Saturday, April 29, 2023

The Existence of Hobbits Proves That The Ring is Not Sauron’s Propaganda, But An Addictive Drug

To be effective in shifting one’s mindset, propaganda needs its receivers to possess two skills: to fear and to desire. Out of all Middle-earth’s races, hobbits are the most capable of great fear and desire, which means that The Ring should corrupt them faster than all other beings in Middle-Earth. Yet, the opposite is the case. Whilst men like Isildur and Boromir are quickly corrupted by The Ring, hobbits such as Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin are slowly or never drawn to possess it as their own. The resistance shared by the Shire-folk community, individuals who both desire and fear more than all else, is no accident. Due to fear of larger creatures, most hobbits spend their entire lives in the Shire: a close-knit community with an abundance of resources. Because of the abundance present, hobbits can usually fulfill their desires and maintain a steady lifestyle of continuous happiness. 

It is this propensity for fear and desire that makes hobbits have such a stable and happy lifestyle. Addictive drugs are the most appealing to those who do not maintain continuous happiness; the ricochet of emotions that unfulfilled desires produce is sedated by an addictive substance. As hobbits maintain a limited form of emotional ricochet, they are the least likely to be vulnerable to the pull of The Ring, as it does not offer an antidote to a problem they experience. All of the other races in Middle-Earth do experience emotional ricochet in varying degrees, which is why – time and time again– The Ring avoids destruction. Hobbits are the most susceptible to the tenants of propaganda and the least susceptible to The Ring, which implies that The Ring is not propaganda. In addition, hobbits experience continuous happiness more than any other creature, which gives them resistance to addictive substances. Therefore, hobbits are resistant to The Ring because their predisposition to maintain an environment of happiness makes them resistant to addictive substances, such as The Ring.

The Ring is not propaganda because the tenants of propaganda: fear and desire, are experienced the most by the group (hobbits) that is the least susceptible to its corruption. In all fearing creatures, the neural mechanisms that produce fear are universal; they are activated when the potential of death is made aware to a being. This means that to have an effect on all fearing creatures, propaganda only needs to create something, such as a group or a concept, that has the potential to cause death to activate the neural mechanisms of fear. As Tolkien writes in the prologue of The Fellowship of the Ring, hobbits as a people experience fear from the beginning when “...the Sea became a word of fear among them, and a token of death, and they turned their faces away from the hills in the west.” Using a cause-and-effect sentence structure, Tolkien makes clear that the cause of the hobbit’s extreme isolation was fear. It is important to note that no other entire race isolated themselves to the extent that hobbits did; therefore, the severity of the hobbit community’s isolation reflects the extreme fear response they are capable of. 

In addition to fear, propaganda needs desire to mobilize one’s fear response towards a specific goal. Fear and desire are not mutually exclusive; the activation of fear results in the desire to alleviate it. Propaganda takes the desire of fear relief and dictates a seemingly perfect plan of action to accomplish the goal. Hobbits experience the capacity to have desire in many cases. For example, throughout The Hobbit and The Fellowship of the Ring, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins is referenced as the source of disappearance for many of Bilbo’s silver spoons during his unexpected journey. Lobelia’s desire for these spoons was so evident that Bilbo decided to give the rest of them to her as he prepares to depart to live with the elves. In addition, the continued incidence of spoon disappearance means that Lobelia’s desire mobilized her to commit thievery while Bilbo was away, likely because she feared that she would never get another golden opportunity to steal the spoons. In this way, Tolkien shows us that hobbits have desires, and the fear of leaving that desire unfulfilled mobilizes them into action to fulfill that desire. If The Ring was propaganda, hobbits should have been seduced by it because they experience both tenants necessary for propaganda to be effective. 

So, if The Ring can’t be propaganda, then what is it?

Because hobbits experience continuous happiness and are not corrupted by The Ring (as fast as others or at all), this implies that The Ring is an addictive substance. The individuals who are most at risk for substance addiction are those who frequently experience mood swings. During a low, a user may take a substance to artificially bring them up to a higher state. However, this desired feeling only lasts as long as the substance is in effect, leading to the user to depend, and then become addicted, to the substance. The Ring gives the wearer a feeling of power and control when possessed; in fact, it literally makes the user invisible and, therefore, in control of the situation. During his first sighting of a Black Rider, Frodo expresses his desire to “slip [The Ring] on. And then he would [feel] safe.” Frodo, who feels apprehensive and out of control in this situation, has a desire to artificially regain control by using the invisibility powers of The Ring. During a later near encounter with a Black Rider, “the desire to slip on The Ring came over Frodo; but this time it was stronger than before.” In this instance, the user Frodo experiences a trigger to use – the feeling of lack of power when a Black Rider is present – and is compelled to use to restore his feeling of control. Because Frodo has already been exposed to The Ring for a longer amount of time during his second Black Rider encounter, a precedent for emotional relief is beginning to form a pattern of behavior that will eventually lead to addiction, hence the ‘stronger’ feeling of wanting to use. 

Other works of Tolkien, such as Farmer Giles, have brought up a theme of farmers and heroism. Given that the real-life counterpart of hobbits is most likely Tolkein’s conception of farmers, the heroism that Tolkein associates is likely due to the resistance of influence that a happy farm-life creates. As this theme remains so persistent, it implies that Tolkien greatly idolizes those who follow a simpler path, as he sees them as the resistors of evil.

-SCJ

Sauron’s Propaganda: Fear, Ambition, and the Curious Case of Hobbits

The history of Middle Earth is littered with examples of Sauron’s corrupting influence. From the fall of Numenor to the many corrupted by the Ring, Sauron clearly has the power to impose his will upon individuals and even whole communities. What’s especially interesting is that this power is impossible to resist; most characters are swayed by Sauron’s will (often through the Ring) almost immediately (such as Smeagol), while even the hardiest give in after enough time (Frodo at Mount Doom). Sauron’s triumph almost feels inevitable for those directly under his influence or that of the Ring.

When discussing the Ring’s power over its bearers, language within the books suggest that they lack the same degree of free will others have. Gollum is an extreme example; Gandalf says that he both hates and loves the ring, but “has no will left in the matter.” Frodo also experiences compulsion even though he had possessed the Ring far less than Gollum—at Weathertop he “felt that he must take the Ring and put it on his finger” and that “resistance became unbearable.” That’s not to say that everyone completely loses all free will under Sauron, nor are characters completely absolved of responsibility for the choices they make while under Sauron’s will. But Sauron appears to reduce the ability to make choices contrary to his will or act against his interests.

This power of Sauron’s is exactly what makes hobbits so fascinating. Hobbits systematically seem to be most able to resist Sauron’s influence and also evil in general, far more so than other races of Middle Earth. Gandalf comments after Frodo survives the splinter of the Morgul-knife (another form of Sauron’s influence) that “hobbits fade very reluctantly,” meaning Frodo was able to hold out against the evil influence. This is borne out by Frodo’s ability to resist the Ring until the very end, far longer than anyone else we’ve seen, and also in how Sam is relatively unaffected by it. This strength of the hobbits is sometimes characterized as stubbornness, which is definitely part of how they are able to resist, but I’m not convinced that’s a full enough explanation.

To understand why hobbits seem to react so uniquely to Sauron’s influence, we first need to understand how Sauron is able to sway people so consistently. Conceiving of Sauron’s influence as propaganda is very useful here, but to see exactly what his propaganda is preying upon requires us to look at actual examples within Tolkien’s work. The two that are most relevant are Sauron’s words as spoken to Ar-Pharazon in the Akallabeth, and Boromir’s conversation with Frodo in which he attempts to take the Ring for himself.

The first visible technique of persuasion is that Sauron or the Ring directly exploit some underlying fear that Boromir and Ar-Pharazon have. Boromir obviously fears the fall of his city, and rants about how unwise he thinks it is to have “a halfling walk blindly into Mordor.” Ar-Pharazon and the Numenoreans in general, meanwhile, fear death, and even before the arrival of Sauron they question why they are subject to death while the elves are not. Sauron then exploits this fear, pushing the character to act in a way that is dangerous and harmful.

Yet I would argue fear alone isn’t enough to explain why Sauron’s propaganda is so effective; he’s also exploiting the underlying ambition of the characters as well. It’s telling that Boromir’s train of thought on how to use the Ring first begins with using it against the Enemy, but ends with him envisioning himself as leader of the host. There’s clearly an underlying ambition of being recognized and admired as a powerful leader. Ar-Pharazon also desires power—when he arrives in Arda, he “claim[ed] the land for his own,” suggesting he is immensely ambitious given he is claiming the literal land of the gods. 

This combination of fear and ambition combines under evil influence to produce a sense of entitlement or ownership over something the character definitely does not control. Boromir finishes his rambling speech, in which he slowly appears more and more corrupted by the Ring’s influence, by declaring that “men of Numernor” are the true owners of the Ring and that “it should be mine.” We have been told numerous times that attempting to claim the Ring is impossible, and yet the Ring’s exploitation of Boromir’s fear and ambition allows it to happen. Similarly, Sauron convinces Ar-Pharazon to sail west by telling him that “the gift of life … is only for such as are worthy, being men of might and pride and great lineage,” suggesting it is unfair that “the King of Kings” Ar-Pharazon is deprived of the eternal life he deserves.

So Sauron is able to influence the wills of others through propaganda that preys on their fear and ambition, thus developing a sense of entitlement to something they cannot control. This then opens them to evil action. Now that we’ve established how Sauron’s propaganda is effective, we can look to hobbits to find why this may not influence them to the same degree it does Men. It would be silly to claim hobbits don’t fear—Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin definitely experience fear throughout the course of the books. It is true that your average hobbit is definitely insulated from fears on the scale that Boromir and Ar-Pharazon experienced, but they can still be scared. Ambition, on the other hand, is worth looking more closely at.

In general, hobbits could best be described as being content with the Shire. Bilbo is thought of as very odd for having left to go on his adventures in The Hobbit, and adventuring in general is described as “not entirely hobbitlike.” Furthermore, when meeting Gandalf, Bilbo declares “We are plain quiet folk and have no use for adventures …. Make you late for dinner!” Bilbo is of course not being entirely honest about his own desire for adventures, but his sentiment is broadly true—hobbits don’t really have grand desires or ambitions beyond the borders of the Shire. In fact, Bilbo’s comment on dinner feels particularly apt, as hobbits are generally more concerned with food and simple pleasures than any sort of ambition Sauron could easily exploit.

This relative lack of ambition then eliminates the sense of entitlement or ownership that corrupted both Boromir and Ar-Pharazon. Hobbit society in general comes across as fairly generous—it is the custom to give out presents on one’s birthday instead of receiving them. They are not without greed, as the Sackville-Bagginses can attest, but it is again limited to things far beneath Sauron’s concern (e.g. the possession of Bilbo’s silver spoons). Thus if hobbits don’t really have worldly ambitions or entitlement that Sauron can effect, it stands to reason that they would be much more resistant to his “propaganda” than those whose lives involve the fate of kingdoms. Hobbits are on a much smaller scale than Sauron ever bothers to think, and combined with their stubbornness that makes them poor targets for Sauron’s will.

-AS

Sauron Supreme: Analyzing Middle-Earth's Rogues Gallery with Tolkien's Conception of Evil

We are following
The will of the one
Through the dark age
And into the storm 
- "Into the Storm" by Blind Guardian

In our discussion on the Ring and Sauron this week, we came upon this idea of evil being the domination of the free will of others. And this works extremely well with both the lore of Middle-Earth, but also Christian beliefs. And ultimately, this gives us Sauron as the great villain of Middle-Earth, because he is the personification of this idea of evil.

To start, consider Saruman. He, believing himself wise (as even Gandalf calls him!), wants to control the world. He says to Gandalf,

The time of the Elves is over, but our time is at hand: the world of Men, which we must rule. But we must have power, power to order all things as we will, for that good which only the Wise can see... and the Wise, such as you and I, may with patience come at last to direct its courses, to control it. (The Lord of the Rings, 259).

His goal, should he obtain the Ring, is to order the world according to "Knowledge, Rule, Order" (The Lord of the Rings, 259). But, even if this was good-intentioned, there is still the lust for power and for dominating the will of others. Therefore, in this conception, Saruman is very clearly evil.

His methods are just as important as his intentions. Saruman speaks in this very political, doublethink fashion. He tries to trick Gandalf and manages to trick Radagast, and all the while playing both sides with Sauron. Should Saruman obtain the Ring, there would undoubtedly be a more forceful domination, but without it, Saruman relies on his sly tongue in order to dominate the will of others. He uses propaganda.

And this perfectly parallels Christian belief. When the serpent convinced Eve to eat of the Tree of Knowledge, he does not force her. He tricks her into doing his bidding, convincing her not only that it is a good idea, but that she wants to do it. He dominates her will in the most powerful way possible: convincing her it is her own. Paralleling this, Eve then convinces Adam to do the same, dominating him with her will (although it is really the serpent's will). Just as Frodo fails, choosing evil because his will is so thoroughly dominated, so Man falls.

The other major force of evil in Middle-Earth (besides the obvious conclusion) is Morgoth. And, admittedly, Morgoth struggles to fit into this as neatly. In contrast with Saruman and Sauron, Morgoth is a very reactive character; he introduces dissonance, knocks over the lamps, destroys the trees, steals the Silmarils. He does not seem to want to dominate the wills over the other Ainur or Ilúvatar; rather, he wants to dominate their creations, namely in stealing or destroying them. As I noted in a blog comment, I think this stems from the initial rejection of Melkor's creation, and that leads to a bitterness such that he wants to destroy other's creations. Therefore, I struggle to see how he fits in with this idea of evil, considering he is undoubtedly evil by the end.

But at the same time, though not written by Tolkien, Blind Guardian's incredible "Into the Storm" has the exact same ideas. "We are following / The will of the one" has a very subtle, yet important word choice. It is not just following someone, like a great leader or exemplary figure; it is following the will, letting your will be dominated by someone else. And the song is very clearly about Morgoth, with the lyrics "The Silmarils / Gems of treelight / Their life belongs to me." Thus, there is absolutely something with Morgoth about dominating wills, but the question becomes what. This is something that I am unsure on but would like to discuss further.

Now, we come to the big bad to end them all: Sauron. What makes Sauron special, in this conception of evil and against the other rogues of Middle-Earth, is that he is the most pure, distilled form of domination over free will, specifically because of his ultimate goal and how he attacks it from all possible angles. 

In Akallabêth, Sauron is described as doing essentially the exact same things that Saruman attempts to do with the Númenóreans—and it works. Númenor is drowned while Sauron laughs, even as his fair form is destroyed. Sauron, at least for a period of time, was capable of acting in this sly form, tricking and deceiving in order to dominate the will of others.

But we also see him act with open intention, as is stated during the council of Elrond: "'The time of my thought is my own to spend,' answered Daín. 'For the present,' said [Sauron's messenger], and rode into the darkness" (The Lord of the Rings, 241). The intentions of the Nazgûl are similarly open:

In their white faces burned keen and merciless eyes; under their mantles were long grey robes; upon their grey hairs were helms of silver; in their haggard hands were swords of steel. Their eyes fell on him and pierced him, as they rushed towards him… The third was taller than the others: his hair was long and gleaming and on his helm was a crown. In one hand he held a long sword, and in the other a knife; both the knife and the hand that held it glowed with a pale light. (The Lord the Rings, 196)

They are, in appearance, unquestionably evil, and their following actions reflect this. Sauron is capable of both honesty and deception in the pursuit of his domination. He can openly tell you "I will soon be controlling your thoughts," but he can also weasel his way to become a great advisor and lead to the downfall of a once-great city.

And this is the strength of the Rings as well. Through the Rings given to the Nine, Sauron creates the Nazgûl, his most powerful servants that are completely enslaved to him, with no will of their own. Likewise, through the One Ring and its propagandistic powers, Sauron is able to spread his control far and wide and is able to exert his will over others. This domination is so powerful that, "Of ‘mortals’ no one, not even Aragorn" could resist the Ring at the Cracks of Doom (Letters, #246). And when Frodo fails, it is not just that he is unable to throw the Ring in, but that he says he chooses not to. The Ring controls him to the extent that its will is unrecognizable from his own. Thus, the Ring, as a separate entity, is just as much a part of Sauron's desire to completely dominate the will of all as his own personal actions are.

To tie all this together, through the various villains of Middle-Earth (including those I have not discussed), Tolkien helps to cultivate this idea of evil as dominating free will. Some are clearer than others (Saruman versus Morgoth), but this conception is clear and works extremely well with Christian faith, specifically the Fall. This allows Tolkien to craft Sauron as the ultimate form and personification of evil, a being whose sole goal and purpose is to dominate the wills of others in any and every possible way. He is the Joker to Middle-Earth's Batman. He is the ultimate villain because he is evil incarnate.

-CVB

Remembrance as Redemption

Recently in class we have been wrestling with the question of why evil exists. While I was pondering this, an idea came to me which did not completely satisfy this question, but at least gave me an interesting new angle from which to look: remembrance and forgetfulness. Does the desire to sin stem from a failure to remember what is true and good? Perhaps not; but although forgetfulness is not the ultimate cause and memory is not the ultimate solution, I do believe remembrance can play a part in the fight against evil.

To begin with, Sauron persuades the Numenoreans that the Valar are liars who are afraid of Men taking their power, hence the ban. The Men forget how Illuvatar (not the Valar!) made them: as mortal beings endowed with the “gift” of death, a nature that they cannot change. Sauron causes them to forget that it is not the land of the Valar or the Valar themselves that confer eternal life, but Illuvatar alone. They forget that death is not something Men can shirk by simply sailing West. If they had remembered these things and resisted the whisperings of Sauron, the story of Numenor might have ended differently. Memory can be a powerful weapon to deploy against propaganda like the words of Sauron; we will see the Ring’s battle with memory in a moment, but first let us examine how memory acts against evil when Frodo wakes up in the barrow:

  “But though his fear was so great that it seemed to be part of the very darkness that was round him, he found himself as he lay thinking of Bilbo Baggins and his stories, of their jogging along together in the lanes of the Shire and talking about roads and adventures. . . . He thought he had come to the end of his adventure, and a terrible end, but the thought hardened him. He found himself stiffening, as if for a final spring; he no longer felt limp like helpless prey” (Bk 1 Ch VIII).

Frodo’s memories of the Shire and the stories connected to it stir within him the potential for a renewed strength, even in the face of hopelessness and defeat. Something about his memories allow him to resist the power of evil– here, the power of the death-filled atmosphere of the barrow and the barrow-wights. This is also a strengthening of his own will, banishing the feeling of being “helpless prey” who is under the force of someone or something else.

Just like how Frodo’s remembrance of Bilbo gives him strength when hope seems lost in the barrow, it likewise strengthens Sam when, on the way to Mount Doom, he realizes that there will be not return journey: 

  “But I would dearly like to see Bywater again, and Rosie Cotton and her brothers, and the Gaffer and Marigold and all. . . . But even as hope died in Sam, or seemed to die, it was turned to a new strength” (Bk 6 Ch III).

In both of these examples, it is only after remembering good things that the characters are able to persevere in the fight against evil. In particularly hopeless moments– when Frodo thinks his journey will end in the barrow and when Sam realizes he will never go home– the only sanctuary is that of remembrance, and this remembrance has a real, physical power to embolden them to go on.

As a final example, we can see the workings of the Ring against memory in Frodo’s response to Sam when he last looks at his cooking gear before casting it away:

    “‘Do you remember that bit of rabbit, Mr. Frodo?’ he said. ‘And our place under the warm bank in Captain Faramir’s country, the day I saw an oliphaunt?’
    ‘No, I am afraid not, Sam,’ said Frodo. ‘At least, I know that such things happened, but I cannot see them. No taste of food, no feel of water, no sound of wind, no memory of tree or glass or flower, no image of moon or star are left to me’” (Bk 6 Ch 3).

The Ring has taken away Frodo’s ability to remember, especially to remember good, pure things like trees and stars and food. In fact, the simplicity and ordinariness of these things is what makes this specific power of the Ring so frightening– everyone should be able to remember what a tree looks like. But the strength of the Ring is such that nothing Frodo knew can be relied upon anymore. The power of the propaganda is so strong that even the simplest truth may seem foreign or hostile.
 
I think a crucial part of remembrance is that it is more than just “recollection.” Frodo could “recall” the rabbit, Faramir, and the oliphaunt; but he couldn’t “see,” “feel,” “taste,” or hear any part of those moments. True remembrance requires making things present and real again in an embodied way, through the senses. There must be a reason Christ said “do this in remembrance of me,” and not just “remember me.” Remembering is doing. I think this is in part why Tolkien places such emphasis on passing down stories through songs and poetry– we need stories to be incarnate in order to remember them! Once a story is ingrained in us in a physical way, it is easier to remember and to be able to conform ourselves to them whenever we need to– when we are fighting against evil, for instance. I think this is demonstrated well by a comment from LeGuin about writing her chapter entitled “The Child and the Shadow.” As a child, she read the Andersen story about the man and his shadow, and she didn’t really like it and she certainly didn’t understand it. But now, as an adult, she is able to remember this story and apply it (even subconsciously) to greater things outside of a simple children’s fairytale.

-LJE

Thursday, April 27, 2023

The Gift of Death and The Envy of Life

Continuing with the comparison to the Catholic canon from our discussion of the Ainulindale, Akallabeth mirrors the fall of man described in Genesis 3.  This is fairly obvious with the prohibition of sailing to the west, the rejection of that prohibition, and the outcome of death because of failing to listen to the Valar, but there are some distinct differences that highlight the questions of why we die and why we would fall into evil if we live on paradise.Again, since Tolkien was trying to replicate the existing Christian myth in his own sub-creation, the differences must highlight truths instead of confusing them.    

Akallabeth, like Genesis, claims that Iluvatar gave the Numenoreans death, but unlike is Biblical counterpart, this happens before the fall.  The first description gives death a negative connotation,"But they did not thus escape from the doom of death that Iluvatar had set upon all mankind, and they were mortal still." Later on the same page, though, the narrator calls it, "the gift of death" denoting that death itself is positive in some way, especially since it occurs pre-fall.   

In Genesis 3, Adam and Eve seem to know about the concept of death since the Snake tempts them by saying they will not die but instead become like God, but it is unclear whether or not they have the ability to die in Eden. Death is not mentioned until God lists the punishment for Adam where the idea of returning to dust is in conjunction with working the fields. This line also seems to imply that Adam was mortal beforehand, but now he must do hard work until he dies. The one line which contradicts this reading is verse 22 where God claims, "The man has now become like one of us, knowing good and evil. He must not be allowed to reach out his hand and take also from the tree of life and eat, and live forever." This implies that Adam would have lived forever had he not fallen, but the Hebrew word translated as "forever" is le'olam, which can also be translated as "a long time". This would be consistent with the Akallabeth reading of man living a long time but never getting sick.  

The question of the fall becomes more interesting as Genesis and Akallabeth seem to diverge after this; In Genesis, Adam and Eve do not question the prohibition of the tree until tempted by the snake whereas in Akallabeth, the Numenoreans ask the Messengers themselves why they should not fear death before Sauron appears.  We had discussed in class that Sauron is more akin to a demon or devil worshipper than Lucifer himself, whereas Morgoth is the Lucifer stand-in for the Numenor and Middle-Earth.  Even though Sauron acts as the tempter, before he arrives we are told Morgoth had already "cast his shadow on the world". This fits well with the broader idea of temptation being a constant force and not necessarily a one-off event as represented in Genesis 3.  Perhaps Adam and Eve were always tempted and acted so quickly by the Snake's temptation because they had thought about this before. This would be tthe same level of escalation for the Numenoreans who we see questioning the Valar and then only taking action to sail west once Sauron arrives.

So the question still remains as to why? To answer this, we should characterize death more thoroughly. 

1. Even though death is a gift from Iluvatar, the Numenoreans do not see it that way.  They envy the Valar who do not die, and it is this comparison that makes them question.

2. The reason the Numenoreans envy the Valar for not dying is because they think by dying they are going in with "blind trust" and "knowing not what lies before us".  It is the fear of not knowing. 

These two things seem to make light of the possibilities of why one would fall from paradise.  First and foremost the unequal treatment strikes one as being unjust instead of diverse.  For this comparison I thought of Cain and Abel's story in Genesis 4 rather than Genesis 3. Because God had praised Abel's gift and not Cain's this jealousy led to Cain murdering Abel. This idea of envy leading to murder is a consistent theme which we see in Feanor's story of the Silmarils as well as the story of the ring, particularly Gollum's story.  You could almost read Cain and Abel as an alternative fall story as it isn't until Cain kills is he sent out from the land, another sinking of Numenor.   

All of this is backed by the idea of the envy coming from a lack of understanding and a wanting of information. In Eden, Adam and Eve wanted knowledge to be like God, the Numenoreans wanted knowledge to be like the Valar, and Cain wanted to be like his brother Abel. This particular envy is the envy to be something other than oneself, the envy of being another. It's wasn't just wanting to know, but wanting to be.  It is against the harmony of creation, and if anything, it is the clearest example of what the discord of creation looks like. I was struggling to figure out exactly what discord looked like, but this idea of envying the being of another seems to somewhat fit.  

The Akallabeth notes, "But for all this, death did not depart from the land, rather it came sooner and more often".  

It is not that death was the issue, as death was an essential part of mortal being, but an agonizing death. But the Numenoreans and those in Eden did not understand this. 

I'm not sure if it fully answers the question we left hanging at the end of class, but this idea of envying the essence of another and wanting to become that, to deny your own creation, seems to be on some track given Tolkien's myth and Genesis.

-Gabby Bayness