Wednesday, April 26, 2023

The manipulation of the Numenoreans

This journey we have taken so far in class has led us to many discussions regarding the method behind Tolkien’s writings, his motivations, and how Tolkien’s stories spin a new tale of mythology, fate, beauty, and free will. But in Tuesday's class we had an opportunity to discuss the origins and beginnings of evil in Tolkien’s universe. This discussion of evil and striving towards the light centered around the Elves and how they navigated Tolkien’s world. 

In these stories the Elves can be seen navigating through the darkness and towards the light. The Eldar, or the group of elves who decided to embark on this immense journey to possibly reach Valinor represent a group of people who are seeking the light. An interesting discussion and stance can be taken on these Elves representing those who are seeking enlightenment. The question therein lies, what is this enlightenment? What are they truly seeking? Could it possibly be that these Elves were turning their back on darkness and evil and attempting to find the goodness in the world that Tolkien had created. 

It is said that some of the Elves that embarked on this journey after the capture of Melkor never made it to the land of immortality, instead they stayed behind in middle earth and are the elves we come to later interact with and know in the Lord of the Rings stories. These elves get coined as dark elves, whereas the elves that completed the journey towards the light are known as the elves of the light. Commonly, but not in all cases, the dark elves that stayed behind are portrayed as having dark hair, and the elves that completed the journey to Valinor are seen with having perfectly white hair. 


These elves, with their stunning white hair, are said to be wise beyond their years. Having reached the light at the end of the journey they not only received immortality but they received the greatest gift of all which is knowledge. This knowledge is something that was their greatest advantage and set them apart the most from those who were mortal and left in darkness. This idea of them getting enlightened is metaphorically portrayed through the description of their transition. But it gets cemented symbolically through seeing the light of the trees. Once they see the light of the trees they transcend into beings that are fully enlightened. 

This creates an interesting dynamic between the valor and the mortals who inhibit middle earth. The most intriguing discussion we had in class was whether or not the valor should be envied by mortal men. For we know that the valor have amassed immense knowledge and have been fully enlightened, but these same valor who have grown up surrounded by the light of the trees also experience no knowledge of death or morality to begin with. So, they end up having things and abilities that mere mortals do not, but are also completely unaware of what is truly the main motivating factor of mortal life, which is death. 

It is through this encounter that the jealousy of the mortal elvish descendants, or Numenoreans, begins. Knowing that they cannot live forever, and knowing that they have direct ancestors who have received this great gift of immortality, it is clear to see how jealousy arose. Even though they were given a life that lasted much longer than that of an average mortal man, and also were blessed with incredible height, strength, and fighting prowess, there was still this idea that there were those who were immortal, and they were being excluded from this group. The Numenoreans were the most powerful inhabitants of middle earth. They dominated man for centuries, and were feared by all, even Sauron at one point. But, as the story goes they fell to the deceit of Sauron, who told them of Melkor and promised them everlasting life, something they had been previously denied. Sauron, the true embodiment of evil thus took over and began not only leading these people, but he became worshiped. 

This leads perfectly into the discussion held around the source and power of evil. Sauron represents evil because he is the embodiment of someone who would purposefully corrupt and marr that which is good in the world. Sauron’s greed and lust for power led him to completely dominate the will of others. He was able to be this all controlling figure, influencing every decision of the Numenoreans is a perfect representation of evil at work in middle earth. Sauron exerted all of his force, manipulation, and power onto others and got them to do his will. 

So, with Sauron representing all that is evil in this world, he convinced the Numenoreans to disobey their godlike figure. This was wittily represented by the Babycandian diagram we were shown. Sauron got the Numenoreans to think like the baby in the diagram, challenging the validity of the Valor. It was this line of thinking that led them to the attempt to destroy the Valar. But obviously the Valar prevailed and destroyed the Numenoreans and also Sauron, sending him back to middle earth where he would begin work again to try and overtake the mortal world. So, Sauron represents this true and pure form of evil. The ability for one to completely control and use another for their own benefit or gain is what true evil is. 


TJG

Tuesday, April 25, 2023

Melkor Did Nothing Wrong… Well, Maybe a Few Things?

Now before I start, I should warn you that I am likely about to spew heresy, and probably have already done so. Here we go.


Let’s begin first with Eru, or Iluvatar as he is known in Arda (and Tolkien does say “he,” which presumes that Iluvatar created the concept of gender before even creating the Ainur, but I am wandering into dangerous territory here. Besides, I’ll cut Tolkien some slack and observe the context of the time period and religious reference). He is primordial and original, creator of creation and of things to come. There is no existence previous to Iluvatar, and he is the beginning of all things. Given Tolkien’s observance of his own Christian worship in the process of writing about Middle-Earth, it can be reasonably inferred that Iluvatar here is synonymous with God.


Moving on, then, to the Ainur. They are Iluvatar’s first creation, “offspring of his thought, and they were with him before aught else was made” (Silmarillion, pg. 3). They are Iluvatar’s angels, and in the Book of Job the angels “shouted for joy” as God created the world (Job 38:4-7). Melkor is one of the Ainur. He had been given out of all the Ainur “the greatest gifts of power and knowledge” (Sil., 4). What sets Melkor apart from the rest of the Ainur is his desire “to bring into Being things of his own” (Sil., 4). This brings Melkor into contention with Iluvatar and the Ainur, as his independence gets woven into his music. The “discord of Melkor” begins to spread, discouraging some of the Ainur and influencing others. In this way, Melkor resembles the fallen angel: Lucifer.

 

But (and here is where things get dicey) is Melkor a spitting image of Lucifer? Can the two of them be completely and perfectly synonymous? Has he even done anything wrong?


The short answer is no. But, if you’re still reading, you want to hear the long answer.

 

There is, of course, the war in the heavens to deal with. The discordance of music in the Ainulindale parallels this conflict. Melkor and Iluvatar wrest for control of the sonority with each other, until Iluvatar reveals his total control of the situation and Melkor is defeated. Iluvatar tells the Ainur and Melkor especially that “no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite.” Melkor is “filled with shame, of which came secret anger” (Sil., 6). Why the shame and anger? On the surface, it appears to be because Iluvatar singled out Melkor out of all the Ainur for his actions. But the reaction is not repentance, but shame and even resentment. This implies that Melkor finds himself justified and Iluvatar’s authority unfair. But why bother trying to see things from Melkor’s point of view?


For the same reason that we pay attention to any of the other Ainur: they represent a facet of Iluvatar’s thoughts. And what does Melkor have that the other Ainur don’t? There are many things we can call it - rebelliousness, discordance, dissent. But we must remember that Melkor is born out of Iluvatar’s thought: Melkor has inherited Iluvatar’s desire for creation. Naturally, creativity will come at odds with other notions of conception, and this is where the discord comes from. However, the root of what Melkor represents is not pure malice, but a desire for independence and creation. It is this desire for free creation that gets undermined by Iluvatar and the other Ainur, which leads to Melkor’s shame and anger. It is a struggle between creativity and order, between originality and foresight. Melkor is an artist, and cannot stand it that his artistry is not truly his but Iluvatar’s. 


There is, of course, one other thing Melkor holds besides the pride of an artist. It is greed. A desire to hold and possess. And at face value, this is sinful. We should not be greedy, we should give and not take, and so on. But Melkor is born from Iluvatar’s thought. Melkor’s desires are also Iluvatar’s own. Iluvatar says it himself: “nor can any alter the music in my despite.” The music of the world is all Iluvatar’s, and none of it is actually individually Melkor’s (much to his consternation). And this, perhaps, is the thing that complicates the issue: all the Ainur, Melkor included, are different facets of Iluvatar. We cannot read Melkor’s desire to possess unless we read the same thing in Iluvatar, and that threatens a theological dilemma. 


So I’ll conclude by saying that Melkor does not seem to be a spic and span copy of Lucifer, and as such, Iluvatar is also a more complicated deity than simply a virtuous creator. Indeed, it could be said that Iluvatar is the most conceptually complex character possible, as all contradictions and opposites in the world live conjoined in the plans of Iluvatar. 


- CLP

Sunday, April 23, 2023

The Origin of Evil

 This week in class one of the things we discussed was evil, and how it came to be in the Tolkien Universe, and what was its purpose. This question is interesting when looking at both how it came to be in the Tolkien Universe, and how Tolkien speaks about it and the other creations in the universe. The idea of evil seems to be closely related to that of free will. More specifically the origin of evil seems to be tightly intertwined with the idea of both subcreation and the free will of the creations. One thing that we have talked about alot is the idea of being a subcreator, and how they go about their creations. In Letters, no. 153, Tolkien is responding to a letter from Peter Hastings and is talking about this idea, and one of the things he talks about is evil and where it comes from in his creation. 

In this letter Tolkien talks about Sauron and says “Sauron was of course not ‘evil’ in origin. He was a ‘spirit’ corrupted by the Prime Dark Lord (the Prime sub-creative Rebel) Morgoth (190).” The first thing that stands out is the way in which he states that Sauron was obviously not evil from the beginning, but instead he was corrupted. Throughout the series we see Sauron as a source of evil, and the place where many evil actions come from. But here Tolkien is essentially saying that Sauron had no predisposition for being evil. Instead he was corrupted by something else that was already evil. It is clear that Tolkien is saying that Sauron had free will and decided to be evil, as opposed to his creator making him in a way in which he would become evil. The choice is important because it ties it closer to the real world and religion, more specifically Christianity. Without the choice of good or evil, it may give undue sympathy to the one who is evil, because it is not their fault, instead they were created that way. The fact that Sauron had a choice, is a huge part to what actually makes him evil.

If we take this a step further and look at how Morgoth became evil, we arrive at an interesting question. When reading The Silmarillion  and looking at the creation of Morgoth, then known as Melkor we see he also was not created with any predisposition to evil either. In the beginning we see that his desire was not to be evil, but instead “to bring into Being things of his own (4)”. This eventually led him down a path that was what we call evil, but his original desires were not that. The question that brings us to is what made him evil? In class when attempting to answer the question I attempted to say that the reason for evil was to show that free will exists. I said that without evil how could people have real options if everything they do is good, is that really free will. But this does not fully encapsulate what was happening. When reexamining The Silmarillion, I realized there was something missing. The thing that led Melkor down the wrong path was envy, and the desire to create in the same way that Eru did. It seems like Tolkien is showing us that the root of evil in his universe comes not through trying to create, but instead trying to create in a way that rivals Eru.

This still does not give us the answer to why Melkor is evil. It is interesting comparing what Tolkien said in Letters to what Augusitne said in City of God. When talking about the good and bad Angels Augustine says “the contrasted aims of the good and evil angels did not arise from any difference in nature or origin(471)”. This is interesting because it is practically the same thing that Tolkien says about his creations. Here Augustine is saying that good and evil have no difference in terms of where they were created and instead it has to come from somewhere else. Later he says that “we must believe that the difference had its origin in their wills and desires” (471). It seems like here Augustine is not only explaining their differences, but he is also saying that evil comes from the desires of those that are evil. So it is not something that comes from their person, but instead from their free will, which even though it was given to them by God, is not a reflection of him. This is a very interesting way to look at the creation of evil, because Augustine also tells us that God saw it coming, but allowed it anyway. It can be somewhat difficult to align the fact that God created the thing that would create evil while knowing that evil would be created, but He was not responsible for the creation. The answer to why belongs in free will. 

Free will is clearly important to Tolkien because he draws on it in a similar vein to Augustine. Free will is the reason a creator is not responsible for the creations of its creations. If a creator gives a subcreator the freedom to create, and do as they please, then they have the ability to make choices. These choices can either be things that are good, or they can be things that are evil and destructive. Either way both Tolkien and Augustine are telling us that the creator is not the source, as long as they do not directly imbue the evil into their creations. 


-RL

Thursday, April 20, 2023

Music as Analogy: Melkor and the “Discord”

In Ainulindale, Eru demanded the Ainur to make a Great Music together, in harmony. Thus I wonder if we may connect the Ainur’s Music with the classical music of real life, as an extended metaphor, when discussing the fall of Melkor. Christopher Tolkien did not choose to add a frame to the story of creation, but the elves who noted down the tale may have used music as a way of understanding in the first place, since none of them were there to witness Creation and could not perceive what it was like in the Void, or outside of the World.


At first, it is remarked that the Ainurs sang “only each alone, or but few together”, which seems that they are only capable of  singing monotonic tones or  melodies together in the same pitch. Perhaps it resembles the parallel octaves etc. in unison or round, such as the Parallel organum. Tolkien used the word “unison” to describe the state of the Ainur’s Music, when they gained deeper understanding of their brethren.


Comparing it with the music history, gradually the Ainur performed more sophisticatedly. Instead of simply singing in unison, they would move gradually toward a more complex polyphonic music, featuring two or more lines at the same line, while each may be considered as a melody of its own. Their voices are thus balanced and varied, in melody and rhythm.


When Illuvatar declared that they should make “in harmony together a Great Music”, the voices of the Ainur became greatly diverse. No longer they sang in unison, but like “unto harps and lutes, and pipes and trumpets, and voils and organs…” These are the metaphors of the elves, since it would be hard to imagine any being singing as if they are the instrument themselves. But,  in analogy, the singing of the Ainur at this stage may be compared to a symphony orchestra, where people form parts and follow the melodic direction of that specific part. The Ainurs who lead and those who follow may be differed into the Valar and the Maiar.


If such is the real-life representation of Illuvatar’s Great Music, what may be suggested about Melkor and his discordant ideas? One major use of dissonance in classical music is to separate various harmonic intervals by inviting uneven pitches so that each interval has its own sense. Intervals that sound harsh and do not blend in are the dissonant intervals. Melkor might have started by creating a dissonant interval when he had the thought of heightening himself, refusing to be in accord with others.


But Melkor did not stop by creating the discord alone. Others who were near him were also affected by his music and decided to “attune their music to his”, which reminds me that another way of breaking the harmony is to add a tone or chord to the music that is not in the original key, or create a out-of-tune division of a whole tune, so that it sounds higher or lower of the original version. The latter sparks me as a possibility when I read Letter 153, in which Tolkien explains that Morgoth made the Orcs as a mockery of the Children of God. It is not Creation, but a distortion of the original being, twisted and ugly. Melkor, when he became to glorify himself, gradually lost the ability to create, shown especially when he took form and descended into the World. As a metaphor, here, the dissonance he and his followers created may have been just a mockery as well.


Ironic that although Melkor tried hard to adopt his dissonance for his own use, the tone, along with the harmony of other Ainur, becomes part of the whole.


It may be quite difficult to create dissonances in a piece of music in the real world, since the means described earlier are few and demand a certain degree of skill, or, in this case, cunningness. Melkor was the Ainur that had the greatest power then, equipped with a wide understanding of music and knowledge, so his place and ability suited well with the discord he created. He may have planned his melody with great intention, leading others along, not just by adding a few notes therefore. 


But the power of Illuvatar was not defeated by the dissonance Melkor created. Instead, the Great Music became more sorrowful, more diverse, sometimes full of chaos, yet on a whole, more beautiful, with his influence, which was of course beyond his expectation. Just like an Orchestra, dissonance was a part of the music, and may be used to heighten the diversity and beauty of the piece when mastered carefully. The World had Evil, Shadows, loss and wrath, because of Melkor, but his was not the Creator, and the World could not have ended so. Through the sadness, there were harmony, glory and hope. Illuvatar showed mercy when he chose to encompass all of the Music, and he again demonstrated this godlike mercy when Melkor made the Orcs. Although they were created as distorted version of elves and men, they still came into being and were permitted to live.


All the Ainurs are thoughts of the Creator, and Melkor was the one that had the most power and was most gifted. His music was tolerated and woven into the greater Music that he was not aware of. This explains the limitation of Ainur’s Free Well. They may be given the choice to become evil and have the chance to act out their parts, each choice came with a price. Like a discordant melody, though it may lead for a while and threaten to let other’s astray, harmonious love shall ultimately take its place.


--JX

The Interplay Between Free Will and the Nature of Evil

 In front of you are two souls, both black and twisted. One was predestined to turn to evil, the other chose it willingly. Which do you deem worse? In Tolkien’s two main works not concerning burglars, the villain is an elemental representation of pure evil. Both Ainur, both immortal spirits, both were formerly, in a sense, “good”. The first, Melkor, later Morgoth, is Tolkien’s vehicle of original sin. Once the greatest of the Vala, he sought to contend with his creator, Eru Ilúvater, in the Music of the Ainur, the fabric of the world, introducing discord that begat all the world’s ills. But it is unclear whether he had any choice in the matter. Each Valar “comprehended only that part of the mind of Ilúvatar from which he came.” (Ainulindalë.) Melkor was only a vehicle for an aspect of Ilúvater’s thought, and was nothing that did not ultimately flow from the allfather. Additionally, the seeds of his treachery and covetousness were sown from the beginning. Before the singing, “he had gone often alone into the void places seeking the Imperishable Flame; for desire grew hot within him to bring into Being things of his own.” (Ainulindalë.) If he was from the outset created to be uniquely prideful as to think himself capable of wielding the sacred flame, and pride is the sin that causes his contention and ultimately his destruction, then was his fall not inevitable by the will of Ilúvater? Was he not a tragic figure, ineluctably saddled by his creator with the unenviable task of introducing shadows to accentuate the light? Without struggles, and those who rise above them, Ilúvater’s world would be but a sandbox, (a video game sandbox more than a playground one,) beautifully adorned, but with no depth. And so Morgoth rose, and so he fell, and so he was cast out into the void until the world’s end.

Each Valar is almost a personification of his or her element. (It’s never stated which Melkor’s is, but when the Vala descend to Arda, he’s shown to have a particular affinity for fire and a particular role in its conception, just as Ulmo did for water.) The Maia are more ambiguous, and more nuanced. They are not aspects of their masters like the Vala are, and don’t even necessarily serve just one Valar, as seen in the case of Melian. This nuance manifests itself in an important way—unlike the Vala, who are Eru’s unquestioning instruments save Morgoth, who is just as inextricably locked into his own ruinous spiral, the Maia have free will to a meaningful degree. (The qualifier is important here—it matters not if the Vala have free will if they’re fated by their given natures to always follow a particular path, as do Melkor and Mandos.) And so there is Sauron. A Maia servant of Aulë, he is seduced by Melkor’s power, choosing of his own volition to follow him. “It was the apparent will and power of Melkor to effect his designs quickly and masterfully that had first attracted Sauron to him.” (Morgoth’s Ring.) First Morgoth’s lieutenant, he becomes in time an evil to rival Morgoth’s: “In all the deeds of Melkor the Morgoth upon Arda, in his vast works and in the deceits of his cunning, Sauron had a part, and was only less evil than his master in that for long he served another and not himself.” (Valaquenta.) (The quote raises some really interesting questions about whether, to Tolkien, the capacity for worship, as Sauron did Melkor, at least in Númenor, was itself a virtue.)

Sauron’s descent is marked by choices, whereas Morgoth incarnate is an elemental, unthinking avatar of destruction. After the War of Wrath and Morgoth’s sundering, Sauron came in contrition before Eönwë, chief of the Maiar. Tolkien leaves open the possibility that this desire for penitence was genuine, if motivated by fear. However, referred up to Manwë, (the structure of Tolkien’s Heaven not unreminiscent of a bureaucracy,) Sauron chooses to flee rather than face the consequences of his actions. “Then Sauron was ashamed, and he was unwilling to return in humiliation and to receive from the Valar a sentence.” (Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age.) To be unwilling of course implies a will to be directed. With this action more than any other, (though the Luciferian War on Heaven [Aman] is a strong contender,) in choosing not to repent and accept the god’s salvation, Sauron chooses his destiny as absolute evil, and the rise and fall that accompanied it.

But was his fall inevitable? Sauron, Tolkien writes, believed that the sundering of the Undying Lands represented the gods’ (the Vala and Eru’s) abnegation of Middle Earth, blessing and cursing its populace with freedom. He could thereby exercise and grow his power without drawing himself into a conflict with the almighty. Morgoth never stood a chance, and neither did the fleet of Númenor, but, had things gone a little differently, Sauron could easily have razed both Gondor and the Shire, and everything in between. Tolkien, however, suggests that Eru intervened in hidden ways, just as the Christian God is said to do. Eru, he writes, saw to it that Bilbo found the Ring, and that Frodo’s failure at Mount Doom was for naught. (It is humorous that, from the available evidence, the post-sundering acts of Eru Ilúvatar, omnipotent father of all and font of gods, seem entirely consigned to manipulating Gollum.) If the God of Gods was indeed intervening, was Sauron’s destruction predestined? If Frodo had faltered, would the deus ex machina have found another way? And why did he take so long, and let the War of the Ring, and all the misery it caused occur? The same reason he let Morgoth’s Fall and the War of Wrath occur. The master craftsman, he knows that his creation needed discord, and needed depth. It needed to be interesting. Why? To add to his ultimate creation, the end to which everything he made hurtled inextricably towards: the Red Book of Westmarch. For the one allfather had his own creator, and he knew how stories work, and he wanted people to buy his book.

As for which soul is weightier? It doesn’t particularly matter, any more than something that came up when I Googled Eru Ilúvater—“Eru Ilúvater power level?” Is he stronger than the Christian God? What about Allah? It’s of course a ridiculous question unanswerable by all but children and perhaps the most scholastic theologists. Each is all. Each is different. Sauron and Morgoth are both as close to absolute evil as evil can get, but they have different domains. One is the elemental evil that shaped the universe, one a scourge in the minds of men. Tolkien even makes an attempt at comparing their powers, but he never sought to seriously answer that. Because after a certain point it’s infinitesimals. Sauron served another, sure, but he was also more conscious of what he was doing, not acting out of pure elemental rage. Is one 0.000001 on the goodness scale, and another 0.00000000001? (Tolkien did not believe in absolute evil.) Who cares? -LAL