Thursday, June 4, 2020

Two Green Beards

The Important Takeaways from Comparing The Green Knight and Treebeard

Tolkien took plenty of inspiration for Treebeard directly from Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Meeting both characters plunges the others instantly into Faerie, completely overwhelming everything that had happened to them before. Both are old, mysterious, and it is unclear whether they are friend or foe at first. The green knight has "a big beard like a bush over his breast hanging", which Tolkien directly references with the name Treebeard. 
Some of the immediate differences are important too. While the Green Knight is, well, green, there is limited nature imagery at least at first. Treebeard on the other hand is the forest itself. The degree of shock for the other characters is similar though. Arthur’s Christmas feast is suddenly much less frivolous, and Merry and Pippin’s journey through the wild now forces them to face sentient Fangorn itself.
Both of their eyes are noted to be remarkable. Pippin described Treebeard’s this way: "One felt as if there was an enormous well behind them, filled up with ages of memory and long, slow, steady thinking; but their surface was sparkling with the present: like sun shimmering on the outer leaves of a vast tree, or on the ripples of a very deep lake". The Green Knight’s "glance was as lighting bright". The Green Knight is the present - the hasty part of Freeboard that can sometimes be roused. Some might say that Treebeard’s eyes are a representation of Eru’s fire of creation itself. They hold memory, and in them the past interacts with the present and is at peace. Both pairs of eyes are unusual, supernatural even.
Everyone who saw the Green Knight immediately noted his immense strength and weapon, whereas it took Merry and Pippin quite a while to understand the great strength of the Ents, although they did fear the forest at first. Initially, everyone feared both of these characters. However, they both turn into a respected ally, either in the fight against Saruman and Sauron, or in the quest to become a better Christian. They are still feared, and still dangerous by the end of the story. 
The most important similarity between the two is that they themselves change very little, while the environment around them and the characters who interact with them are changed significantly, and for the better. This is why they are both "good" characters. The Green Knight is frightening, even barbaric to the original audience of the story, but Sir Gawain’s character development and the Green Knight’s knowledge of Christianity leave the reader feeling much more positive toward him than if he was only there to accomplish Morgan le Fay’s plan to hurt Guinevere. Treebeard is still part of Fangorn, which is definitely dangerous, and the ents took plenty of convincing to help destroy Isengard, and even Galadriel warned the fellowship about the forest. And yet his is decidedly on the good side not just because of the destruction of Isengard, but because this is a turning point for Merry and Pippin. They go from baggage that eats way too much food, to being movers of the great events of the war. I don’t remember any subsequent stories of Gawain, but before challenging the Green Knight he was kind of useless, and he certainly needed much courage to follow through with the second encounter. (On a side note, I was very surprised to see the Green Knight portrayed as an absolute monster in the trailer for the upcoming movie, as the grey area is what makes the story interesting.)
Tolkien still manages to make an immense contrast without diminishing Merry and Pippin. They are saplings who don’t know very much about the world, but Treebeard treats them as young entings and helps them grow, even forgetting that they are hobbits at one point. When they drink the ent draught, "the hair on their heads was actually standing up, waving and curling and growing", like the uppermost leaves of a plant that has just been watered. They grow physically. They also grow mentally. Until now, the story has not truly described the horrors of Sauron’s work. The Black Riders have terrorized the Shire, and Gandalf fell in Moria, but Merry and Pippin, and therefore the readers, remain relatively ignorant of what the growing Shadow means for normal civilians. The destruction of the forest is put in a new light because Treebeard can speak to the trees and raised some of them. Tolkien is noting an important aspect of war that is often forgotten, and which became abundantly clear in World War 1. The casualties are not limited to the battlefield, but history and legend tends to care about important battles and kings. The people who are caught in the middle, whose ordinary wonderful lives, at least in Tolkien’s writing, are just as important, it not more important, than the war itself. And those who get taken over for resources to fuel the war die in a different way. I am not trying to say that this is allegory. This portion of The Two Towers can also be said to represent the need to respect the dwindling wild places of the world, or the power of a people to rise up in unison and throw down their oppressor. However, this particular metaphor is relevant to the Green Knight story, where Sir Gawain’s actions with Morgan, whom he thought was just a normal person at the time, ended up saving his life. 

Cult transcending culture: a global religion for (at least some of) the peoples of Middle Earth

 “Cult” has spooky undertones, but, according to the tomes of Merriam and Webster, in its earliest English sense it just means worship. It comes from the Latin root colo (colere, colui, cultus), literally agricultural cultivation. Colo apparently already took on the secondary meaning of religious devotion in antiquity, along with another alternative meaning of education, which may be the one that gives rise to our word “culture.” While culture can literally mean the fine tastes resulting from education, the sense that I find more common and which I’m interested in exploring in relation to cult is as a constellation of linguistic, artistic, and technological features that give identity to a group of individuals, often in close geographic proximity to one another. That’s the type of culture we might refer to in “French culture” or infamously “Self, Culture, and Society.” “Popular culture” and “internet culture” are pushing the envelope a little, but they can fall into this category as well.

Cult as a convention of worship and culture as a collection of conventions come together as two related aspects of communities of people. Worship is communal, even in cases of private devotion. Ascetics, like Catholic anchoresses, rely on outside supporters to bring them food and, in some religions, to fulfill communal rituals like Communion. Personal prayers that diverge from liturgy still have to adhere to a communally established religious paradigm, which may be more or less strict in its tolerance for originality—semantics of worship can be especially important in Nicene Christianity, where terminological distinctions like homoiousios vs. homoousios and adore vs. venerate are the difference between heresy and orthodox practice. Cults of worship are themselves the collections of these phrases and practices, implicitly built on religious beliefs, held to be valid by a community of coreligionists. While these may often aspire towards universal truth, they are distinctly channeled through the cultural features of their community, expressed through particular languages, in particular artistic and architectural mediums, and with particular understandings of social order and the cosmos.

I want to situate Tolkien’s approach to religion between the two opposing poles of cultural specificity and theological universality. In most respects, Tolkien highly values cultural heterogeneity. In one of his wartime letters to Christopher Tolkien, he bemoans globalization’s effect of destroying the interesting things about the world: “The bigger things get the smaller and duller or flatter the globe gets. It is getting to be all one blasted little provincial suburb… But seriously: I do find this Americo-cosmopolitanism very terrifying.” (Letters, n. 53). He specifically views linguistic homogenization as a problem, and only half-jokingly wishes for a second Tower of Babel—a very interesting reframing of a Biblical curse to suggest that linguistic diversity has religious value or might even be an ideal.

While Tolkien certainly doesn’t want everyone speaking in English, he might want everyone praying in Latin. In line with his Catholic faith, religious universality is very important to Tolkien. In a 1968 letter drafted to his son Michael, Tolkien reflected on the aftermath of the groundbreaking Second Vatican Council and Pope Paul VI’s continued reforms. While the 70-year-old Tolkien found many of the changes frustrating, he writes: “I find myself in sympathy with those developments that are strictly ‘ecumenical,’ that is concerned with other groups or churches that call themselves (and often truly are) ‘Christian’. We have prayed endlessly for a Christian reunion, but it is difficult to see, if one reflects, how that could possibly come about except as it has, with all its inevitable minor absurdities.” (Letters, n. 306). “Catholic” literally means universal and the early ecumenical councils were so-called because they attempted to settle on religious doctrines for the entire world. The Greek concept of “oikomene” referring to the entire inhabited world is actually similar to Germanic variants of “Midgard,” which Tolkien draws his Middle-Earth from. Overall, Tolkien’s sympathies are very much in the traditional Catholic direction of one unified religion for the entire world, though he does tolerate “minor absurdities” that color variant groups that still follow the important universal ideals.

The religious dimension of Middle-Earth is subtle and almost entirely lacks rituals or clerical structures, but Tolkien still imbues it with the ideal of a universal cult of worship, transcending cultural differences. In Book III, “The Departure of Boromir,” Aragorn and Legolas join together to improvise a poetic eulogy for the fallen Gondorian warrior, joining together their cultures and races in a single act of “worship”: “The West Wind comes walking, and about the walls it goes/…/From the mouths of the Sea the South Wind flies…” (Houghton-Mifflin p. 417). Interestingly, Gimli declines to take part, which Aragorn anticipates by not giving him a chance to recite a third and final stanza. I’m not sure exactly what to make of that, but it does seem to suggest that dwarves are in some way excluded from the “true religion” of elves and men despite the apparent universalizing ideal—perhaps related to their illicit creation by Aulë, recounted in the Silmarilion, and their exclusion from the special divine connection that elves and men have as Children of Illuvatar. Gimli is allowed to sail to Valinor with Legolas at the end of the book though, pretty much the highest form of divine approval! This case does show religious unity across particulars between Aragorn and Legolas at least, especially as their alternating stanzas mesh perfectly with one another and don’t really bear marks of either of their authorship (of course Tolkien actually wrote all of the stanzas).

Due to the exclusion of dwarves, the above case might fall short of being fully “ecumenical.” The strongest thrust for a totally Middle-Global cult of worship comes right at the denouement of the story, when Sam and Frodo have achieved their quest of seeing the Ring destroyed at Mount Doom. The day of Sauron’s defeat becomes Middle Earth’s closest equivalent to a religious holiday, and all the “good guys” of the story come together to praise the Hobbits’ brave actions together. Aragorn, as the newly enthroned leader of the western world, calls forth a minstrel, who delivers an address about the Hobbits like a Bible sermon: “‘Lo! lords and knights and men of valour unashamed, kings and princes, and fair people of Gondor, and Riders of Rohan, and ye sons of Eldron, and Dúnedain of the North, and Elf and Dwarf, and greathearts of the Shire, and all free folk of the West, now listen to my lay. For I will sing of Frodo of the Nine Fingers and the Ring of Doom.’” (Houghton-Mifflin p. 954). This fulfills Sam’s hopes that their actions will become a story with a happy ending. Interestingly, almost all the “good guys” we’ve encountered through the book are here participating as listeners: including multiple types of elves and men, along with hobbits and dwarves. We are missing Eagles and Ents, but those cases can be excused since the Eagles had just left Minas Tirith and it would have taken the Ents forever to walk there from Isengard. With the outer story of Lord of the Rings coming to a happy conclusion, Tolkien’s rosy ideal of complete religious union also comes into shape.

As a digression, I want to reflect on my own perspective on religious universality and cultural specificity as an observant Jew. One well-known area where we diverge from Christianity is in our lesser emphasis on universality. We also believe in one God for the entire world—that’s arguably the most important part of the religion—but we embrace the cultural trappings of our particular relationship with God as essential to Judaism. We view the Bible’s commandments as specifically aimed at us as a cultural unit (some of the words used in the Bible for its concept of nationhood are עם, גוי, לשון, and specifically to the Jewish people בני ישראל , and עברים). Those rules are not obligatory for members of other “nations,” with the exception of the seven Noahide laws, which are mostly common sense like not murdering. We see many of our customs as sacred as well as culturally native, like the Hebrew language, Kosher food, and the calendar of holidays. I think Tolkien’s aesthetic appreciation of cultural quirks aligns with my own appreciation of the many forms of native religion, diverse “cults of worship” to the same divinity, that can arise when religious forms are brought more towards the specific rather than the universal. The “flavor” of religion comes from all the wacky details! Despite Catholicism’s inclination to the universal, it certainly has rich particulars as well, accumulated over 2000 years of history and manifested in different cultural forms for, say, Ireland and Mexico.

-Daniel Steinberg

Wednesday, June 3, 2020

Elves worship as elves, Man as man and Hobbits as ?

 I believe most of us would make good hobbits. Indeed, it’s not for no reason that Tolkien presents this story from the view of the Hobbits, they are the race we can most readily identify with: they do not seem all that honorable like Numenoreans, nor vicious like orcs, nor all that down to gain military glory like some man in Middle Earth. Hobbits like good tiled earth, good pipe-weed, good celebrations, good food and they generally like to be left to themselves: think of Bilbo at the beginning of the Hobbit who just wanted to have yet another day of drinking tea and sorting his house affairs. Being insular in their nature, they had little contact with ‘queer folk’ and had thus little, or rather no knowledge of the worship practices of Middle Earth. Outside folk had also forgotten about the hobbits. But were Hobbits sinful and had they no appreciation for creation? What of this changes with the destruction of the ring and the Scourging of the Shire?

Are Hobbits lazy like Saruman and his ruffians thought? As the prologue to The Lord of the Rings says, they did not like complicated machinery although they were skillful with their hands. They do like good food, good beer, good pipe-weed and seem to favor tea over climbing trees, but I don’t think we have textual evidence that they are generally actually lazy – as I once thought. Hobbits just didn’t fall for the regime of ‘total-work’ Pieper describes as being the norm in the modern world and this seems to be compatible with the association of the Shire with rural England. Indeed, I think we ought to see their natural tendency to comfort as not wholly evil. Although this isolates them from the outside world and its worship practices, Hobbits also end up preserving a taste for leisure and saw work as a means for life rather than the other way around. One can think that because of their size and the strength of others, maybe it was for the best that Hobbits – who, descending from pre-Numenorean man, might not have had more intentional worship in the first place – isolated themselves since that allowed them to preserve at least their leisurely life. Hobbits’ non-dominating attitude towards nature, their appreciation of nature and leisure are rustic forms of appreciating creation, although not particularly conscious of the transcendental origin of nature and leisure. In this way, I think it’s fair to say that, to some extent, in The Lord of the Rings their love of food and parties, for instance, is not for the sake of their work, that it’s also a contemplative celebration of the ale brewed, the pipe-weed grown and an attitude of not being busy, which is in Aristotle and Medieval Christianity seen as proper leisure and fundamental in itself for man’s life. (Leisure, p.64, 67, 69) But, Hobbits’ leisure is not faultless, indeed, their lack of conscious worship would be an important shortcoming in their leisure following Pieper’s ideas. Now, we move to what the War of the Rings accomplished for the Shire and how that impacts their worship, and consequently leisure.

From both the prologue and the last few books of The Lord of the Rings we can see that the four Hobbits are both acknowledged, for instance, by Gondor for their deeds and thus put their race on the map so to speak. Ioreth recognizes their worth, ‘they are small, but they are valiant,’ and in Frodo, Sam, Pippin and Merry, the halfings are praised: ‘Long live the Halflings!’ (LOTR, Steward and The King) In their worship, ‘fulfilling the chief purpose of life’, Gondor would call on all created things to join in their chorus, ‘all mountains and hills, all orchards and forests, all things that creep and birds on the wing’ and halflings. (Sanct. Myth, p.10) In this way already, halflings are part of the ‘church militant’ of middle earth that one is united to when praising God and the splendor of creation. But is this true from the Shire-folk’s perspective, that they are more united in worship to the outside world after the War of the Ring? In class, we explored the idea that, indeed, they are. It’s clear that the hobbits that went on the quest of the ring are drawn out of the shire and towards man’s and elvish worship of creation. Maybe the clearest example is that of Frodo and Sam who adopt throughout their travel into Mordor the elvish practice of invoking Elbereth and experience first-hand the power of prayer, and also when Frodo replies to Faramir that hobbits have no custom akin to that of looking towards Numenor before meals, Frodo feels ‘strangely rustic and untutored’ and joins them. In the persons of Frodo, Merry, Pippin and Sam, the Shire joins the wider practices of worship and praise in Middle Earth. But does it stop there? No, the events of the War of the Ring, specially the Battle of Bywater, bring the outside world to the Shire. Not only do these awaken in the Hobbits a desire to write down their traditions, ‘the greater families were also concerned with events in the Kingdom at large, and many of their members studied its ancient histories and legends,’ which might be seen as a door to praising the deeds of Men and Elves and consequently to calling on them to join the Shire’s chorus in praising the splendor of creation. Additionally, those that fought in the Battle of Bywater had in that joined Aragorn’s, Gimli’s and Legola’s rejection of the evil of Sauron and proclaimed the greatness of unmarred and well-tended creation. Those who died had a martyr’s death. An important difficulty in this view that the Shire is brought into communion with the rest of Middle Earth is discussed below.

But the Shire-folk at large seemingly didn’t change their habbits with the Scourging of the Shire and the destruction of the Ring. They continue keen in their love of celebrations, ale, pipe-weed and at the same time they do not invoke or sing of Elbereth, and, as far as the text goes, do not say grace before eating. So, the extent to which the four hobbits’ experience of these and other forms of worship in the outside world impact the Shire is at first glance limited. This seeming failure of the Hobbits to save the Shire from ignorance of worship has been explored in a previous post that partially called into question the reading we did in class of the hobbit’s travel as a pilgrimage that connected their people to the worshipful world outside the Shire. There a proposition is made: we don’t need to lose our Hobbit-ness to worship. This is getting at an important thing the Scourging of the Shire and the destruction of the ring accomplish for the Shire-folk. Their leisure is sanctified. In the reconstruction of the Shire, they are doing God’s work more intentionally; they are actively choosing for the good and the beautiful against the evil that Saruman brought. And so, when resting, I can only imagine that they will all the more look at Creation and say: it is Good, a contemplative celebration which Pieper – not Pippin – points out as one of the essential attitudes of leisure. (Leisure, p.68) In learning about and praising Merry and Pippin’s adventures in parties, the Hobbits will be praising their and the fellowship’s great virtuous deeds and, in a way, they will be praising proto-saints or at least proto-apostles.  If not of Christ’s passion, their deeds can be seen as at least a prefigurement of the early Christians fighting the ‘good fight.’ So even if the Shire didn’t, or couldn’t, adopt the elvish praise of Elebereth and their lembas, nor Gondor’s saying grace, their leisure was sanctified so that it constitutes not lazyness or praise of a good, quiet material life, but a more conscious praising of the good, beautiful and the truth in creation. 

Hobbits worship as Hobbits, not as elves or man. Going to Gondor, Rohan, Lothlorien and Mordor, and these coming to the Shire, the fellowship united their people with the outside world in worship. But, they are in communion with middle earth not because they worship in the same way as other peoples, but because at the end of the day they worship the same One, which in the primary reality is the God of the sabbath.


-PT

Works Cited:

Pieper, Josef. Leisure : the basis of culture ; The philosophical act. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2009. Print.
Birzer, Bradley J. J.R.R. Tolkien's sanctifying myth : understanding Middle-earth. Wilmington, Del: ISI Book, 2003. Print.
Tolkien, J. R. R., and Douglas A. Anderson. The Hobbit and the lord of the rings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2014. Print.

Hobbits, Humans, and the Meaning of Life

The Lord of the Rings follows the adventures, struggles, successes, and failures of the unlikely little Hobbit heroes. Hobbits are not particularly remarkable. They eat a lot and tend to be fat, they love to laugh, and enjoy living comfortably. They prefer to live quiet and static lives, remaining almost entirely unknown by most in Middle Earth. Not only do Hobbits avoid adventure, they actually disdain it. Bilbo Baggins was one of the only Hobbits in recent memory to have gone on an adventure, and he was considered by most of the Shire folk to be “queer”. Just as the world didn’t know much about Hobbits, likewise the Hobbits did not know much about the world. 

As a rule, adventures are disdained by Hobbits because they are unknown, scary, and can ruin one’s reputation. They also have the added inconvenience of potentially disrupting a Hobbit’s ideal meal schedule, something both Bilbo and Sam complained about. It takes a lot to get a Hobbit to agree to embark on an adventure. For Bilbo, it took significant blows to his pride before he agreed to go on the Quest of Erebor, and even then, he spent considerable time on his journey pining for the comforts of his Hobbit hole. Only after learning that the fate of the world literally rested on his shoulders did Froo join the Fellowship and embark on a journey to Mordor.   Though destroying the ring was a seemingly impossible task,  he accepted the ring out of duty and the goodness of his heart. Tolkien wrote, “It seems clear to me that Frodo’s duty was ‘humane’... the quest had as its object… the liberation from an evil tyranny of all the ‘humane’”.  Merry and Pippin insist on joining Frodo only because they are his friends, they love him, and want him to be safe. When Frodo is trying to go to Mordor alone at the end of the Fellowship of the Ring, Sam does the same: “‘It would be the death of you to come with me, Sam,’ said Frodo…  ‘I know that well enough, Mr. Frodo… And I'm coming with you.’” 

Tolkien writes, “Mine is not an ‘imaginary’ world, but an imaginary historical moment on ‘Middle-earth’ – which is our habitation.” In other words, their world is our world and just like the Hobbits, humans tend to accept a mundane life. People are inclined to live out routines and go through life just checking off boxes. This, however, is not how we are meant to live. “The opposite of holiness is not, first and foremost, a life of sin, so much as settling for a bland and mediocre existence.” 

Both The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, contain themes about the value of humans departing from their routine and resolving to live radical and holy lives. Saint Francis de Sales said, “All of us can attain to Christian virtue and holiness, no matter what condition of life we live and no matter what our life work may be.”... Likewise Tolkien wrote:“For if there is anything in a journey of any length, for me it is this: a deliverance from the plantlike state of helpless passive sufferer, an exercise however small of will, and mobility”. 

Once people start to move out of their comfort zone and embark on the figurative and uncomfortable journey toward holiness, only then they can find their purpose in life. Tolkien explains, “So it may be said that the chief purpose of life, for any one of us, is to increase according to our capacity, our knowledge of God by all the means we have, and to be moved by it to praise and thanks.”  A purposeful life rejects the mundane and embraces the supernatural and the sacred so we can be closer to Christ. Once we resolve to go on the saintly journey, our lives will be forever changed, just as the Hobbits were never the same after they rejected their dim and routine lives in the Shire. 

The Bilbo we meet in The Lord of the Rings is interesting and exciting.  He is an Elf friend, poet, linguist, wielder of the ring of power, master negotiator, and a warrior.  This Bilbo is far different from the Bilbo we met earlier in The Hobbit before his life-changing adventure. The pre-quest Bilbo was frightened when an eccentric wizard thrust him into a wild escapade where he encountered over a dozen dwarves, evil Trolls, noble Elves, terrifying spiders, and treasures guarded by a ferocious dragon. Though he reluctantly agrees to join the quest (partly out of pride) the quest transforms him. At the end of The Hobbit, Gandalf notes, “You've changed, Bilbo Baggins. You're not the same Hobbit as the one who left the Shire…”. Likewise, Pippin and Merry literally grow taller, after drinking Ent-draughts, symbolic of their character growth. As the story develops, Sam also changes, namely his love for Frodo intensifies. He drives the mission forward by saving Frodo from Shelob, and makes key decisions, like leaving their things behind in the final chapter of their journey to Mordor. He even resolves, at the end, to carry Frodo, despite realizing that once he reaches the top of Mount Doom he may never come back: “‘Come, Mr. Frodo!' he cried. 'I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you.’”

Merry, Pippin, Bilbo, and Sam experience positive character development and achievements. Frodo, however, has a serious lapse of judgement when he fails to destroy the ring, keeping it for himself instead. Eventually, the ring is destroyed, but Frodo’s failure to destroy it himself speaks to our human condition.  If we make the courageous decision to strive for holiness, we will have failures, and that’s okay. Frodo, despite failing, bore the ring all the way to Mount Doom. Without his efforts, the ring would never have been destroyed. As humans, we know we can never be perfect, but we can strive for saintliness, and in the end trying is better than doing nothing.  

Frodo endures much suffering and he is forever changed by quest to Mordor. Similarly, we should also expect suffering in our lives.  Suffering is never in vain because suffering unites us to others and most importantly, to our Lord’s suffering and passion. Christ never promised us comfort on Earth which is why Saint Paul wrote, “...be self-possessed in all circumstances; put up with hardship; perform the work of an evangelist; fulfill your ministry.” (2 Timothy 4:3-7) Sam recognized the darkness and tragedy that is the reality of human life in his speech to Frodo on the way to Mordor, “It’s like in the great stories Mr. Frodo. The ones that really mattered. Full of darkness and danger they were, and sometimes you didn’t want to know the end. Because how could the end be happy? How could the world go back to the way it was when so much bad happened. But in the end, it’s only a passing thing, this shadow. Even darkness must pass. A new day will come. And when the sun shines it will shine out the clearer.” That is the promise Christ makes us: everlasting life with him in heaven. He conquered the darkness. He conquered death. On the cross he promised the good thief that that very day he could be with him in paradise.  Three days later, through his resurrection he promised those who love and follow Him that they too will join Him in paradise, where we will bask in His glorious light and be relieved of all the  suffering and hardships of our earthly journey. 
The Lord of the Rings is, as Tolkien said, “a fundamentally religious and Catholic work…” It is not allegorical, but rather filled with mythological metaphors. It is likewise difficult not to note the many Catholic themes are found in his body of work. For example, Frodo and Sam’s journey to Mordor can evoke very deep discussions and diverse interpretations than the one put forward in this blogpost. Tolkien’s writing lends itself to these debates and unconstrained analysis based on one’s lived experiences.  For example, I read The Lord of the Rings through the eyes of a devout Roman Catholic who now attends a secular university. As a young adult, I am actively trying to make sense of the world I was raised in and the world I now live in. Tolkien's work and this class have been a serendipitous spiritual wake up call, where the Hobbit’s journey presents deeply personal and important spiritual questions in my own life. As Tolkien said, “If sanctity inhabits [my] work or as a pervading light illumines it then it does not come from [me] but through [me]. And neither of you would perceive it in these terms unless it was with you also.” I see the meek and unsuspecting Hobbits, Frodo, Sam, Pippin, Merry, and Bilbo, as God’s call to reject the easy path and to pursue the adventurous, albeit difficult, life of seeking truth, justice, and saintliness. As Sam says, “There’s some good in this world, Mr. Frodo. And it’s worth fighting for.” These books are beautifully written and reveal greater layered truths about humanity, life, purpose, prayer, and the meaning of death through a Catholic prism. Tolkien recognized that his work does not belong to him and will be interpreted and used by others who draw meaning from it that he never intended. As Tolkien fans and students of this class we are privileged to be gaining the knowledge and insight  to “defend” the books against “the malice of its enemies.” 

~Evita

“A Elbereth!" — Tolkien's Psalms


In Letter 142, Tolkien says “For the religious element is absorbed into the story and its symbolism.” Here he is, of course, referring to the elements of his own Catholic theology embedded in the Lord of the Rings. One of these elements that stands out particularly to me is the poems/verse that are scattered throughout the tale, as they often bring to mind psalms and prayers found in the Bible and in liturgy, especially those that mention and/or are praises to Elbereth. The similarities between the songs/invocations of Elbereth and psalms I think display not only Tolkien’s views about how religion should be practiced, but also I think the importance of religion in our lives as a grounding and life-giving practice.
The reverence that the elves have for Elbereth (Varda) is clear in the hobbits’ first encounter with them outside of the Shire and the elves are singing of Elbereth. One stanza in particular is heavily reminiscent of a hymn:

Snow-White! Snow-White! O Lady Clear!
O Queen beyond the Western Seas!
O Light to us that wander here
Amid the world of woven trees!...

O stars that in the Sunless Year
With shining hand by her were sown
In windy fields now bright and clear
We see your silver blossom blown! (Tolkien 88)

"Varda of the Stars" by Kip Rasmussen

The psalms, of course, are filled with poetry and verse that have a similar...vibe, so to speak, as the elves’ song to Elbereth. The elves’ song can very easily be mapped onto a psalm, as both  do many of the same things: naming the object of their praise as a ruler over the land (or in this case, the seas), praising the works of their hands, calling them a light for the people, etc.

In his letter to his son, Christopher, Tolkien talks about ways to find comfort when he can’t attend Mass: “If you don’t do so already, make a habit of the ‘praises,’” after which he lists several hymns/psalms that he himself uses to worship. Pairing this letter with the The Ancrene Riwle, it is pretty clear to see that praise in the forms of psalms and hymns are extremely important elements of worship to Tolkien, and he relays this through the text in the form of hymns to Elbereth.

Another ‘psalm’ to Elbereth that is of particular note is in chapter ten of book four of The Lord of the Rings, when Sam is defending Frodo from Shelob. Just as he falls to the ground, a ‘swoon upon him,’ Sam pulls out the Phial of Galadriel and cries out:

A Elbereth Gilthoniel
o menel palan-diriel
le nallon sí di’nguruthos!
A tiro nin, Fanuilos!

In his letter to Rhona Beare, Tolkien says that this ‘hymn-fragment’ translates to “O Elbereth Starkindler from heaven gazing-afar, to thee I cry now in the shadow (the fear of) death. O look towards me, Everwhite!” This verse has a reference, intentional or otherwise, that I recognized near instantly: “Though I walk in the valley of the shadow of death, I fear no evil, for thou art with me” (Psalm 23). The stark similarity between Sam’s outburst and the well-known Psalm 23 I think lends itself to further conveying Tolkien’s point here, that in moments of darkness, faith and worship can be lights to carry us through. He mentions this in his letter to his son, saying “How these old words smite one out of the dark antiquity!” in reference to a poem from the Exeter book, and in Sam’s case, the hymn to Elbereth quite literally smites the enemy about to attack him.

Several times throughout The Lord of the Rings, we see one of the characters crying out to Elbereth in times of dire need: Frodo on Weathertop, Legolas before firing his bow at the flying creature in chapter nine of book two, etc. Similarly, many psalms cry out to God, asking for protection, for forgiveness, for deliverance, and the list goes on. Needless to say, Tolkien’s use of characters crying out to Elbereth very much keeps with the religious overtones of the hymns to Elbereth elsewhere in the text. In Tolkien’s letter to Michael Tolkien, Letter 250, he says “In the last resort faith is an act of will, inspired by love.” I think this line is very much applicable to these moments where the characters cry out to Elbereth, especially Sam when he’s fighting off Shelob. While I think that perhaps Tolkien’s words in the letter refer to a love of God, Sam holding up the Phial and crying out to Elbereth is an act of will, an act of faith, inspired by his love and devotion for Frodo. In his last resort, Sam reached out to a higher power and made an act of worship in order to save his friend (and also the quest, but I think it’s pretty obvious the quest is secondary to Frodo in Sam’s mind).

While Tolkien’s use of hymn and psalm in The Lord of the Rings is partially a product of his own faith and life experiences, I also think that it’s a deliberate move to subtly impress upon the readers (us) the importance of faith, especially in dark times. In demonstrating the necessity of worshipful acts like praise and singing hymns/saying the psalms, Tolkien also demonstrates how faith can lead us through life’s tribulations and ground us when things are difficult. And these lessons stretch across the bounds of time, as faith can be a source of peace and light for us as well in the turbulent times we inhabit today.

- CR