Wednesday, June 3, 2020

“A Elbereth!" — Tolkien's Psalms


In Letter 142, Tolkien says “For the religious element is absorbed into the story and its symbolism.” Here he is, of course, referring to the elements of his own Catholic theology embedded in the Lord of the Rings. One of these elements that stands out particularly to me is the poems/verse that are scattered throughout the tale, as they often bring to mind psalms and prayers found in the Bible and in liturgy, especially those that mention and/or are praises to Elbereth. The similarities between the songs/invocations of Elbereth and psalms I think display not only Tolkien’s views about how religion should be practiced, but also I think the importance of religion in our lives as a grounding and life-giving practice.
The reverence that the elves have for Elbereth (Varda) is clear in the hobbits’ first encounter with them outside of the Shire and the elves are singing of Elbereth. One stanza in particular is heavily reminiscent of a hymn:

Snow-White! Snow-White! O Lady Clear!
O Queen beyond the Western Seas!
O Light to us that wander here
Amid the world of woven trees!...

O stars that in the Sunless Year
With shining hand by her were sown
In windy fields now bright and clear
We see your silver blossom blown! (Tolkien 88)

"Varda of the Stars" by Kip Rasmussen

The psalms, of course, are filled with poetry and verse that have a similar...vibe, so to speak, as the elves’ song to Elbereth. The elves’ song can very easily be mapped onto a psalm, as both  do many of the same things: naming the object of their praise as a ruler over the land (or in this case, the seas), praising the works of their hands, calling them a light for the people, etc.

In his letter to his son, Christopher, Tolkien talks about ways to find comfort when he can’t attend Mass: “If you don’t do so already, make a habit of the ‘praises,’” after which he lists several hymns/psalms that he himself uses to worship. Pairing this letter with the The Ancrene Riwle, it is pretty clear to see that praise in the forms of psalms and hymns are extremely important elements of worship to Tolkien, and he relays this through the text in the form of hymns to Elbereth.

Another ‘psalm’ to Elbereth that is of particular note is in chapter ten of book four of The Lord of the Rings, when Sam is defending Frodo from Shelob. Just as he falls to the ground, a ‘swoon upon him,’ Sam pulls out the Phial of Galadriel and cries out:

A Elbereth Gilthoniel
o menel palan-diriel
le nallon sí di’nguruthos!
A tiro nin, Fanuilos!

In his letter to Rhona Beare, Tolkien says that this ‘hymn-fragment’ translates to “O Elbereth Starkindler from heaven gazing-afar, to thee I cry now in the shadow (the fear of) death. O look towards me, Everwhite!” This verse has a reference, intentional or otherwise, that I recognized near instantly: “Though I walk in the valley of the shadow of death, I fear no evil, for thou art with me” (Psalm 23). The stark similarity between Sam’s outburst and the well-known Psalm 23 I think lends itself to further conveying Tolkien’s point here, that in moments of darkness, faith and worship can be lights to carry us through. He mentions this in his letter to his son, saying “How these old words smite one out of the dark antiquity!” in reference to a poem from the Exeter book, and in Sam’s case, the hymn to Elbereth quite literally smites the enemy about to attack him.

Several times throughout The Lord of the Rings, we see one of the characters crying out to Elbereth in times of dire need: Frodo on Weathertop, Legolas before firing his bow at the flying creature in chapter nine of book two, etc. Similarly, many psalms cry out to God, asking for protection, for forgiveness, for deliverance, and the list goes on. Needless to say, Tolkien’s use of characters crying out to Elbereth very much keeps with the religious overtones of the hymns to Elbereth elsewhere in the text. In Tolkien’s letter to Michael Tolkien, Letter 250, he says “In the last resort faith is an act of will, inspired by love.” I think this line is very much applicable to these moments where the characters cry out to Elbereth, especially Sam when he’s fighting off Shelob. While I think that perhaps Tolkien’s words in the letter refer to a love of God, Sam holding up the Phial and crying out to Elbereth is an act of will, an act of faith, inspired by his love and devotion for Frodo. In his last resort, Sam reached out to a higher power and made an act of worship in order to save his friend (and also the quest, but I think it’s pretty obvious the quest is secondary to Frodo in Sam’s mind).

While Tolkien’s use of hymn and psalm in The Lord of the Rings is partially a product of his own faith and life experiences, I also think that it’s a deliberate move to subtly impress upon the readers (us) the importance of faith, especially in dark times. In demonstrating the necessity of worshipful acts like praise and singing hymns/saying the psalms, Tolkien also demonstrates how faith can lead us through life’s tribulations and ground us when things are difficult. And these lessons stretch across the bounds of time, as faith can be a source of peace and light for us as well in the turbulent times we inhabit today.

- CR

Friday, May 29, 2020

True Heroes: Pictures of Christ in the Fellowship


Professor Fulton- Brown brought up a point in class about Christ being everywhere in the story (of Lord of the Rings) but not being literally apparent. I have often noted this about the story, whenever someone tries to tell me that so-and-so character is an allegory for Christ, I think of another one that is equally but differently demonstrative of Christ’s role and attributes in what Tolkien views as the real story. Looking especially at the fellowship of the ring, I believe that several of its members reflect aspects of Christ throughout Tolkien’s story. This is not of course to say that Tolkien placed these there as intended allegories, but rather a natural tendency for Truth to be integrated in the creation of these characters as they formed from his subconscious. Of course, the heroes of Tolkien’s work would reflect the hero of the actual story, but it is important to note that no one character is able to reflect all the attributes of the Christ. But that does not stop the aspects from leaking into the story and expressing themselves through several characters. For the sake of time, I am going to focus briefly, mainly on three members of the fellowship which I think all display differing aspects of the Christ story: Aragorn, Gandalf, and Frodo.

First of all, Aragorn. The chosen King from a great lineage whose coming marks the beginning of a new era: Aragorn is the most obvious messianic figure in the texts with his otherworldly wisdom, goodness, and power. He even looks the part in Peter Jackson’s adaptations. But is not quite that simple. Aragorn reflects the perfect anointed King, the one who can and will defend his own and will uplift it but most importantly the one who is king because he can heal. In the chapter “In the Houses of Healing” Ioreth recognizes her future king, not by his great sword or his Kingly demeanor, but by his power to heal and restore: “The hands of the king are the hands of a healer, and so shall the rightful king be known” (Lord of the Rings Book V Ch. VIII). Aragorn mirrors the kingly authority that Christ is said to have not only because he is the great warrior but because, and more importantly, he is the great healer.
 He also has the genealogy that reaches back to great men of the past such as Elendil and beyond to Numenor and then to the Elves themselves. This is a standard trope of the great Romantic hero, but Tolkien would point out that the trope itself reflects a Truth of our reality, namely that the greatest romantic hero ever has his own great genealogy with great kings and sires. Jeremiah 23:5 speaks of a branch of David being raised up to Kingship just as Aragorn, Isildur’s heir is foretold to come and restore the kingdom. This epic story of the great hero winning his kingdom and his bride reminds of the victory of Christ as he gains his everlasting kingdom and is own spotless bride (the Church) as a result of his deeds: “And to Him was given dominion, glory and a kingdom” (Daniel 7:14). Aragorn reflects the King facet of Christ: the victorious conqueror and the steadfast protector and King but also the healer and provider.
Gandalf also reflects a different aspect of Christ, one that Tolkien is very aware of and places great importance in. Tolkien speaks of the Eucatastrophe, the moment of incarnation of divine spirit into a mortal body, as the crucial moment in the true story, the one around which all other things must revolve to make sense. This great mystery is also present in the character of Gandalf who is a great and powerful spirit somehow confined and made vulnerable by a mortal frame. He too must endure the mortal experience while still being a thing alien to the restraints it brings. Echoes of Christ as the Risen savior can be found in Gandalf as well when he returns greater than ever as Gandalf the White after a great sacrifice and struggle. Jesus is described in Revelation 3:5 as “he who overcomes shall thus be clothed in white garments” which only strengthens this notion of Gandalf also reflecting that sacrificial overcoming of evil only to emerge greater than before. Also, Gandalf’s nickname as the white rider has incredible significance. Look at the passage from Helm’s deep (or recall that epic scene from the end of the Two Towers movie) where he appears with the dawn to save the day: “There suddenly appeared upon a ridge a rider, clad in white, shining in the rising sun” (The Lord of the Rings Book III Ch. VII). Revelation paints the same image of Christ: “And I saw heaven opened and behold, a white horse, and He who sat upon it is called Faithful and True” (Rev. 19:11). This beautiful and terrible description of both shows how Gandalf reflects not only the hidden glory of the incarnate Christ but also the terror and splendor of the fully revealed Christ. 

Frodo is an altogether different reflection of Christ. The best way to show this is to look at these two pictures: the first Sam holding a weary and nearly spent Frodo and the second: Mary holding her dead son in her arms.












Frodo’s journey of self-sacrifice being poured out and emptied as it were for the good of his fellow hobbits, men, dwarves, and elves is a picture in its small and humble way of the suffering of Christ as the sacrifice for the good of his fellow man. Of course, it is not in any way of the same magnitude but Frodo’s selfless journey to Mount Doom is why he succeeds, for he is not honored for destroying the ring but for sacrificing himself so that is might be destroyed. It is a beautiful reflection of the deep Truth that is the real story.
Professor Fulton-Brown was right Christ is everywhere in the story.  But it is not in an allegorical sense in that this part of the story stands for this, or this character represents Christ because of this, but in the most organic, and in my opinion beautiful, way possible. Tolkien, in setting out to make a mythology that would be able to convey Truth, naturally included the deepest truths of what he believed was the great True story. He strives for realism in his story because he wants that believability and that also applies to his themes and attributes. He creates his characters with Christ-like traits not because they are allegories for him but because these traits are fundamental truths of what constitutes a great aspirational character.

—Abe West

Éowyn: Feminist or Medievalist?

There is a contentious debate among fans and critics of J.R.R Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings, over whether or not the ‘sheildmaiden’, Éowyn, is a feminist symbol or not. Éowyn is often used as a defense of Tolkien when critics call his work ‘sexist’ or ‘misogynistic’ because Éowyn is a strong female character. She asserts strength and independence when she dresses as a man, rides into battle, and kills the Witch-king. Opponents of this defense argue she only fought out of anguish after Aragorn rejected her love. In other words, her actions were a desperate suicide mission, not a feminist flex. Additionally, she never fights again after she kills the Witch-king, instead vowing to become a ‘healer’, which critics argue is a dated female stereotype that Tolkien is pushing on one of the few female characters who seems to have countered the status quo for women in Middle Earth. 

In truth, Éowyn is not a feminist character at all. She is the manifestation of one of Tolkien’s most important and deeply Christian lessons within The Lord of the Rings. Éowyn’s story is about changing for the better and understanding the value of life. True leaders are healers not killers, and war is good only when it is just and waged for the right reasons. Those who fight out of love and duty, like the hobbits, are the real heroes.   

Théoden, Éowyn’s uncle and the King of Rohan, planned to ride into battle against Mordor, and he appointed Éowyn to be the leader of Rohan and watch over the people. Éowyn, feeling pained, rejected, and angry because her romantic feelings toward Aragorn were not reciprocated, abandoned her post. She disguised herself as a man, and rode to Minas Tirith. In battle, she challenged the Witch-King, who boasted that "no living man may hinder me". She famously removed her helmet, exposing her long blond hair, and declared, "No living man am I! You look upon a woman! Éowyn I am, Éomund's daughter. Begone if you be not deathless!" To my knowledge, these are the most assertive words to come from a woman in all of the legendarium. After her declaration, Éowyn stabbed her sword through the Witch-king's head, killing him. This was to be her last battle. 



In the House of Healing she meets Faramir, who helps her to realize how she truly felt about Aragorn, “You desired to have the love of the Lord Aragorn. Because he was high and puissant, and you wished to have renown and glory and to be lifted far above the mean things that crawl on the earth.” Faramir articulates the internal battle within Éowyn that possessed her to disobey Théoden and ride off into war. Éowyn was infatuated with Aragron. She did not love him; she loved what he represented: glory, bravery, and freedom. After Faramir helps her understand herself, she trades her idealism of death and war and replaces it with love and respect for herself and the value of life. Faramir says, “Here is the Lady Éowyn of Rohan, and now she is healed.” Ewoyn herself resolves to be a healer, “I want to be a healer, and love all things that grow and are not barren.” Glory, war, bloodshed, and pride do not make someone leader. She recognizes that being a healer makes someone a true leader. 

Does Éowyn’s shift from shieldmaiden to healer represent an archaic trope that women are ‘gentle’ healers? Does the shift within Éowyn mean she is learning to be a ‘real’ woman who now understands that her feminine role is to nurture life and not to ride off bravely into battle? The answer is no. Healer is not exclusively Éowyn’s role. The king in Lord of the Rings, Aragorn, who is the rightful heir of Isildur, is very infrequently shown in battle. Instead, Aragorn is shown from the very beginning of the story to have an ability to heal and renew through his skill and knowledge of herbs. When he heals Éowyn, Faramir, and Merry, Old Wife Ioreth proclaims to everyone, “The hands of the King are the hands of a healer!” Éowyn isn’t asserting a feminist trope by being a sheildmaiden. Tolkien maintains gender equality in Middle Earth by not making Éowyn’s story about feminism. Both men and women have the ability to kill, to engage in battle, and to seek out glory. The question is not can she, it is should she. Should anyone fight for the sake of fighting? Additionally the role of leader is not exclusive to men. A leader is a healer and both Aragron and Éowyn, male and female, are healers.

Of course, this is not to say that war is always wrong. The Catholic Church teaches that although we should avoid war, there is such a thing as a ‘just war’. A war is just once all attempts of peace have been exhausted. Just wars are never waged for the sake of glory. They are only utilized when one's community and/or nation is in great danger and one is trying to eliminate a grave evil. Tolkien understood the horror of war, having served in World War I and having had several friends die in it. He also understood that while war is horrific, it can be necessary. Faramir said in The Two Towers,“War must be, while we defend our lives against a destroyer who would devour all; but I do not love the bright sword for its sharpness, nor the arrow for its swiftness, nor the warrior for his glory. I love only that which they defend.”

The true heroes are the hobbits who were thrust into conflict. Hobbits are unexpected protagonists in this epic, magical, and dark world. They are so small that they are mostly unknown, even in the Elves’ records. They live peacefully in the Shire removed from most of Middle Earth. They are not in the great legends of the days of valor. There are no songs sung about them in the great halls of Rohan or Gondor. However, there is no mistake on the part of J.R.R. Tolkien when he made these tiny men the true essence of courage and honor in The Lord of the Rings. The hobbits didn’t seek out power or honor in battle. They are simple halflings -  totally loveable, relatable, and unsuspecting. Frodo accepted the ring because no one else would. He knew the risks, but accepted the burden out of the goodness of his heart. Merry, Pippin, and Sam join Frodo out of love for him. Tolkien once said, “We are here surviving because of the courage of small people against impossible odds.”

Even though Tolkien did not make allegories he couldn’t help but reveal greater truths about life and humanity through the prism of his Catholic faith. In letter 131 he writes, “I dislike Allegory – the conscious and intentional.” He admits in letter 142 that The Lord of the Rings, “is a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision” and the “religious element is absorbed into the story and the symbolism”. Truly the Church’s teachings on war are ingrained in The Lord of the Rings. When war is necessary people must use it, but it should never be waged for the sake of personal glory. This is why the story is centered around the hobbits who are perfect little heroes. They didn’t choose to go on the journey because they were seeking out honor. Frodo does it because no one else will, and his friends join him out of love for him. Éowyn is not a feminist icon, but a broken person. She goes from being prideful, unsatisfied, impulsive, and reckless, to a person who loves and values life and her duty as a princess and leader. As a woman she is capable of fighting, just like a man, but she realizes in the end that she should be a healer to her people. Just as Aragorn the king in The Lord if the Rings is a healer not a killer, so too is the King of Kings, Jesus Christ, "Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy and my burden is light."

~Evita 

Lest we despair, Tolkien

It is tempting to dwell on Tolkien’s medieval side and go down the hobbit hole of his work and of what he would have read - Kalevala, Beowulf, Sir Orfeo and the list goes on – to try to get a glimpse, hoping for more of course, of that lost odd world where man wrote and passed on these grand stories of impossible quests, dragons and curses, and bejeweled the bones of saints and wrought rich monstrances for the Body of Christ who himself protagonized the eucatastrophe of a story. But that might lead one to miss an important aspect of Tolkien’s work, how well he bridges the gap between the medieval tradition he is drawing from and his modern readers, and how aware he is of modern sensibilities. Indeed, through this bridging of the old traditions to our time and his awareness of the struggles of modern men, Tolkien gives us a great gift: a reflection on suffering, death and, ultimately, hope. Starting with the story we all know, The Lord of the Rings, I will show how Tolkien’s awareness of modern sentiment informs his tale and invites the reader to reflect on suffering and death. 

We first consider Aragorn and Frodo, two heroes in their own right. Aragorn is the hero that stands tall above, quite literally, both hobbit and regular man. Coming from the shadows and with his half-elven ancestry, Aragorn is foreign. On the other hand, Frodo is not foreign to us. Frodo is the little man ‘alive in the films of Chaplin as he is in Chaucer’ that we can identify with. (T.C, p.124) What Tolkien does to these two heroes accommodates his tale for an age that can no longer stomach the supernatural and mythological very well. On one hand, although Aragorn reminds us of many earlier larger-than-life heroes via divers motifs – for example, from his superhuman ancestry, the likes of Sigurd fathered by Odin; from his time in obscurity and from his relationship with Narsil, Beowulf – Tolkien takes care that modern readers are not pushed away. He provides more realistic basis for Aragorn’s ancestry than that of his predecessors, for example Sigurd, who were fathered by gods. Aragorn’s ancestry is thus still noble and ‘immortal’, but ‘no god’s intervention, no magic, … or supernatural event’ are behind it; it’s rather that he is half-elven through the union of two natural races. (T.C, p.126) Creating Aragorn in a great lineage of heroes larger than oneself, Tolkien doesn’t forget to bridge the gap between our modern minds and the mythological where that divide would be too detrimental to his goal, ‘the realization of imagined wonder.’ (F.S, p.14) On the other hand, although Frodo is closer to us, Tolkien doesn’t leave it at that and ennobles him by linking him to mythological motifs. One of these is seen in Frodo’s relationship to Bilbo, the nephew-uncle motif present in Beowulf, where the nephew takes to conclusion something initiated by the uncle. And, perhaps more importantly, Frodo’s orphancy echoes that mysterious child motif seen in splendor in the story of Scyld, a.k.a Frodi, who brings prosperity. Creating Frodo as a common man, Tolkien ennobles both Frodo and the common man through the mythological associations and, specially, in his role as bringer of prosperity, although he himself doesn’t share in this prosperity. By giving mythological importance to Frodo, Tolkien thus raises us closer to Aragorn's greatness, who on his own was already made more believable. Also worth of notice is Tolkien’s modernization of the battle ‘against the offspring of the dark which ends for all in defeat.’ (Monsters, p.29) As Flieger describes it as it happens in TheLord of The Rings, ‘fighting those dark elements within himself which Gollum externalizes, Frodo fights the most insidious monster of all - and loses.’ (T.C, p.144) Rather than choosing a too-much-to-swallow of a dragon, Tolkien chose a struggle his modern audience would accept without a struggle. Frodo’s struggle and subsequent failure is all too much familiar, which together with the successful ‘realization of imagined wonder’ around him and his mythological importance as bringer of prosperity begs the practical-minded modern man to reconsider whether sacrifice is worthless after all. But how does Frodo bring prosperity if not by failing? It is not fair that Frodo should suffer! one could answer. Tolkien might well agree with this, but he would then point us to the gift of death.

In Tolkien’s legendarium death is central to both its stories and philosophy. It’s but through death and successive generations that the stories take place. Death is Eru’s gift to man. It’s malice that leads man to think otherwise. While elves are bound to this world to its end, man can escape the pains found here on earth by accepting death. Although it’s without guarantees, death releases man from his bondage to earth. In Numenor, those who didn’t willingly accept their deaths when the time came and postponed it were seen as doing wrong. The epitome of not accepting death can be seen in Ar Pharazon’s foolish search for immortality that led to the Downfall of Numenor. On the other hand, Aragorn accepts death. Indeed, his death recalls us of the Ars Moriendi, the instructions for a good Christian to die well. He rejects despair and gives away his earthly riches, in the crown of Gondor, to Eldarion. Tolkien’s thus illustrates the necessity to die well, to accept ‘hope without guarantees.’ (Letters, 237) To further this point, we look at the great philosophical debate of the Legendarium: Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth. Finrod, discussing the place of man’s mortality in Eru’s creation with Andreth, raises the point that man is in a constant restlessness in Arda: they ‘look at no thing for itself’ … Where are these other things?’ In further discussion, they reach that man has in this way a sort of vision of Eru’s plan. And questioned by Andreth whereto man should now go, ‘'What then is to be done now? … darkness lies before us, into which we stare in vain,’ Finrod proposes hope, and again, without guarantees. Tolkien expounds on the preciousness of dying well, without relinquishing hope. For man, death is in his nature, it’s foolish and perilous to fight it, all he can have is hope: hope in the One who gave man the gift of death.

Although we might be no Aragorn, hope is found in the fact that small hands can and do turn the wheels of the world as Elrond reminds us. In Frodo, Tolkien raises our littleness and our sacrifice to great worth. Suffering exists and one might incur in it even if ‘unfair’, but it’s far from pointless: Frodo’s breaking down gained great prosperity for Middle Earth. What Tolkien offers is not a remedy for our earthly sorrows, but hope. Indeed, hope without guarantees, but nonetheless: as our restlessness in Arda points us ever to an unreasonable joy beyond the confines of Ëa, may we delight in the ‘thought of regions where pain and delight flow together and tears are the very wine of blessedness’ and hope that one day we are

                                        ‘Over death, over dread, over doom lifted
                                        Out of loss, out of life, unto long glory.’ (LOTR, Many Partings)


PT

Cited Work:
Zimbardo, Rose A., and Neil D. Isaacs. Understanding The lord of the rings : the best of Tolkien criticism. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2004
Tolkien, J. R. R., Humphrey Carpenter, and Christopher Tolkien. The letters of J.R.R. Tolkien. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1981.
Tolkien, J. R. R., Verlyn Flieger, and Douglas A. Anderson. Tolkien on fairy-stories. London: HarperCollinsPublishers, 2014.
Tolkien, J. R. R., and Christopher Tolkien. The monsters and the critics, and other essays. London: HarperCollins, 1997.

Love Thy Neighbor

            An undeniable main theme of The Lord of the Rings is love. In Tolkien’s work, we see a multitude of types of love. There is romantic love, best seen between Aragorn and Arwen, but also as Eowyn’s unrequited love of Aragorn transitions into loving Faramir. There is familial love, best depicted by Frodo and Bilbo. But there is also the love of nature, embodied by Yavanna in The Silmarillion as well as Treebeard, and the love of things in addition to the love of the self through Gollum: “[Gollum] hated [The Ring] and loved it, as he hated and loved himself”(Fellowship of the Ring). I think, however, that the primary form of love in The Lord of the Rings is the love that exists between Frodo and Sam, or at the very least the love that Sam has for Frodo. At the simplest level, Tolkien uses Sam to depict a thoughtful and incredibly kind friend as well as an exemplary servant. Sam would do quite literally anything in his power for Frodo because, depending on your reading of Mordor, he actually goes through hell and back for his master. Anyone would incredibly fortunate to be on the receiving end of this type of friendship, but like with everything that Tolkien writes, I believe it is a little more nuanced than just a plain, touching friendship.
            When Frodo begins his journey, Sam definitely accompanies him out of love, but also maybe due to some feeling of responsibility. Sam’s entry into the story comes directly from his role as the Baggins’ gardener, but when he hears that Frodo will be leaving, he choked, telling Gandalf “I tried not to sir, but it burst out of me: I was so upset”(FoTR). As the son of the Baggins’s gardener, and then serving in that role himself, Sam undoubtedly was able to grow close to Frodo, and it’s exactly the mixing of his friendship with Frodo and his role as a servant that can be seen in his entry into the quest. I do believe that any sort of responsibility Sam feels is directly related to his love of his master, because there is also a responsibility placed on him as a friend. He is expected to help and love his friend to the best of his ability.
As the quest begins, Sam falls perfectly into his already established roll as Frodo’s servant, which perpetuates the inequality in their statuses. He carries more than his fair share and is quick to try and ease Frodo’s physical burden: “’I could take a lot more yet, sir. My packet is quite light,’ said Sam stoutly and untruthfully”(FoTR). And indeed throughout the entire journey, Sam continues to serve Mr. Frodo. However, the journey that Frodo and Sam take is surely transformative, if only in the relationship that they have between them. The love that they have between them transforms from the conventional servant-master relationship to become a more brotherly love.
            I think what makes their relationship so touching is the deep, intimate male bonding that occurs because of the quest. The difficulty of their journey, having to journey through literal hell towards the end, is an intense bonding experience that builds on their already existing close relationship. There is a scene in The Return of the King that exemplifies this really well. After rescuing Frodo from the orc-tower, Sam and Frodo divest themselves of all the items they would not need on the rest of the journey to Mount Doom. Unsurprisingly, Sam has a difficult time parting with everything that he had packed. Even though they were just common items that he had brought from the Shire, “each of them had become dear to him, if only because he had borne them so far with so much toil… Tears welled in his eyes at the thought of casting it away” (RoTK). Throughout the story, Sam has been sentimental and emotional, so forming an attachment to inanimate objects fits right in line with his character. But this is only more telling of how the journey has intensified his feelings for Frodo. And in the end, Sam adopts an almost motherly role towards Frodo. After rescuing Frodo, Sam “half lifted his master and hugged him to his breast”(RoTK), he let Frodo “lay back in [his] gentle arms, closing his eyes, like a child at rest when night-fears are driven away by some loved voice”(RoTK), and he even kisses Frodo’s forehead. When he brings Frodo orc garments, Sam in some sense dresses Frodo, and even has Frodo sleep on his lap.
            What I mean to say is that their servant-master relationship develops into something deeply intimate, and could be read in some ways as romantic. However, I do think that Tolkien points to differences between romantic love and the intense brotherly love between Sam and Frodo by including Rosie. While Sam has very deep love for Frodo, it is not a romantic love because Sam eventually marries Rosie. This, however, doesn’t dampen the relationship between Sam and Frodo in anyway whatsoever. In fact, I think that what makes their relationship so notable is that I don’t think it’s very common to see a portrayal of a close male friendship without anything frivolous. There are no obscene jokes to undercut the relationship to make it more palatable for audiences, just two men who really care for each other. What makes it even more powerful is Sam’s apparent lack of expectations from Frodo. It doesn’t seem like there is any expectation on Sam’s part for this tender treatment to be reciprocated. Granted, this might be due to Sam’s status as Frodo’s servant, so Frodo is not expected to care for Sam like Sam cares for him. Nonetheless, Sam is continues to be devoted and loving, even after Frodo’s treatment of him on the Stairs of Cirith Ungol.
            Additionally, something that’s interesting about Frodo and Sam is that they really embody a deeply Christian sentiment: “Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself”(King James Bible, Matthew 22:39). Sam sacrifices his own safety and is prepared to spend his life to save his master and friend. Indeed, Sam regularly demonstrates that he isn’t concerned with recognition for himself as he repeats how famous Frodo will become after the quest to destroy The Ring. But it’s in his meekness that Sam shines, for “blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the Earth” ”(King James Bible, Matthew 5:5). And Sam does go on to inherit the Earth, in some sense. He inherits what used to be his whole world: he becomes mayor of the Shire. If we were ever to look for an example besides Jesus of how to truly be selfless, I argue we should look to Sam. I’m not trying to argue that Sam is perfect, for he is mortal, but he repeatedly puts others before himself.

- NP