Tuesday, April 18, 2023

Should we teach aliens to play Monopoly? -On metaphors in the world of Tolkien

Imagine a scenario where we are visited by extraterrestrial life whose civilization is unknown to us. This raises the question of how we can introduce our civilization to them. Two potential options come to mind: firstly, we could teach them to play Monopoly; secondly, we could introduce them to the works of J.R.R. Tolkien. The question remains: which option should we choose? At first glance, these two options may seem equally absurd, but upon closer analysis, their viability becomes apparent. 

Although some may initially doubt Monopoly's ability to represent our civilization, those familiar with the history of the Cold War may find the answer to this question rather straightforward. The USSR banned Monopoly in the 1980s, as it was believed that the board game, along with Coca-Cola, played a significant role in helping people in the East understand Western culture and evoking their longing for it. Given its potential impact, could Monopoly be used as an icebreaker during our initial interaction with extraterrestrial beings? Nevertheless, are there any potential risks associated with this approach? 



Another example may aid in analyzing this issue. In 2016, a film called Arrival, directed by Villeneuve, depicted humanity's attempt to establish communication with an extraterrestrial species possessing a completely distinct language system. While the protagonist, Louise Banks, worked to decipher their language, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) used a simpler yet seemingly effective method to communicate: playing Mahjong, a competitive board game. However, this approach led the CCP to interpret the aliens' intentions as hostile, in contrast to the message Louise had directly translated from the aliens' writing. Why did the CCP's approach distort the message of benevolence conveyed by the aliens? One explanation is rooted in the theories presented in our lecture: our language and cognition systems rely heavily on metaphors, and competitive games such as chess and Mahjong typically embody war-related metaphors. Consequently, these metaphors have established perilous "unspoken lines" between humans and aliens, which may contribute to misunderstandings and complications in inter-species communication. 

Now, let's consider the message we would convey to aliens if we introduced our civilization by teaching them to play Monopoly. The central objective of the game is to compete for resources and thwart the other players, driven by greed and an intense desire to win. While this may be a sad reality for many people in our flawed world, the question remains: are we ready to acknowledge and accept this fact? Are we willing to plummet into places, deep and dark, without hoping to hold on to the thing we could climb to? Rung after rung, don’t we pray for pulling ourselves out of ourselves, reaching for something greater? We are flawed, but we can convey to aliens that we possess the courage to confront our flaws and take steps to better ourselves. Can Tolkien's literary works effectively convey this message to aliens? To determine the answer, we must delve into the metaphors that Tolkien aimed to express through his writing.


The first metaphor in Tolkien's work pertains to the Truth of Creation, which distinguishes it from craftship. Our lectures have taught us that in Tolkien's world, true creation originates in the mind of Eru. The thoughts, or themes, are then brought to life by the incarnated Valars after they enter the material world where time flows. Finally, the Children of Eru show their gratitude and appreciation for the creation, which is conveyed back to Eru through the Valars. As Professor Brown pointed out, we can see from Sayers' book "The Mind of the Maker" that this three-stage procedure aligns with the general creation process of artists. For example, in the case of a writer, everything starts with an idea, which is non-being. Then, through hard work, we bring the idea to life and create a book. Finally, we receive feedback from readers, including ourselves, which completes the creative cycle.


Craftsmanship, in contrast to creation, involves the transformation of raw materials into finished products, as exemplified by the works of Celebrimbor, Fëanor, Sauron, and even Morgoth in Middle-earth. This process operates within the realm of the material world, dealing with objects that already exist, from being to being. Furthermore, in the tales of Middle-earth, the most magnificent crafts, such as the Silmarillion and the Rings of Power, often bring with them a series of tragic events, serving as a poignant reminder of the catastrophic consequences that followed the rapid advancement of human technology during the late 19th and early 20th centuries, including devastating wars. 


Through a deep understanding of this metaphor and a constant remembrance of the Truth of Creation, we can endeavor to create with good intentions, just as our Creator did in the beginning. Even if our work entails crafting, we must not forget the cautionary tale of Celebrimbor's tragedy, which serves as a stark reminder of the peril that comes with blindly pursuing advanced craftsmanship. It highlights the potential risk of corrupting our initial good intentions, leading to the inadvertent perversion of our work into something malevolent.


The second metaphor concerns the nature of evil, with the One Ring serving as a perfect representation of the obsession with possessions in the material world. This obsession is often considered to be the root of all evil, as it drives individuals to engage in unethical and immoral behavior in pursuit of their desires. Whether it was Isildur, Gollum, Boromir, or even Frodo, their gaze upon the One Ring revealed a similar obsession to that of Morgoth's desire to conquer Arda and make it his own kingdom. In contrast to other works that may exploit such obsession to attract readers or even subtly encourage it, Tolkien's writings demonstrate a deep sympathy for those caught in its grasp. He endeavored to guide readers towards a path of escape. In the third chapter of The Children of Húrin, Tolkien used the voice of Húrin to convey a message:


“Do you forget to whom you speak? Such things you spoke long ago to our fathers; but we escaped from your shadow. And now we have knowledge of you, for we have looked on the faces that have seen the Light, and heard the voices that have spoken with Manwe. Before Arda you were, but others also; and you did not make it. Neither are you the most mighty; for you have spent your strength upon yourself and wasted it in your own emptiness. No more are you now than an escaped thrall of the Valar, and their chain still awaits you.”


With the power of the Light and the Words from the One, we can see through the pathetic nature of evil and break free from the downward spiral of obsession and destruction. Hold onto this faith, and the darkness shall not conquer us.


In the third metaphor, the focus is on the connection between sorrow and compassion. According to the Valaquenta, Nienna, the Lady of Sorrows, “is acquainted with grief, and mourns for every wound that Arda has suffered in the marring of Melkor.” “So great was her sorrow, as the Music unfolded, that her song turned to lamentation long before its end, and the sound of mourning was woven into the themes of the World before it began.” I would like to share a poem by Rilke,


Pietà


Jetzt wird mein Elend voll, und namenlos

erfüllt es mich. Ich starre wie des Steins

Inneres starrt.

Hart wie ich bin, weiß ich nur Eins:

Du wurdest groß -

... und wurdest groß,

um als zu großer Schmerz

ganz über meines Herzens Fassung

hinauszustehn.

Jetzt liegst du quer durch meinen Schooß,

jetzt kann ich dich nicht mehr

gebären.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    

Yet, “those who hearken to her learn pity, and endurance in hope.” 


-Y.P.L.


Sunday, April 16, 2023

The Secret Language of the Dwarves

 “his world-dominion by creative act: not his to worship the great Artefact, man, sub-creator, the refracted light through whom is splintered from a single White to many hues, and endlessly combined in living shapes that moved from mind to mind.” (Mythopoeia)

                                             

It is no secret that Tolkien was a linguaphile, therefore, it should come as no surprise that he holds language in high esteem, believing that human language is the same form of creation that was used by God when he created the universe.  For Tolkien language is not just the giver of life but is alive itself and this ability to constantly evolve is what gives life to language.  The Oxford English dictionary, which he contributed to, comes out every year with a list of new words, keeping the English language alive.  Tolkien gives the Orcs, the foulest of all races in Middle Earth, a dead language in their Black Speech to portray their corrupted nature. Contrasting Black Speech with the languages of Elves, which are ever evolving, as portrayed by the Tree of Tongues, only emphasizes this point.

 

Tolkien states that the Dwarves “are not evil by nature”, yet their language has “changed little by the years”.  Why then are the Dwarves and their language more closely linked to the Black Speech than the Elvish languages?  I believe that this question can be answered through a look at Tolkien’s opinion on naming and how it relates to language.

 

“I like history, and am moved by it, but its finest moments for me are those in which it throws light on words and names!” (Letters, 264)

 

            With a background in, and passion for, philology one might be surprised to learn that Tolkien did not view people trying to find the meaning in his characters’ names favorably.

 

“I remain puzzled, and indeed sometimes irritated, by many of the guesses at the ‘sources’ of the nomenclature, and theories or fancies concerning hidden meanings.” (Letters, 379)

 

“looking around for more or less similar words or names is not in fact very useful even as a source of of sounds, and not at all as an explanation of inner meanings and significances.” (Letters, 387)

 

             Tolkien created the languages and names solely as pleasurable exercise in “linguistic ‘æsthetic’”, where there is no meaning for these words outside of the stories, they are created in.  Any link of names to “real” languages is purely a coincidence and it is a waste of time to try and sort through all of these.  These names are Tolkien’s version of the Cellar Door concept, and by searching for a meaning in names outside of the story you will miss the forest for the trees.  It is infinitely more worthwhile to just take Tolkien’s names and languages as a given and work with them in the framework they were intended for.  This is why Tolkien’s nomenclature does not place emphasis on concepts like “true names”, such as one might find in the story of Rumpelstiltskin, but rather on how names define relationships.  Take Gandalf for example, who goes by many different names and what he is called depends on his relationship to those people. To the people of Gondor, he is Mithrandir, meaning “Grey Pilgrim”, and to the hobbits and the north men he is Gandalf, meaning “Wand-elf”, among many other examples.  While the meaning of these names in their respective languages is important, what is more important is the relationship that these names convey.  Even Earendil, the one name he admits to lifting directly from Anglo-Saxon language, was only given meaning in his story once it had been incorporated into the “Elvish linguistic situation”.  Therefore, in Tolkien’s world, nomenclature is inseparable from the languages that he created.      

 

            Therefore, I would invite you to look at the language of the Dwarves as a critique on this dismantling of language by the likes of Ursula Le Guin, Robert Graves, and all those who seek meaning in names where there is none.  The notion of holding power over an entity through the knowledge of its true name, like in the story of Rumpelstiltskin, is, in my opinion, why the Dwarves hide their language and their names.  The Dwarves are so secretive of their native tongue that they even refuse to inscribe their “true names” on their tombs.  Through this practice, the Dwarves lose their connection to this language they valued so much and leave their legacy translated into a different language and, therefore, a different people.  I believe that this is why Tolkien describes them as “a race apart” from Elves and Men.  Unlike the Orcs, the Dwarves are not evil by nature, but they have bastardized their language the same way the Orcs did the Black Speech.  The Dwarves’ mistaken beliefs around secrecy killed the very language they sought to protect, turning it into “a tongue of lore rather than a cradle-speech” (The Lord of the Rings, Appendix F).  The result of the Dwarves’ actions concerning their language that was valued as “a treasure of the past” is a warning against the dismantling effects that digging too deep into a language triggers.  

 

The scholars who seek a “real world” meaning behind every name and the Dwarves who destroy their language while trying to guard it have both toppled the metaphorical tower to read the inscriptions on the bricks.  Therefore, the language of the Dwarves should serve as Tolkien’s warning to all those who seek to find meaning in every single name and word: that by dismantling these languages you risk missing the point of the narrative and, therefore, ruining the story for youself.


-CG

Saturday, April 15, 2023

When three is not three


“Until now, science could arise only on this solidified, granite foundation of ignorance, the will to know rising up on the foundation of a much more powerful will, the will to not know, to uncertainty, to untruth! Not as its opposite, but rather — as its refinement!” - Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil, Part 2.

In class and discussion, we questioned if someone could learn a myth older, not only if they would remember it but if it would stick in their brain as something innately true, even in its untruth. I know D'Aulaires' Book of Greek Myths to be false — to be myths in both senses of the word —, but my parents put that book on tape so often that “In olden times, when men still worshiped ugly idols, there lived in the land of Greece…” still rings true to me. The cadence of the words still sounds in my ears as truth even in falsity. The music still compels me.

But how can something be both true and false at the same time? We also discussed the unchanging and objective quality of music: if it is made from math, how can it be wrong? Three is three is three… unless it’s not. In this quote, Nietzsche questions the very foundations of our epistemological claims. Take the example of music: we know a song to start on a three-count, but it will never really start there, there will always be a millisecond off, a certain impreciseness. Sounds will always be a little discordant, even if barely perceptible to the human ear. But if a music director were to narrow in on making sure that the notes begin at exactly three seconds, he would miss the human character of the music, the experience of hearing a song. To Nietzsche, it is impossible for life to exist except on the basis of subjective perspectival experiences. Either way, something is lost: three is not really three, at least in the way we’d like it to be.

To say three is so simple is belies a lie; it implicitly admits that the search for truth tacitly accepts not only ignorance but falsity. If the material world only ever approximates the world of forms, why must we insist on the forms themselves? Nietzsche would answer that we have a powerful call to ignorance, a weakness that prevents all but the most powerful from accessing reality, a new philosophy. I would say that this impreciseness is a symptom of the Fall but our good natures still allow us to access a certain truth, even if it is obscured. Our knowledge of good is like Plato’s remembrance; our past life is pre-lapsarian.

This brings me to another question we raised: can we perceive Melkor’s discord? If Melkor’s revolt is like Lucifer’s rebellion, if discord is evil, then we present the same problem that we have in Christian theology: the origin of this evil. Iluvatar/harmony/good/God/order exists first in this narrative — it is not the chaos of Hesiod’s Theogony. And thus, a departure from this good is not a separate thing, but a negation of the good itself [how does this happen? I am not satisfied with Augustine’s explanation and am deeply confused]. I don’t even think that it has to be a complete negation, as Iluvatar asserts that it still has an ultimate source in him (17) [thus can anything be truly evil? The Fall? Augustine’s unprompted thievery of the pear?]. However, I think that not only can we hear Melkor’s discord (if a hampered version), but in fact, all we hear is Melkor’s discord. Everything is built on this mix of unity and negation: three is never quite three.

To return to youth: other philosophers would answer that we are not able to believe myths in the same way as adults because we have a different relationship to truth and falsehood. In Plato’s Republic Book VII, Socrates suggests banishing everyone over ten from the city to create a “just city” out of an unjust one might be possible. Of course, this is patently preposterous: it is comical in the same way a city without meat can be called the “City of Pigs.” And yet we are primed to accept this preposterousness; we accept that a city must have both no adults and no families and yet must still have procreation for the creation of new citizens. There is something inherently illogical at the root of fallen societies. Put in sharp relief, we are not as likely to believe, but as children, we are lulled into a false sense of security — we are habituated into a certain self-delusion. Even as adults, we survive on this delusion, both because it makes us comfortable and because it is necessary to move through the world as functional beings. We are always in a cave, one of our own making. However, new myths don’t stick to adults in the same way they do to children because we have already been taught to accept a certain flavor of falsehood in our youth. In fact, we are so accustomed to this delusion that even the pursuit of knowledge involves a sort of tacit ignorance.

Art adds another layer of abstraction. As Plato says again in his Republic, artists are second-order liars — every move from Form to material to representation of material distorts it: every creation is a type of lie. Putting this in conversation with Tolkien’s sub-creation is practically impossible (yet another case of Neoplatonism being paradoxical). Perhaps putting the two together raises the question: how can sub-creation be possible among such fallen souls? How can we at once be likened to Iluvatar in our creative capacity and yet corrupted by Melkor’s discord in every facet of our minds? Perhaps Plato would have preferred creation remain unthought, a potentiality in Iluvatar's mind never quite reached.
- KW

Naming and Information

 On Tuesday, we discussed at length the role that names and naming play in our immersion in a piece of media. More specifically, the relationship between two very different viewpoints-

​One, that every person, place, and thing possesses a true name that holds power with it. Name a thing, and you can control it. There are a few issues with this point of view, though it can work if done properly. It presupposes the existence of some primordial language- or languages- that the true names are spoken in. This fundamentally changes the role of language, from something that humans use as subcreators and masters of their world, to something inhuman which is simply harnessed by humans. Language as an inhuman phenomenon raises some questions, given that we rarely see things other than humans use language. It can still work, however, depending on how ancient you want the world to be. 

​On the other hand, there is a viewpoint that names are just arbitrary sounds, thrown together by humans to reflect something. I do not think Tolkien would appreciate this viewpoint either. Within his works, there are numerous examples of language and names holding special power over someone or something. The Black Speech of Mordor, for example, so corrupted the Mouth of Sauron that his mouth was physically disgusting, as well as the words which came from it. Clearly, we can see that names do hold some power- but not purely in their status as names, but rather the power deriving from something the name is attached to. 

​Within Tolkien’s work, names are used to reflect the relationship between a linguistic group which speaks a language and the thing they are naming. Often times when a name is uttered, it has a specific meaning in mind that it is being used to evoke. This is often historical, but can refer to great feats and aspects of that thing as well. Gandalf’s list of names given in Book IV Chapter V is a great example of this. When Frodo and Sam meet Faramir and they discuss Gandalf, Faramir calls Gandalf by the name Mithrandir, which Frodo is taken aback by, having only ever personally called him by one name. Faramir replies: 

‘Mithrandir we called him in elf-fashion,’ said Faramir, ‘and he was content. Many are my names in many countries, he said. Mithrandir among the Elves, Tharkûn to the Dwarves; Olórin I was in my youth in the West that is forgotten, in the South Incánus, in the North Gandalf; to the East I go not.’

​This type of “direct” worldbuilding allows us to analyze these names and what they mean for the people who call him by these names. 

The name Mithrandir is rather straightforward, being of Elvish origin. It is comprised of Mith, meaning “grey”, and Randir, meaning “wanderer”. 

Tharkûn, then, is extremely unclear in specific etymology. As it comes from the Dwarvish language, who famously keep their language a secret to outsiders, we know nothing of its morphology other than that it has the meaning of Grey-man. 

Olórin has a meaning associated with dreams or the mind, denoting his demeanor and expertise.

Incánus, then, has a slightly less clear origin, given that he is called that in the South, which generally has less information available due to its less civilized nature. It is suggested, however, that it comes from the words of the Haradrim Inkā-nūs, meaning North Spy. This shows both the close-minded nature of the people of the South as well as the general infrequency with which he visits.

Gandalf, then, means “Staff-Elf” and is so named from Old Norse. As a result, it does not have any strictly in-universe etymology given, but rather the people of the North have given him a name which happens to match the etymology of the “real world”. This one is of particular interest to me. Not only because it is the primary name people know him by, but that in-universe, we have spottier information than even the name from the South. Knowing how Tolkien essentially localized the text of the Lord of the Rings rather than presenting names exactly as they would appear, it is possible that “Gandalf”, too, is a localized name.

All of these names are two-way mirrors into both the conception of Gandalf by these people groups as well as what we can learn about the people groups from the names. The extremely plain names of the Elves and Dwarves, for example, speak to the frequency with which Gandalf would appear to them, and how he generally fit in to some extent. Likewise, from the outside looking in, it tells us how to perceive the Elves and Dwarves somewhat. Given that we are intended to view the Elves and Dwarves as distinctly “not like us” in some respect, the fact that they would have a plain name for a wizard places him and them firmly in the same world of our conception. 

The name Olórin, then, betrays Gandalf’s origin as a maia. Not only is it definitively more ethereal in feel, but it has a distinct name that does not simply characterize him as being “like a man” in some way. Thus, the name places the people who named him as being more like him in some respect.

The fundamental difference between names like these, which place both the named and namers firmly within a “built world” and names which we use in ours is a clear origin. There is a tendency in fantasy for names to have clear etymologies, while in our language, they typically do not. It is possible that someone knew the etymologies of names we use at some point, but most have been lost. There is a clear break in our world between names with clear origins and those without. “Germany”, for example, is first attested as the name of a people living around the Rhine in the first century B.C.. It cannot be placed further back than that, already existing as a name. Of course, there are other names we do know the origins of. America, for instance, coming from the name Amerigo Vespucci, who was an early explorer of the New World. 

This is a trade-off faced by everyone who goes to build a world, in the sense Tolkien would be satisfied with- between explanation and believability, between known facts and mystery. Every author must solve this problem in a way that is suited for their world.

Of course Tolkien, as a philologist, would find it incredibly unsatisfying to simply leave etymologies unknown- where’s the fun in that? Instead, he leaves massive chunks of his geography as proverbial question marks on his map. Other authors handle this differently. In total, though, it is just interesting to see this conundrum of worldbuilding come up upon the analysis of names, given its omnipresence in works such as this.

-BTS

Melkor's Fall

        In the Ainulindalë,* Eru Ilúvatar inspires his first creations, the Ainur, to make music based off of a theme he provides. This music intends to bring the entire universe into being, in Ilúvatar's name. However, one Ainu, Melkor, uses his own theme to create discord (Ainulindalë, The Silmarllion). Some would attribute this moment to be the cause of his Fall into Darkness, because it is a strong first sign of things to come, but the truth is more complicated. Melkor's Fall is not marked by his disruption of the Ainulindalë, nor a singular snap from "good" to "evil," but rather by a slow progression towards evil that, eventually, had some final and decisive moments. In addition to his greed (which initially caused him to disrupt the Music) (Ainulindalë, 4), his growing resentment and his inability to collaborate with others are what ultimately contribute to his Fall.

        Before addressing Melkor's Fall itself, we do need to address the role of Theodicy in this discussion. Eru Ilúvatar initially stops Melkor's disruption by showing that he has ultimate control over the music. For one thing, he could stop all the singing, including Melkor's, just by "[raising] up both his hands and in one chord... the Music ceased." He then lectures Melkor about how no one would be able to alter his music in a malicious way without his permission (Ainulindalë, 5-6). Since Melkor was acting in contempt of Ilúvatar, his statement seems to imply that the music Melkor made was actually under Ilúvatar's control. On an initial level, that is solid evidence that Melkor disrupting the music was not actually a Fall at all. However, Melkor does eventually go on to legitimately Fall into Darkness, so Eru's statement about the amount of control he has seems slightly suspicious. The other option is that Eru's power over the Ainur is finite, and while he may have control over the music of creation, and be able to limit their powers when they enter into Arda (Ainulindalë, 10), he still can't keep Melkor from committing acts of true evil. The problem is that both Eru intending for Melkor to work evil and Eru's powers being finite are both difficult ideas to accept. For the sake of evaluating Melkor's Fall, however, I will be examining his descent more from the perspective that Eru does not have total control over him. More specifically, Melkor exerts many signs of apparent free will, regardless of whether he actually possesses it, so I will mostly be examining his Fall as if he chose it entirely himself. 

        Aside from Eru's intent, however, the fact that Eru exerts some control over Melkor's powers (and, specifically stated, what he can contribute to the music) shows that the first important factor in when Melkor fell comes from the idea that Ilúvatar intended for Melkor's contribution of discord to the song of the Ainur to happen. As he tells Melkor, "no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite. For he that attempteth this shall prove but mine instrument in the devising of things more wonderful, which he himself hath not imagined" (Ainulindalë, 6). In the case that no theme (including Melkor's) can be played that is not in Eru's plan, it is unlikely that Melkor's introduction of another theme was the moment that marked his Fall, or even that he was doing anything other than his job. Remember that when Ilúvatar initially introduced his first theme, he instructed the Ainur to "show forth your powers in adorning this theme, each with his own thoughts and devices, if he will" (Ainulindalë, 1). Although Melkor's conflicting theme comes from a place of greed, what he is actually doing is contributing to the music. He even, as Ilùvatar points out, creates (seen-as-beautiful) ice in the process (Ainulindalë, 8). The Music of the Ainur is described, at this point in the story, to have multiple themes; Melkor's theme does seem to conflict with Eru's, but eventually, their themes actually merge, and Eru creates a third theme that uses parts of the two merged themes in its own music (Ainulindalë, 5). The result is what ultimately creates the vision of Arda that Ilúvatar shows to the Ainur (Ainulindalë, 7-9). Melkor's theme helps create Arda, he follows Eru's instruction to make choices and add his own details, and his actions are blatantly part of Eru's plan. As such, we cannot say that Melkor's discordant theme is actually something that opposes Ilúvatar, even if he was working from a place of arrogant belief in his own superiority. Melkor's actions during Ainulindalë did not mark his Fall.

        Instead, the actual cause of Melkor's Fall can be tracked through a series of events that progress towards him being ultimately overcome by his envy and greed. Chronologically, a few things happen on Melkor's path to Darkness. First, he creates the opposition to Ilúvatar's first theme; second, he is put in his place by Ilúvatar "defeating" him, and begins to foster resentment against Eru; third, Melkor begins lying to himself that he wishes the best for the nascent universe, while steadily repressing his growing feelings of avarice; then, Melkor and the other Valar go down to Arda, and Melkor begins actively coveting the realm, trying to manipulate the work of the other Valar in ways that benefit his goals. Finally, Melkor's envy gets the better of him when he sees that the Valar have taken physical forms, and he switches from trying to interfere with the development of Arda to actively trying to undo the progress that's been made (Ainulindalë). His behavior at the end of his journey is markedly different than at the beginning, demonstrating that the Fall happened; one can look at the starting and ending positions to see this difference. In the beginning of Ainulindalë, Melkor is focused on "[increasing] the power and glory of the part assigned to himself" (Ainulindalë, 4). This version of Melkor is prideful and selfish, but he desires to create things entirely of his own more than anything else. His way of chasing power is through creation.

        However, the version of Melkor that lives at the end of Ainulindalë is vastly different. When he takes physical form and begins war against the Valar, "naught might have peace or come to lasting growth, for as surely as the Valar began a labour so would Melkor undo it or corrupt it... all things were in hue and shape other than the Valar had first intended" (Ainulindalë, 12). Melkor's Fallen Form (for at the end of Ainulindalë, it is clear that he has Fallen, even if it's not obvious when) is primarily focused not on increasing his personal glory, but on tearing down what others have built. He has switched to chasing power through destruction, rather than through creation, and that contrast makes all the difference. At the point where he chooses destruction over creation, it seems like he no longer cares about what he's ruling as much as the idea of having something to rule. He doesn't even care about making something original anymore, like how with the Music he desired to create his own theme, separate from Eru's. Now, he only corrupts existing material and destroys it. His true moment of Falling was when he decided he would rather destroy what others have made rather than try to make something himself, but he had to go through many steps to deteriorate to that point. At one point, he fights with his brother Manwë and the other Valar over who has the rights to rule Arda, and "for that time Melkor withdrew and departed to other regions and did there what he would; but he did not put the desire of the Kingdom of Arda from his heart" (Ainulindalë, 11). Crucially, this moment shows that even when Melkor had the opportunity to go elsewhere in Creation (i.e. somewhere that was not Arda, that he could shape as he saw fit, just like he had wanted to do when he made his own theme in the Music), he could not stop thinking about Arda, the charge of, at that point, the other Valar. This lingering envy, the desire to break or change what others have instead of make something for himself even when given the opportunity to do as he wishes elsewhere, proves that Melkor's descent continued to occur past his actions at Ainulindalë. 

        Then, a new question arises, concerning what factors were present that caused Melkor's Fall. The biggest factor is that he does not learn the right lessons from Eru's words. After the Music has finished, Ilúvatar tells Melkor that he will eventually "discover all the secret thoughts of thy mind, and wilt perceive that they are but a part of the whole and tributary to its glory" (Ainulindalë, 6). Ilúvatar's words come across as an intent for Melkor to learn a lesson about humility in this event, and his statement predicts that Melkor will, after reflection, move past this event with the knowledge of Eru's power, and a new respect for his role as a part of the whole. That is, of course, not what happens. Melkor certainly grows to know his own mind, but doing so only drives him farther down the Dark path. On a side note, Ilúvatar's intentions for Melkor (returning to the Theodical dilemma for a moment here) actually have very little to do with his Fall in this moment; even if Melkor's fall were to somehow be predestined, Ilúvatar's words themselves provide solid advice about respecting and appreciating the work of others. Aside from the factor of Melkor's already established greed, the fact that he fails to accept Eru's message shows that he is quite self-absorbed, and doesn't grasp the idea of being part of something bigger than himself. For contrast, Ulmo, Vala of the Water, when finding out that Melkor's theme had meddled with his domain to create ice and rain, was thrilled, and immediately sought out Manwë (Vala of the Sky, whose domain related to Melkor's creation of rain as well) in order to collaborate more closely with him (Ainulindalë, 8-9). On the other hand, when Melkor finds out other Valar are working in the same space as him and made something beautiful, he throws a temper tantrum.

        Furthermore, a fascinating comparison can be drawn between Melkor and Aulë, "to whom Ilúvatar had given skill and knowledge scarce less than to Melkor; but the delight and pride of Aulë is in the deed of making, and in the thing made, and neither in possession nor in his own mastery; therefore he gives and hoards not, and is free from care, passing ever on to some new work" (Ainulindalë, 8). Aulë seems to be extremely similar to Melkor in that they both are fixated on creation (or, depending on what stage of his descent Melkor is in, destruction). The fact that Aulë is compared to Melkor in terms of skill and knowledge suggests that there is probably a greater similarity between the two of them in those areas than with other Valar. However, Aulë demonstrates several virtues that Melkor lacks: namely, the ability to work as part of a whole, and appreciate the creation itself (especially as a form of praise for Ilúvatar) rather than the possession of it. It is also worthwhile to note that Aulë created the Dwarves apparently against the will of Ilúvatar, at first glance in a similar manner to how Melkor vainly desired to create things outside of Ilúvatar's influence. However, when Ilúvatar confronts him about his reasons, Aulë responds that he "did not desire such lordship. I desired things other than I am, to love and to teach them, so that they too might perceive the beauty of Eä, which thou hast caused to be... the making of things is in my heart from my own making by thee" (The Silmarillion, 37-38). Even when Aulë "did a Melkor," so to speak, and tried creating things outside of the permission of Ilúvatar, he only did it out of a desire to see Ilúvatar's vision honored. He owned up to his mistake, and as a result Ilúvatar allowed him to continue with his project (The Silmarillion, 38). On another interesting side note, the conversation between Eru Ilúvatar and Aulë also adds to the Theodical discussion, because Aulë's actions are distinctly outside of Ilúvatar's plan (The Silmarillion, 38-39), which would imply that Eru is not all powerful, and therefore would also imply that Eru genuinely did not want Melkor to Fall, and could not prevent him from Falling. This probability and the comparison between the two Valar show that Melkor's Fall is largely his own fault.

        As it turns out, Eru Ilúvatar may have planned for Melkor's contribution of discord to Ainulindalë, but Melkor's Fall was likely out of his control. As such, the blame and the cause for Melkor Falling into Darkness lies with his progressively deteriorating moral standing. Over the course of Ainulindalë, he immerses himself deeper and deeper into greed, envy, and his own ego, and refuses to accept his place as part of a whole-- part of a team. By comparison, the discord that his theme causes in Ainulindalë is quite benign.

--GCE

*"Ainulindalë" refers to the text. "Ainulindalë," without the italics, refers to the event.