnaturally youthful long life, as shown through Bilbo’s physical description at the time. Bilbo’s birthday exhibits the traditional aspects of a Hobbit’s birthday, just on a much larger scale. For Hobbits, birthdays serve as a way of bringing the community and/or family together, where with each coming birthday, gifts and tokens of appreciation are given to and from the Hobbit whose birth is being celebrated. Birthdays serve as a mechanism to strengthen the family and communities of Hobbits, a mechanism that could potentially help combat the threat of death by keeping Hobbits close to each other or at least in contact with one another. The inclusion of birthdays as being such an important part of Hobbit culture and traditions shows that while it may not be a conscious reminder of death, the mortality of hobbits is readily apparent through this simple idea. A race such as the Elves or the Ents have no real use of the concept of birthdays as time isn’t always on their mind like men and hobbits. Mortality is something that every hobbit and man faces, a reason why adventure is so tempting to some, yet also so frightening. Everyone wants to make the most of their time in Arda, and birthdays serve as a reminder to the limited time one has.
            Men, a race with a long history of conflict has need for healers and houses of healing probably more than any other race in Tolkien’s world. Men are the most susceptible to ailments, thus increasing their need in the knowledge of remedies and cures for diseases and wounds. As seen with the downfall and legacy of the Numenoreans, there is a constant obsession with death, and with their once friendship with the elves, the knowledge of healing and cures allowed them to pass on this information and instill a natural ability for healing into their descendants. One of these descendants, Aragorn, becomes the larger than life heroic figure that complements the other hero, Frodo. The need for one of the heroes and savior of men to possess the ability to heal serves two main purposes. This shows that there is a constant need for men to have the ability to endure the blows that come their way; the king, their leader and savior, has the knowledge and ability to provide and heal his people in their times of need. This is demonstrated after Strider is able to slow the damage from the wound Frodo suffered at Amon Sul. Men and hobbits are bound to Middle Earth during their time on Arda, they are unable to venture to the Undying Lands like the Elves, so for these two races there needs to be the ability to preserve and prolong their lives within their own kind. I suppose that healing and healing houses are only major parts of the societies of men as hobbits possess natural resistances to disease and they do not have a history that is as full of conflict and violence as men.  
            Although these two features of hobbit and human societies might appear to be minor aspects and details, I think that these combine to show just how pressing the idea of death is to the mortal races of Middle Earth. Even though these constantly remind us of death, they also serve as avenues to keep death at bay or to keep a community’s spirits up in the defiance of death’s gaze.

-AS

Wednesday, May 27, 2020

“It is a gift!” -Boromir

 J.R.R. Tolkien heart-wrenchingly wrote this about the death of his own wife, his Luthien, “But the story has gone crooked, & I am left, and I cannot plead before the inexorable Mandos” (Letter 340). As he so often does, Tolkien captures several of the core lamentations about the human condition: the loss of a loved one, the finitude and suffering of life, and the sometimes seemingly cruel apathy of the universe. In a phrase, fear of death. While Edith's may have been among the worst losses Tolkien endured in life, it certainly was not his first. He had been well acquainted with the barbs of the human condition long before he penned The Lord of the Rings and even before the first rough conceptions of The Silmarillion took root. Indeed, the following could be said of Tolkien and his legendarium: “So great was her sorrow, as the Music unfolded, that her song turned to lamentation long before its end, and the sound of mourning was woven into the themes of the World before it began.” And so Tolkien wrestled with his conception of mortality, or expressed his understanding of it, by putting it in dialogue with immortality throughout his works. A theme which he explores from the first pages of The Silmarillion to the Akallabêth to The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. Yet, it is in the final story of Arwen and Aragorn in Appendix A where his findings are condensed. In the end, we find Tolkien provides an argument more so than final answers to the great debate, which is all anyone can do. 

When Aragorn reaches the end of his time on earth, Arwen is distraught. “She was not yet weary of her days, and thus she tasted the bitterness of the mortality that she had taken upon her” (Appendix A). Interestingly enough, Aragorn himself seems long reconciled with the notion of death, saying, “To me has been given not only a span of thrice that of Men of Middle-Earth, but also the grace to go at my will, and give back the gift. Now, therefore, I will sleep” (Appendix A). The inversion of the usual roles here is certainly not unintentional by Tolkien. 

Prior to this interaction, it is Men who label their mortality as the Doom of Man, and it is the Elves who label it the Gift of Men. In every letter he discusses the topic, Tolkien reminds and reasserts it is the Elves who call it the Gift of Men because that is how they perceive it as immortals. Tolkien writes, even if mortality is a product of the Fall, the Elves can only see it as a positive gift: “It should be regarded as an Elvish perception of what death — not being tied to the 'circles of the world' – should now become for Men, however it arose” (Letter 208). Arwen herself admits she used to scorn the wicked, foolish men who resented the great gift that "as Time wears even the Powers shall envy" (Silmarillion). That is precisely Tolkien’s way of wrestling with morality. So very many of us succumb to the fears of Ar-Pharazon and dread the prospect of death and dream ever after immortality. Tolkien points out, quite simply, that immortality may not be as an exciting prospect as all that. “Many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view,” and the very thing we see as our doom is seen to be a gift by others (Star Wars: Return of the Jedi). The reverse is also true: Men throughout Tolkien's legendarium cling to life and envy the Elves for their unending ones. As Tolkien describes it, “The 'Elves' are 'immortal', at least as far as this world goes: and hence are concerned rather with the griefs and burdens of deathlessness in time and change, than with death” (Letter 131). Meanwhile, “The Doom (or the Gift) of Men is mortality, freedom from the circles of the world. Since the point of view of the whole cycle is the Elvish, mortality is not explained mythically: it is a mystery of God of which no more is known than that 'what God has purposed for Men is hidden': a grief and an envy to the immortal Elves” (Letter 131). The debate can be summarized as such, “Death and Immortality: the mystery of the love of the world in the hearts of a race 'doomed' to leave and seemingly lose it; the anguish in the hearts of a race 'doomed' not to leave it, until its whole evil-aroused story is complete” (Letter 186). 

One man's view of death, perhaps one we could all adopt, at least relative to the unfortunate fate of the Elves.
Thus the inversion in the final chapter of the story of Arwen and Aragorn is stunning. Even an Elf comes to lament and bitterly resent the cruel fate of Men. But Aragorn is King, he is a wise and studied man. He seems to have realized the following truth long ago, and passes it along to Arwen in their last moments when her grief is culminating, “I speak no comfort to you, for there is no comfort for such pain within the circles of the world” (Appendix A). Certainly not a coincidence by Tolkien, Aragorn encapsulates one of the key arguments for why death ought to be seen as a Gift rather than a Doom: the Elves are condemned to wallow in the misery and regret of lost things till the end of days, and there will be no comfort or escape from the misery, loss, and fading of things to be found on earth, but in death there may yet prove some release from this fate. He reminds her of the options in front of her, “The uttermost choice is before you: to repent and go to the Havens and bear away into the West the memory of our days together that shall be there evergreen but never more than memory; or else to abide the Doom of Men” (Appendix A). And here is where Tolkien enters as close to an answer on life after death as he will, Aragorn says in closing, “In sorrow we must go, but not in despair. Behold! we are not bound for ever to the circles of the world, and beyond them is more than memory” (Appendix A). Though none, not even the Elves, know what lies beyond Death, it is perhaps better than being bound to eternity. To continue to live after loss maintains only the memory of what once was. Death brings the possibility of something more, something beyond, something, Tolkien believes, more than mere memory. Perhaps even many meetings and reunions await, just as Luthien and Beren passed together "beyond the confines of the world," for it is written, "and yet at last they met once more, and long ago they passed away in the forest singing sorrowless" (A Knife in the Dark).

Moreover, Tolkien again comments on if Death is a consequence of the Fall of Man, then “A divine 'punishment' is also a divine 'gift', if accepted, since its object is ultimate blessing, and the supreme inventiveness of the Creator will make 'punishments' (that is changes of design) produce a good not otherwise to be attained: a 'mortal' Man has probably (an Elf would say) a higher if unrevealed destiny than a longeval one” (Letter 212). And it is perhaps only with this understanding can we understand that death is a gift of God and should be treated and respected as such. There are few things more heinous than rejecting a gift from God, especially since the very act is impossible: “To attempt by device or 'magic' to recover longevity is thus a supreme folly and wickedness of 'mortals'. Longevity or counterfeit 'immortality' (true immortality is beyond Ea) is the chief bait of Sauron – it leads the small to a Gollum, and the great to a Ringwraith” (Letter 212). Not only is it offensive to God, it is an impossible undertaking to deny the gift and will of the Creator, the very attempt of which can lead to, in a particularly egregious case, the intervention of God himself in the Numenoreans revolt against mortality.  Indeed, Tolkien summarizes his findings as such, “Death is not an Enemy! I said, or meant to say, that the 'message' was the hideous peril of confusing true 'immortality' with limitless serial longevity. Freedom from Time, and clinging to Time. The confusion is the work of the Enemy, and one of the chief causes of human disaster. Compare the death of Aragorn with a Ringwraith” (Letter 208). Moreover, “The attempt to escape it is wicked because 'unnatural', and silly because Death in that sense is the Gift of God (envied by the Elves), release from the weariness of Time. Death, in the penal sense, is viewed as a change in attitude to it: fear, reluctance. A good Númenórean died of free will when he felt it to be time to do so” (Letter 156). There is, perhaps, no one better to come to this understanding, as well as espouse and exemplify this view than Aragorn son of Arathorn, both because of his relationship with Arwen, as well as because his ancestry fell from grace so spectacularly precisely by being consumed by this fear and the confusion over "immortality" (more aptly, eternal memories- and nothing more- than things that once were and have been lost) and "mortality" (escape from the loss and the opportunity for more than despairing memories). 

When we realize immortality is hardly, if at all, a better gift, and in some ways is more obviously worse than the unknown potentialities of Death, and pair that with the acceptance and reverence of gifts of a good Creator, as well as acknowledging it is an unescapable aspect of the human condition, we can at least see an argument on why we ought to accept Death, maybe even as a gift, even if we are still left clueless as to what lies beyond the horizon. Tolkien writes his concern was with, “Death as part of the nature, physical and spiritual, of Man, and with Hope without guarantees.” Perhaps death is a fool's hope, but there is at least hope in it, nonetheless. And so Tolkien once again has gotten the better of himself, transmuting the greatest sorrow of Man into wisdom. We can, and perhaps should be sorrowful that things come to an end and loved ones (at least temporarily) abandon us in their escape from Time. Tolkien’s mourning of Edith as well as Arwen’s mourning of Aragorn are justified, it is a testament to the quality of time they had together, only enhanced by its fleeting nature. Grief is the price we pay for love. Both should heed Gandalf’s parting words, “I will not say: do not weep; for not all tears are an evil.” Their grief is expected, but they are not justified to despair. The rules are already set, perhaps in our favor, and so we cannot "plead to the inexorable Mandos" anymore than we can stop the sun from setting. We should grieve, but remember to appreciate that while the inexorable Mandos taketh, it also giveth all the things we so fear to lose. "Out of the darkness of my life, so much frustrated, I put before you the one great thing to love on earth: the Blessed Sacrament. .... There you will find romance, glory, honour, fidelity, and the true way of all your loves upon earth, and more than that: Death: by the divine paradox, that which ends life, and demands the surrender of all, and yet by the taste (or foretaste) of which alone can what you seek in your earthly relationships (love, faithfulness, joy) be maintained, or take on that complexion of reality, of eternal endurance, which every man's heart desires” (Letter 43). As Pippin says in the face of certain doom, "That's got to count for something."

To Hope without guarantees,
Tom B(ombadil)

The Key-spring of The Lord of the Rings

“Death, the inevitability of death,” Tolkien once remarked, is the theme central to “practically all” large stories that hold the interest of human beings. He believed that a central aspect of what it means to be human is our relationship to our own mortality. In his seminal essay “On Fairy-stories,” he had this to say in much the same vein: “the oldest and deepest desire [is] the Great Escape: the Escape from Death,” which appears throughout fairy-stories, their “scientifically inspired” counterparts, and “other studies.”

That Tolkien was heavily focused on humanity’s mortal condition is apparent even in The Lord of the Rings, which is ostensibly more about the nature of Power and Domination. He said as much on numerous occasions in his letters, but perhaps most fascinatingly in a 1968 interview conducted by the BBC, from which the opening quotation of this blog post is also cited. At the end of the interview, Tolkien was asked about his own view of life and how it relates to his fictional world. He responded by pulling a newspaper clipping from his jacket pocket and from it quoting Simone de Beauvoir’s A Very Easy Death:

There is no such thing as a natural death: nothing that happens to a man is ever natural, since his presence calls the world into question. All men must die: but for every man his death is an accident and, even if he knows it and consents to it, an unjustifiable violation.

“Well,” he continues, “you may agree with the words or not, but those are the key-spring of The Lord of the Rings.” That Tolkien would so strongly state the most powerful theme he sees in his book is of course significant, but as mentioned before, it is by no means a unique occurrence of such a statement (cf. Letters 186, 203, 208, etc.). But the de Beauvoir quotation is significant in its explicit exemplification of this idea.

The importance of the quotation is that it expresses man’s fear of death in Tolkienian terms while being utterly distinct from his mythology. This shows the universalizability of Tolkien’s central theme. The ever-present resentment of humanity for its mortality and its suffocating fear of death is a powerful and ubiquitous feeling. Death is the most universal experience for our species. And de Beauvoir sums up the roiling emotions behind it in A Very Easy Death.

But Tolkien does not of course mean to say that her statement is the correct way to view death. It is the “key-spring” in that it is the primary driving force for the events of Tolkien’s mythology. In his world, the desire to cheat death, to remain embodied within the bounds of the physical world for as long as possible, is found throughout the race of Men. Perhaps the clearest and most direct expression of this idea comes from Andreth, the Wise-woman of the House of Bëor, who laments the unjust fate of her kind in the “Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth.” She believes that Man was not always meant to be short of life, to die and leave the world, but that such was the contrivance of Morgoth. He, so it was said among her people, had corrupted the destiny of the Edain, and thus had their lives been cut short and their futures doomed. To her mind, Men were meant to be as elves, to reside within the Circles of the World for all time.

This is the same belief that was held by the corrupted later kings of Númenor. In the days of their people’s glory, the rulers of the island held the view “that a ‘good’ Man would or should die voluntarily by surrender with trust before being compelled” (Note to Letter 212). They laid down their scepter before being taken by age and becoming dotard. But the thirteenth king Tar-Atanamir, refused to do so, clinging to life until he was taken against his will. It was he who had scoffed at the elves of Valinor, openly declaring his resentment for the mortality he viewed as having cursed him. He and his people had grown envious of the elves, whom they called “the least of the deathless.”

In both of these cases, it is seen that Men are desirous of the fate of the Eldar. Andreth is revealed to be bitter at her old age in large part because of her love of an immortal elf. But this is of course not as it was meant to be in the beginning. Death is the “Gift of Ilúvatar” to the race of Men, unique to them, which the elves say “as Time wears even the Powers shall envy” (The Silmarillion, Chapter 1). It was Morgoth, the prime mover of evil who began it. He alone is responsible for the introduction of fear into the world, which dates even to the birth of the elves themselves. (Cf. Tom Bombadil’s words that he “knew the dark under the stars when it was fearless – before the Dark Lord came from Outside” (The Lord of the Rings, Chapter 7)). And from his work the fear of death spread among men. The “Athrabeth” explains further that Morgoth even made Men to worship the darkness and to turn utterly from the light for a time.

The history of Men was therefore plagued through time with their dread of death, so that by the time of Sauron’s rule as the “Dark Lord,” he was further able to pervert the Gift into a twisted lie. The clearest example in this case is that of the Nazgûl. The rings that Sauron gave to them were able to confer longer life. But this was of course no true immortality. The Men who received them became wraiths, shadows of the Shadow, wasted and weary as the centuries came and went.

In all of the cases presented, the role of de Beauvoir’s passage is clear: Tolkien’s Men are fearful of the unknown that awaits them upon their deaths, and so they resent their mortality and seek for any means they can to circumvent it, with disastrous results. Perverting the will of Ilúvatar is utterly hopeless. And thus, the “Great Escape” from death into immortality sought throughout fairy-stories is the most pernicious of lies. Man is not meant for immortality. Once “achieved,” it is revealed to be merely some horrible kind of “endless serial living” (On Fairy-stories), like that of the Nazgûl.

A final and summarizing illustration of this concept is found in the Narn I Chîn Húrin, the Tale of the Children of Húrin. Húrin, a Man, is chained to a chair on the slopes of Thangorodrim as punishment for his role in resisting Morgoth. Still defiant, Húrin declares to Morgoth that “though all Arda and Menel fall in [his] dominion,” he would still never be Lord of Men, for he could not pursue them beyond the Circles of the World. Morgoth declares that “beyond the Circles of the World there is Nothing” and that within them, none could escape him. Morgoth’s lie is the same he has told forever, and Húrin’s statement of faith is the pure manifestation of his belief in the Gift of Ilúvatar. And after all of Húrin’s family is killed through the horrible works of Morgoth, this glimmer of hope remains to us who read of it. Though the lives of these fallen Men in Arda were made into a misery by the forces of evil, they did escape beyond the Circles of the World in the end, departing the physical world for one utterly beyond the grasp of Morgoth. In doing so, they realized the True Great Escape: not one away from death and into false immortality, but into the embrace of the Gift of Ilúvatar.

          – Andrew Stump

On Death

By far the most interesting Tolkien reading we’ve done this quarter was The Debate of Finrod and Andreth(Athrabeth Finrod Ah Andreth), further referred to as The Debate. This blog post, unlike my previous ones, isn’t going to just make a single argument about some aspect of the Legendarium, but is more a consolidation of some reactions from this week’s readings in a loosely connected way.

The first reason I find this week’s reading particularly interesting is that they show how integral the legendarium was to Tolkien’s way of life. He grappled with the questions of Death and the desire for eternal life not in some real-world way, but rather by writing philosophical conversations with his characters in his books. He dealt with grief about his wife by drawing parallels to her as Luthien. Only on reading Letter 340 did I truly understand how much this story meant to JRR Tolkien. He particularly points out that this name isn’t just a ‘sentimental fallacy' and is ‘not comparable to quoting of pet names’. He laments that he cannot plead with Mandos, which just goes to show how much he truly believed in his Legendarium’s myths. This letter showed me that to Tolkien, the Legendarium wasn’t just a hobby, or an academic interest. It was the framework through which he understood his personal life and how he comprehended even Love. His sources weren’t just academic Old English words but also his very life and loved ones. I find this level of dedication to subcreation incredible, and I think Letter 340 is the best argument I have yet seen for taking this course: to study the depths of a brilliant and utterly singly-focused man’s life’s work.

The Debate again shows us Tolkien grappling with real-life questions of mortality through his fiction. This is my favourite reading, because it shows a side of the Legendarium that I never even knew existed: a part which questions the very nature of evil. Never before had I seen such candid descriptions of why Men were more susceptible to Melkor’s words. Never before had I heard such a clear and honest conversation between Elf and Man about what exactly makes them different. It fills in a lot of the philosophical questions the Legendarium raises. The Debate is honest about how being seduced by Melkor isn’t something that can happen only to ‘weak’ Men, but shows how Melkor’s words are convincing to even the strongest of Men. This is a level of honesty about evil that we don’t really see in much of the Legendarium: the honesty to discuss Evil in a non-antagonistic, but rather academic sense. One thing that I would like to note is that the argument for Melkor’s evil nature is always tautological, even in the Debate: the fact that he acted against the Creator Eru is all that makes him Evil, not his actions or anything else. This feels annoying to me, but is ultimately consistent with Tolkien’s view of a monotheist, Christian God.

The final(in more than one sense) question that needs to be answered then, is the question of the Gift of Men. Why is Death a gift to us, in Tolkien’s worldview? Tolkien isn’t particularly fond of death: he puts the immortal Elves at the centre of his stories and considers them the greatest (non-Ainur) beings on Middle-Earth. This attitude of the Eldar being ‘greater’ than Men was common among even the Elves, as noted by Finrod. Death is the cause of tragedy for every single romance between Elves and Men in Middle-Earth. It seems as though Men are cursed with Death! Tolkien acknowledges this bitterness with Arwen’s last words to Aragorn: ‘if this is the gift of the One to Men, it is bitter to receive.’ Death is difficult. The death of a loved one is possibly the most difficult thing someone ever has to do in their life. Tolkien is painfully aware of this himself, and even Aragorn acknowledges the sorrow of death on his deathbed. Tolkien had seen enough death in his life, as a war veteran, and was certainly not naive enough to claim that this cause of sorrow and pain was somehow an unquestionable Gift.

Yet, it is the Gift of Men. I have but one reasoning for this, and the argument is somewhat as follows. Our fea exist in Arda when we are alive, as do the Elves. The Elves are forever bound to Arda, for their fea can’t leave. This means that Elves fundamentally never face uncertainty in their lives. The Valar protect them, and their destinies are safe and predictable. The only uncertainty they face is that of Dagor Dagorath, and what happens after the End of the World. This is solved for them, by their concept of Estel. Estel is an unquestioning Hope(or trust), that, no matter what, because they are the Children of Illuvatar, they will be taken care of. It’s an optimism based on trust in the Lord and nothing else. (Note how, on replacing ‘Eru’ with ‘the Lord’ in the previous sentence, how similar I made it sound to the Christian trust in Jesus and God.) However, Men cannot have this same level of trust and certainty in their future. Death is a fundamental unknown. Unlike the known unknown that is the future, the afterlife is an unknowable unknown, that cannot be deduced even in part from the current state of the world. This unknowable unknown is scary, and sad, because Melkor made it so. Melkor associated it with Darkness and hardship and misery. This is what Tolkien meant when he said that Men are more susceptible to corruption than the Elves: because the Elves lack this unknown unknown, it is impossible for Melkor to turn this uncertainty into fear.

How then, does an unmarred Man, a Child of Illuvatar, deal with death? The answer is the same as that for the Elves, but much harder: Estel. Estel is difficult for Men: Men do not interact with the Valar on a daily basis. Men don’t have the fortune of having guidance from Eru, even through his Ainur. Men have a fundamental uncertainty in their near future, of death. This makes faith in Eru difficult, if not impossible. This makes Men susceptible to Melkor. But it is possible to not fear death. To believe, that, like the Elves, the uncertainty that awaits Men is Good, too. For if, after death, the fea of Men have no place on Earth, they must go out of this World, and be united with the Creator, Eru. This is what Estel means for Men: to have the faith that our afterlife is fundamentally Good, because it is ordained by Eru, our Creator, and because we are Children of Illuvatar. Thus, our fate is fundamentally the same as that of the Elves: to become one with Eru and a part of Arda Healed. The only difference is, that we do it quicker. This way, we do not have our experiences marred by memory and tragedy, like the Elves necessarily do.

The reason Death is a Gift, then, is because it unites us with the One.

-Rohan Kapoor

Remember Today, Little Brother

Elves, the Firstborn, the Elder Child. Strong, beautiful, wise. Waking under star and speaking with the gods; gazing upon the light that dwells in the West; falling in pride and yet saved by hope—that Men might do what they cannot and bring them back to the light.

Men, the Secondborn, the Younger Child. Followers, strangers, short-lived. Waking under Shadow yet with faces toward the sun; destined to inherit the world; falling in fear and yet saved by hope—trust in Eru that Arda will be restored, and that death is not the end but rather indicative of their freedom from and purpose within the world.

The primary relationship between Elves and Men is one of siblinghood. They are two halves of a family tree that intertwine with one another, the first enriching the second until only Men are left in Middle-Earth, carrying on the family line through the joining of both races. Though by the end of the Third Age, Men and Elves are mostly estranged (and by present day, they have faded away entirely) this was not always so. The conversation between Finrod and Andreth points to both the friendship between the two races as well as their underlying kinship. They learn much from one another, Finrod of the human tradition that immortality was their original lot until lost through some means of the Shadow, Andreth of Elvish death, and the final end that awaits the Elves once Arda fails. But even while they learn from each other, they also give each other insight that points them toward truth. When Finrod suggests that Arda is not humanity’s true home, Andreth is moved; something within her rises to that suggestion. When Andreth discusses Man’s interaction with Arda, Finrod sees a vision of healing that gives him joy and hope. Elf and woman are able to affect each other so deeply because they are ultimately brother and sister.

In Genesis, God establishes his covenant with the younger son, though everyone would expect the firstborn to receive the promise, and brother is momentarily (or permanently) estranged from brother. Ishmael is passed over for Isaac, Esau for Jacob. Even Abel pleases God more than his older brother Cain (and earns a premature demise for his troubles). This family that God chooses is one that he will use to bring his creation back to himself. As children of the promise, Israel is meant to bless the other nations; they are God’s chosen instrument for world renewal.

Men, the Secondborn, similarly become the children of the promise. Of course, the promise is never stated outright, and Eru, unlike the Judeo-Christian God, hardly bothers to speak to his creation, but it is Men, not Elves, who inherit Arda. And humans come into more than just an inheritance: Finrod’s vision presents a world that has been restored by men—through them, Arda Marred becomes Arda Remade. It suggests that Men are not at home in Arda because their hearts belong to this healed future, while the Elves love the world too much and remain firmly within it. Because Men have the gift of free will, they are able to act beyond the Music, which patterns Arda Marred, and can remake the world into something new. It is Men who are the ones said to join in the Second Music at the end, while the fate of Elves is unknown. It is Men who will perhaps save the Elves from their never-ending sorrow.

While this purpose of Man aligns with mankind’s gifts from Eru, what has actually taken place does not seem so hopeful. Just as younger siblings imitate the older, so Men follow in the footsteps of the Elves. The there-and-back motion of the Noldor who go to the light and then flee from it is mirrored in the path of the Númenóreans. Physically, both move West and then return East, but even in name, there are echoes of their parallel movements from light. Flieger notes the spectrum of light present in the naming of the elves—the High Elves, the Twilight Elves, and the Dark Elves (Splintered Light). Similarly, Faramir calls the descendents of the Númenóreans the High, while the Rohirrim are Men of the Twilight, and their enemies are the Men of the Darkness. Just as the Noldor, upon returning, become more and more like the Sindar, their Twilight brethren, so Faramir notes that the men of Gondor are becoming increasingly like the men of Rohan (LotR IV.5).

Yet, as the children of the promise, descent into darkness is not to be the fate of mankind. Flieger suggests that the interaction between Men and Elves is one of crossing paths—Elves are moving away from the light while Men move toward it, and their interactions mutually benefit each other: “Elves need Men just as much as Men need Elves. Elves, going toward darkness, will set Men’s feet on the path to the light. With that accomplished, Men—less visibly great than Elves but with immeasurably greater potential, may be able to turn back and assist Elves into the light” (Splintered Light 145). But how do Men return to the light having trod for so long beneath the Shadow?

The answer, it seems, lies in the union between Elves and Men, and here is where the biblical motif takes a turn. Instead of simply superseding the other, the younger brother can only gain the promise with the help of the elder, and he acts on behalf of them both. Through the “ennoblement of the Human Race” (Letter 153), a new light is found within humanity: “this indwelling light [...] is at last to replace the tangible, external light” (Splintered Light 145). In other words, this is the moment in which the metaphor made literal returns to being a metaphor. Humanity is the new light. The West, the (pen)ultimate source and symbol of light throughout the legendarium, is ultimately rejected by the Half-Elven—when Aragorn and Arwen agree to marry, they reject the West as well as the East: “And there upon that hill they looked east to the Shadow and west to the Twilight, and they plighted their troth and were glad.” Twilight, which once covered only Middle-Earth, now encompasses the West, the Blessed Realm itself. Hope will not come from the Valar. Hope comes from trust in Eru beyond Arda and his intent to use Men within Arda in order to bring about the renewal of the world.

KY