Tuesday, May 9, 2023

More Religious Symbolism in the Silmarils

 In class last Thursday, we discussed the symbolism and meaning found within the central story of the Silmarillion, that of the jewels themselves. The Silmarils, as created by Fëanor, are a set of three jewels, unrivaled throughout all of Middle Earth, so much so that protracted wars were fought over them. Most importantly, the Silmarils contain the light of the trees, Telperion and Laurelin, which provides to them a light and inner beauty that makes them so coveted. Due to this beauty, the Vala Melkor covets the jewels, going as far as to first rob the world of the light of the trees, leaving only the jewels to remain as their bearer, and then kill Fëanor’s father to steal them for himself.

Tolkien’s Christian (and more specifically, Roman Catholic) faith is hardly obscured in his works. Famously, he said that “The Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision” (Letters, 142). Based on this, it is wholly unsurprising that we would find religious symbolism and parallels in his works. At the same time, it is important not to fall into the trap of allegory. Tolkien also famously hated allegory, saying it detracts from the work and the universe. If you write with metaphors and symbols, then the reader can read what they want into those. If you work instead with allegory, however, then there is only one way to read your work, and that is as a whole, and mapped onto some other work or event. This type of writing is antithetical to Tolkien’s, as your read would never be deeper than the event it is based on, while his works seemingly have the depth of the real world.

With this being said, religious metaphor and symbolism does find its way into Tolkien’s writing with regularity, being a religious work. The Book of Revelation provides a description of the city of Jerusalem coming out of heaven in the end times, which in and of itself bears many similarities to things in Tolkien’s works. The city on Túna is described in a fairly paradisal way, being home to the Valar in Valinor. The city from Revelation bears the strongest resemblance to Gondolin, however. In Revelation, it is said “And he carried me away in the spirit to a great and high mountain, and shewed me that great city, the holy Jerusalem, descending out of heaven from God” (21:10, KJV) as well as “And had a wall great and high, and had twelve gates, and at the gates twelve angels, and names written thereon, which are the names of the twelve tribes of the children of Israel” (21:12). Gondolin, meanwhile, is a city hidden among the mountains, so hidden that one must be shown it, which has guarding it seven unique gates before the entrance one must pass through. Neither of these is a perfect fit, although I find Gondolin a more compelling candidate. Similarly, it is this lack of a perfect fit for things that makes Tolkien’s writing non-allegorical. The reader can read whatever of these Biblical stories into it as they want, or none. It is a part of what gives his writing the mystique of “Did his stories come from ours, or ours from his, somewhere way back in history?”.

One of the most compelling parallels I have noticed, however, is that of Silmarils with the forbidden fruit in Genesis. There are many similarities between the way Tolkien treats the Silmarils and the effects they have with the Biblical story of the first humans on Earth.

For starters, there is the obvious comparison that they both come from trees in some way. Genesis 2:17 states “but you must not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, for when you eat from it you will certainly die.” The Silmarils, likewise, contain the light of the trees, as created by Fëanor. In this sense, we could say that just as the knowledge the fruit contains is an emanation of the Tree, the light contained within the Silmarils is also an emanation of their respective trees.

The trees, and thus their light, originate in the home of the Valar, Valinor. Though I vaguely compared it to Jerusalem earlier, it is a more apt comparison to liken it to Eden, given that there, the Elves live alongside the Valar, the refracted lights of Eru made physical, or their gods. They are described similarly, as being a lush paradise unspoiled by mortals. This is not an uncommon comparison for scholars of Tolkien, and strengthens the association between the Silmarils and the forbidden fruit.

For a few minor points, the Silmarils themselves are described as being unrecreatable, that the knowledge of how to make them was lost alongside their actual creation. This serves as a storytelling element to make them rare and more desirable, but also reinforces their connection with knowledge. Additionally, Fëanor was one of the Noldor, literally meaning “those with knowledge” in Quenya.

The light of the trees, additionally, was “drank” by Ungoliant in Melkor’s plot. This phrasing makes the light seem like a food, or at least something that can be physically consumed, furthering the connection.

Most strongly in relation to Tolkien’s specifically Catholic faith, however, is the Silmaril’s connection to original sin. In his quest to reclaim the Silmarils, Fëanor swears a “terrible oath” that he and his descendants will reclaim the jewels no matter the cost. In doing so, they war for years, even going as far as the kin-slaying, the killing of other Elves in Valinor to steal their ships and pursue Melkor. The Elves that arrive in Beleriand to chase him later settle in Middle Earth after the end of the wars. Not every Elf in Middle Earth is a descendant of or one of those who did the kin-slaying, but many are, and their exile in mortal lands is a constant reminder of their separation from their paradise. In many ways, the consumption of the forbidden fruit by Adam and Eve and man’s subsequent mortality and separation from God is extremely analogous.

These types of comparisons are everywhere in Tolkien’s works if one looks for them, but leave a large amount of room for interpretation in them. It is this inspiration but also room for interpretation that, in part, makes his writing and world seem so magical and connected with our own.

-BTS

Monday, May 8, 2023

Jewelry and its Purpose

 Something that stuck with me after Thursday’s lecture was the question of why Faery clothing and jewelry are so radically different from our own and why that might be.  We discussed the idea that medieval-style jewelry might be embarrassing, or too ornamental for a place like corporate America, which necessitates conformative dress.  I also think the religious context of many jewelry items contributes to this difference between the medieval and the modern. In Medieval times, jewelry was often commissioned by the Church or the wealthy for commemorative purposes or as reliquaries.  The association between wealth, religion, and display, meant these pieces were exclusive and for a small, elite group. Today, religious jewelry serves a broader audience and is intended for everyday wear, so affordability and practicality matter more than show.  As a result, these pieces are smaller and less elaborate.  Anecdotally, I suspect there has also been a shift in the attitudes towards flashy religious pieces.  Growing up Catholic, many of my family members word scapulars and rosaries.  However, I was always told that those items were meant to be worn under clothes rather than seen, because showing them off defeated their purpose.  Religious practice was for the individual, not for others.


However, I think the key to the radical difference between Faery and modern jewelry lies in the purpose of medieval jewelry which we discussed in class.  In addition to reliquaries, jewelry served many purposes such as a ring used to seal a document, a brooch used to fasten clothing, or a pendant used to hold perfume or other scents.  This practicality, in addition to the value of jewelry as a status symbol during the Middle Ages, made it a prominent part of daily life which is not particularly relevant today.  We no longer have a widespread need to seal letters, we have buttons to fasten our clothes, and if we really need perfume on the go, a purse does the trick.  Digital banking negates the need to put your wealth into gems and precious metals, and technological advances have created a new kind of status symbol in cars and gadgets.  However, the intention of jewelry that exists in the Middle Ages applies in Middle Earth with one notable difference.  The jewelry of Middle Earth serves less physical but nevertheless important purposes.  They are vessels of power, and their appearance reflects this significance. 


For example, this week we discussed the Silmarils and their appearance and purpose. They were created by Fëanor as “he pondered how the light of the Trees [of Valinor], the glory of the Blessed Realm, might be preserved imperishable” (The Silmarillion, 67). The Silmarils were described as having a bright inner light, as if containing the essence of the Two Trees of Valinor, which gave light to the world before they were destroyed by the dark lord Morgoth. They were crystal-like and appeared to be on fire, and they were said to change color depending on the angle and intensity of the light.  Feanor created the Silmarils from three different types of light: the light of the Two Trees of Valinor, the starlight of Varda, and his own inner flame. Each Silmaril contained a different type of light and was set into a beautiful golden chain, called the "Nauglamir," which was also crafted by Feanor.  Their beauty conveys their power by drawing desire.  They attract a “greedy love” and were the cause of war at the hands of Melkor. 


Another example of powerful and beautiful jewelry is the Elfstone, Elessar, given by Galadriel to Aragorn, or the analogical Evenstar he is given by Arwen in the movies.  The Eflstone was a green gem set in a silver eagle-shaped brooch. It was a token of friendship and a symbol of Aragorn's future as the rightful king of Gondor.  The stone was also said to have healing properties, which were said to be able to cure wounds and illnesses.  The Elfstone, much like the Silmarils, was also supposed to contain light (specifically the light of the Sun).  Also like the Silmarils, this elaborate piece of jewelry contained a power to be wielded and envied. 


Lastly, I want to address the most important, yet most plain, unadorned piece of jewelry in Middle Earth: the One Ring. The One Ring is intentionally plain and unadorned in contrast to the highly ornate and decorative jewelry of Middle-earth because it is meant to be the ultimate tool of power.  The ring was created by Sauron to consolidate his power over the other races of Middle-earth, and its design reflects this purpose. Rather than being highly ornate, the ring is unassuming and inconspicuous, allowing its wearer to blend in and avoid drawing attention to themselves. The plainness of the ring also serves to mask its true nature as a powerful artifact, which is crucial to Sauron's plan to use it to dominate all of Middle-earth.


Furthermore, the simplicity of the ring's design makes it more relatable to a wider audience. Unlike the highly ornate and specialized jewelry of the elves or dwarves, the One Ring is a simple gold band that could be worn by anyone. This makes it all the more dangerous, as it can appeal to anyone who desires power or control, regardless of their background or allegiances. - JMR


Saturday, May 6, 2023

Are the Jewels Worth the Dragon?

 . . . Though now long estranged,

Man is not wholly lost nor wholly changed.

Dis-graced he may be, yet is not dethroned,

and keeps the rags of lordship once he owned,

his world-dominion by creative act:

not his to worship the great Artefact,

Man, Sub-creator, the refracted light

through whom is splintered from a single White

to many hues, and endlessly combined

in living shapes that move from mind to mind.


J.R.R. Tolkien, Mythopoeia


Lately we’ve been exploring the nature of dragons and their connection to the jewels which they are so famous for hoarding. I would like to address a few of the questions we grappled with during discussion. To begin with: What category of creature does “dragon” fall under: monster, animal, person– and is it the same category as Sauron or Morgoth? 


Dragons do not seem to fit into any one category: they are monsters but also animals, but have a human-like rationality; they are hybrid and unfamiliar, but can be predictable. The only category they fall into completely is “imaginary.” Monsters are artifacts. Like mixing up adjectives and nouns (like “green sun”), we can mix up natural elements in new ways to create monsters (like dragons) in our secondary world. Dragons are an example of subcreation, but the kind of subcreation that acts back on us, making them terrifying and dangerous. Like Feanor creating the Silmarils that subsequently corrupt him, we create dragons that scare and threaten us. Worse than these threats, however, is this crucial aspect of a dragon’s nature: hoarding jewels.


What are Tolkien’s jewels? We can see clearly from his description of the Silmarils that they are much more than pretty stones:


“Yet that crystal was to the Silmarils but as is the body to the Children of Illuvatar: the house of its inner fire, that is within it and yet in all parts of it, and is its life. . . . Therefore even in the darkness of the deepest treasury the Silmarils of their own radiance shone like the stars of Varda; and yet, as were they indeed living things, they rejoiced in light and received it and gave it back in hues more marvelous than before” (Quenta Silmarillion ch. 7). 


Jewels are good subcreations, through which the “refracted light” can shimmer. They are little incarnations, because the light inside is not from the subcreator, but the primary Creator. Now Morgoth, the destroyer of the subcreation of the Valar, would undoubtedly want to demolish these jewels completely. However, dragons are not creators or destroyers like Morgoth– they are not evil in the same way, wanting instead to hoard the gems, but not use them (for good or ill) or do away with them. Dragons effectively prevent anyone else from seeing the jewels in their splendor. 


“There he lay, a vast red-golden dragon, fast asleep; thrumming came from his jaws and nostrils, and wisps of smoke, but his fires were low in slumber. Beneath him, under all his limbs and his huge coiled tail, and about him on all sides stretching away across the unseen floors, lay countless piles of precious things, gold wrought and unwrought, gems and jewels, and silver red-stained in the ruddy light. . . . Dragons may not have much real use for all their wealth, but they know it to an ounce as a rule, especially after long possession, and Smaug was no exception” (The Hobbit ch. 12).


So why is it so essential that we defeat the dragon? If dragons are so dangerous, it certainly is tempting to leave them alone with their hoard and abandon all hope of seeing the jewels… but this is dissatisfying. We all want to see the dragon slain, don’t we? But even admitting that the dragon exists is embarrassing. Acknowledging the use of the imagination, especially to the extent of conjuring up dragons, is childish and unproductive, and we are embarrassed of that. We are afraid of the monster because we are afraid to use our imagination. And this fear may be warranted– dragons are indeed dangerous, as are the Silmarils and the Ring. But is this fear enough to let us be complacent with the dragon, and let him sit peacefully on his hoard?


No. The jewels are worth the fight. If the dragons are the worst of our imagination, the jewels are the best of it. If we give in to the fear of the dragon, we miss the jewels, which are more than just a subcreation of imagination: they hold the light! We are meant to see the jewels, and to want to make the jewels, as we are meant to subcreate because we are made in the image and likeness of the Creator. If we are afraid of our own imagination, we would never make good subcreations; if we never confront the dragon, we will never get to the jewels.


And if we cannot believe in the jewels– that the jewels are worth fighting a dragon for– how can we believe in the story of the greatest Jewel, the mother who held the Light in her womb? How can we believe in the story of the Incarnation, or the transformation of bread into flesh? A belief like this requires the imagination that the dragons guard by fear– only this time the stakes are much higher, since the imagination is not subcreating something new, but instead helping us to understand reality. Imagination used in this way fuels belief, and we must fight the embarrassment that condemns both imagination and belief as childish or unproductive. The glory and majesty of the jewels demand that we slay the dragon.


-LJE

Friday, May 5, 2023

Of Monsters and Men

 For years, I have been haunted by a recurring nightmare. In it, my friends and I are relentlessly pursued by a horde of monsters. One by one, they succumb to the horde's grasp and are transformed into one of them. As I was running frantically, doubts start to creep into my mind. Are they still my friends or purely monster? The line between them blurs, leaving me with an ominous feeling of uncertainty. As the chase continues, I feel a growing sense of dread. Despite my efforts to outrun the horde, I eventually succumb to their clutches. The feeling of being enveloped by the swarm is suffocating, and I am left wondering if I too will become one of them. This is where the nightmare always ends, leaving me with an unsettling feeling that lingers long after I wake up. Will I be able to resist the transformation and retain my humanity, or will I become just another monster in the horde? The answer remains a mystery to me. 

This dream has left me with a thought-provoking question: what truly differentiates a monster from a human? Is there a clear-cut boundary that separates the two, or is it a blurred line that can be crossed? Could it be that there is no boundary at all, and that monsters and humans are capable of transforming into each other? To explore these questions, I will begin by offering my definitions of monsters, both in a narrow and general sense. Then, I will examine the concept of monsters transforming into humans and vice versa. To illustrate my analysis, I have created an illustration inspired by Professor Brown's lecture, which I will elaborate on.


In my understanding, monsters can be narrowly defined as creatures that are often depicted as physically grotesque, with features such as horns, claws, or skeletal appearances. While they may not necessarily be dangerous, they are meant to be quite spooky in nature. If we adhere to this narrow definition, we can easily understand the first two pictures in the illustration. Sméagol, who lacks any of the monstrous features, can be classified as a human. On the other hand, Jack the Pumpkin King's appearance certainly qualifies him as a monster.


In a broader sense, monsters can be defined as beings that are different from humans, often labeled as "The Other." Therefore, we can define a monster by first defining what it means to be human. In my understanding, human life is complex. We experience a range of emotions, from love and hate to happiness and melancholy. We have the ability to pursue multiple interests, such as being a scientist while also loving art. We can create and appreciate the creations of others. In contrast, monsters like Smaug may spend their entire day sleeping on a hoard of gold with no other thoughts in mind. Their minds are often twisted, and their lives are reduced to a single-minded pursuit.

From this definition, we can say that it was after Sméagol's first sin, murdering for the Ring, that he turned into Gollum, a human into a monster, even though he still looked like a human being at the time. Sméagol's transformation into Gollum is a perfect example of how a human can turn into a monster, if we accept the general definition of a monster. There are many more "Sméagols" in our world, such as Doctor Faustus in Thomas Mann's novel. These cases are well-known and have been extensively discussed, so I will not delve into further detail about them. Later, after I finish introducing cases where monsters can also turn into humans, I will present another case of "human turning into monster," but in a completely different sense than the Sméagol case.

Having established why Sméagol is considered a "monster" in the third picture, the question arises as to why Jack is labeled as a "man." To answer this question, we may benefit from watching a video:

Right after this scene, Sally, the most angelic girl in all worlds, says, “Jack, I know how you feel." I believe that she is not the only one, both inside and outside of the screen, who feels this way. This moment marks the breaking of the boundary between human and monster. No one would deny Jack's humanity, as his thoughts seem to have resonated with many of us. This video illustrates that Jack is quite different from standard monsters such as Smaug and Sméagol, according to our previous definition. While those monsters are often portrayed as having singular, spooky, and monstrous routines, Jack is seeking something beyond his usual routine. This is what evokes our familiar feeling and makes him relatable. In this modern age, many human beings have been reduced to mere tools and pseudo-monsters. Seeking a moment of escape and doing something different is an instinctive response to restore a part of our humanity that has been lost. Returning to the film, despite Jack's bitter and arduous Christmas journey, we begin to perceive a human soul within his hollow bones, especially in the final scene where he realized what is truly precious in his “life”. It is at this point that I believe Jack, the king of monsters, has transcended his monstrous nature and become a fully realized human being, and that this nightmare has transformed into a sweet dream.



In the last part of my discussion, we'll be looking at a sensitive topic - another case of a human “turning” into a "monster." You might have noticed the quotation marks I used here; this means that the terms “turning" and "monster" have a different connotation than in the case of Sméagol. Although it is regrettable to admit, the term "monster" has been used not only to describe actual monsters we mentioned before, but also those who are not. Throughout thousands of years of intolerance, those who hold different ideas from those in authority, and anyone who shows sympathy towards them, have often been labeled as monsters. If their voices are too weak to defend themselves, they would be viewed by those who are unaware of the truth as evil wolves lurking in the forest. Even if they follow the way of the Lamb faithfully, they are deemed to have a wolf's heart beneath their sheepskin.


Stephen King once said, "The trust of the innocent is the liar's most useful tool." While this may explain some cases of how lambs are "turned" into "wolves," it cannot account for all such cases. Recently, through a lecture, I learned that there may be an even more brutal reason behind this “transformation”. During the lecture, we reviewed Mark 5:15-17, which I hadn't paid much attention to before:


And they came to Jesus, and they see him that was troubled with the devil, sitting, clothed, and well in his wits, and they were afraid.

And they that had seen it, told them, in what manner he had been dealt with who had the devil; and concerning the swine.

And they began to pray him that he would depart from their coasts.


After Jesus successfully drove away the demons and turned the "monster" back into a human, he was not met with cheers from the crowd, but instead with fear. Now, Jesus himself became the "unwelcome one" or even worse, the new "monster" in the eyes of the people. I couldn't understand this story before, but after the lecture, everything makes sense: perhaps a monster is what the community needs. People need a scapegoat to blame everything on so that they can feel human. By labeling this scapegoat a “monster”, they absolve themselves of guilt and can easily throw stones at him. Jesus, with his love for humanity, could not bear to witness this tragedy unfold, as those who threw stones at the "monster" were actually throwing stones at their own souls. Therefore, he saved us from it, even at the cost of becoming the new "monster" and being sacrificed for the bloodthirsty nature of humanity. Although the "monster-transforming ritual" may continue, he planted a seed of hope in our hearts, and this hope will never fade as long as we follow his way. For those walking the Way of Sorrows, I have a poem to share:


-Y.P.L.

Gondor and Byzantium

    Frequently, it is asserted that Tolkien consciously rejected the Classics in his works to focus on Medieval themes. But this assertion is unmerited. Most prominently, Numenor is explicitly a recasting of the Atlantis myth (and the name of the island is even Talante in Elvish). The most blatant in LotR itself are the overt parallels running between the Gondor storylines and the Iliad. An excellent paper on this topic is Troy and the Rings: Tolkien and the Medieval Myth of England by Michael Livingston. Briefly, Livingston argues that Minas Tirith parallels Troy; Boromir, Faramir, and Denethor parallel Hector, Paris, and Priam; and a connection is made to Layamon’s Brut to explain why the Trojan-like characters are good. But more interesting are the ways in which Tolkien has changed the legend. Boromir’s belt parallels Hector’s, but while Hector’s corpse is dragged around Troy by it, Boromir’s is only laid on his body before it is sent out to sea. But Tolkien has made history and myth not tragic but eucatastrophic: the men of Gondor triumph and the City does not fall; Faramir is not nearly so cowardly as Paris and happily marries a foreign princess instead of abducting another’s wife; and Boromir’s death ultimately saves his city.

    But there is an intersection between the Classics and the Medieval world, for the break was far from clean. During the summary of the history of Middle Earth in Letter 131, Tolkien confirms a long-time suspicion of mine about his world’s geopolitics:


But in the north Arnor dwindles, is broken into petty princedoms, and finally vanishes. The remnant of the Númenóreans becomes a hidden wandering Folk, and though their true line of Kings of Isildur's heirs never fails; this is known only in the House of Elrond.

In the south Gondor rises to a peak of power, almost reflecting Númenor, and then fades slowly to decayed Middle Age, a kind of proud, venerable, but increasingly impotent Byzantium.


Other than the geopolitical situation vis-a-vis being the struggling remaining half of a fallen empire: what, if anything, is Byzantine about Gondor? What can we learn from comparing the two?


    A quick refresher: after the fall of the Western Roman Empire in 476, the Eastern half survived in one form or another for another thousand years until finally being conquered by the Ottoman Turks in 1453. (Terminology is an issue here; the people of that state only ever referred to themselves as “Rhomaioi”, lit. Romans. But here I will stick with the misnomer Byzantine to avoid confusion). More-or-less as a direct consequence of the competition for legitimacy as heir of Rome, after Charlemagne’s crowning as Holy Roman Emperor, Western authors were dismissive of the state as a whole. Even Gibbon, possibly the most influential historian of Rome in the Anglosphere, hand-waved the survival of the East—in my opinion, because the survival of the Christian Empire squarely contradicted his thesis about Christianity destroying Rome. Regardless, the Western blind spot for the Empire meant that almost all Byzantine texts had never been translated into English until the mid-late 20th century. 


But the prevailing attitude towards Byzantium is best summed up in the introduction to my copy of Chronographia of Michael Psellos, written by the translator, the English Byzantinist E. R. A. Sewter:


Fifty years ago any English schoolboy who professed admiration for things Byzantine would almost certainly have been reprimanded. The Golden Age of Athens, the fifth century before Christ, was the most profitable age of study, and Roman History was respectable up to the reign of Hadrian; after that (had Gibbon not said so?) there followed a period of decline and fall. The miserable Byzantines were pale reflections of decadent Greeks: their art was stereotyped, lacking in inspiration, and stiff; their form of government was static and inefficient, their literature debased. Byzantinus est, non legitur* was the accepted maxim…


* [it is Byzantine, not readable—a play on Graecum est, non legitur]

A fantastic analysis of this work is The Argument of Psellos’ Chronographia by Michael Kaldellis.


    Certainly it is true that there are more than a few parallels to Constantinople and the Empire in the descriptions we get of Minas Tirith given as Gandalf and Pippin enter (bk 5 ch 1, “Gandalf passed now…” to “where the White Tree had grown.”). The great wall far from the city resembles the Anastasian Wall; the beacon system of Gondor had an exact parallel in the beacons that ran from the Taurus to Constantinople to warn of Arab razzias. The architecture and layout of Minas Tirith is somewhat Byzantine, but mostly not. Constantinople had seven hills, like the seven levels of Minas Tirith, and had famous fortifications in its threefold Theodosian Walls (replacing the earlier Constantinian Walls) with the Golden Gate, which the Great Gate of Minas Tirith maybe resembles. Constantinople dominated utterly as the religious, political, and economic heart of the Empire, especially in later years, as Minas Tirith utterly dominates Gondor. Were one to stretch overly, Osgiliath could be the city of Rome as the original, fallen capital of the Empire, recovered later in ruins. The palace being at the top of the city matches somewhat the Great Palace of Constantinople being at the tip of the peninsula; though there are no parallels to the great Hippodrome or Hagia Sophia. In the latter matter, the great tombs of the kings of Gondor resemble the great tombs the Numenorean kings built when they became paranoid of death; but they have little parallel in the Byzantine Empire, except (stretching again) for the massive, ornate churches sponsored by the emperors. Much of the description of dilapidated houses of nobles matches with the decline of the City, which continually lost population from the 6th century onwards, though it recovered at times. By the end, the population was so small (maybe a tenth of its peak) that there were fields well within the walls. Gondor and Byzantium had vastly different political systems. The Byzantines had few settled rules of succession, and kept on as the later Roman emperors did: the current emperor groomed his successor, typically a relative and did not always succeed because of frequent civil wars.


    But Tolkien's primary point of comparison is the decline of both states, so an investigation is in order. The causes of Byzantine decline are subtle and difficult to pin down. If they could be summed up shortly: the, well, byzantine political system that held up the Empire both robustly sustained it and caused constant political maneuvering that led to civil wars, and the internal weakness of the state made it unable to deal with its constant external threats. Another cause was the Empire’s military weakness. The reorganization from the system of Diocletian into the theme system of military districts settled by soldiers saved the Empire from total obliteration under the invasions of Arabs and Slavs in the 7th and 8th centuries; but the gradual decay of the theme system and renewed reliance on foreign mercenaries completely handicapped the capability of the Byzantine state to protect itself. Even the famous Varangian Guard, originally formed of Norsemen but later dominated by Anglo-Saxon exiles from Norman England, was a symptom of this reliance on mercenaries. The most successful Byzantine ruler (other than Justinian) was most likely Basil II, a harsh man who lived a Spartan lifestyle and did not care much for literature or art (though they flourished modestly under his reign). He subjugated Bulgaria so brutally and effectively that his usual epithet was Boulgaroktonos, “Bulgar-slayer”; infamously, at the Battle of Kleidion, he blinded 99 of every 100 prisoners and left the last with one eye to lead the rest home. And though he left a stable state with overflowing treasuries and a robust military, he had no children and within a hundred years of his death the empire was in severe decline again (the topic of the Chronographia, for Psellos was an eyewitness to most of it). The battle at Manzikert became an irreversible disaster because the emperor was captured and there followed ten years with as many civil wars; the sack of Constantinople in 1204 was the product of yet another claimant to the throne hiring foreign mercenaries. At the critical moment after Basil II's death when new enemies had gathered on the frontiers, the urban aristocracy fought tooth and nail for new bureaucratic positions and urban amenities when the theme system which held the country together was in severe decline. And the Byzantine state, as inwardly-conflicted as it was, could not withstand the pressure of constant nomad invasions by Cumans and Pechenegs and Bulgars and Hungarians and Normans and Turks, so on and so forth, from the east and north, invasions and piracy by the Arabs, and several plagues. And the material causes of the decline of Gondor, stated only briefly in the appendices, do somewhat match this factors: for they suffered a great plague (like the Plague of Justinian), a brutal civil war (the Kin-Strife), and nomad invasions from the East (the Wainriders), all of which left the state in dire straits.


However, Gondor's spiritual-moral decline is presented by Faramir in The Two Towers (though a more on-the-nose variation of these lines was delivered by Gandalf in the film of RotK):


…The old wisdom and beauty brought out of the West remained long in the realm of the sons of Elendil the Fair, and they linger there still. Yet even so it was Gondor that brought about its own decay, falling by degrees into dotage, and thinking that the Enemy was asleep, who was only banished not destroyed.


Death was ever present, because the Numenoreans still, as they had in their old kingdom, and so lost it, hungered after endless life unchanging. Kings made tombs more splendid than houses of the living, and counted old names in the rolls of their descent dearer than the names of sons. Childless lords sat in aged halls musing on heraldry; in secret chambers withered men compounded strong elixirs, or in high cold towers asked questions of the stars. And the last king of the line of Anarion had no heir...


This description does match the stereotyped decline of Byzantium presented by Sewter, that of unoriginal preservation. (Ironically a total inversion of Sailing to Byzantium: "That is no country for old men.") For one thing, it is at least true that the Byzantines were extremely conscious of their Classical heritage, both Roman and Greek, and preserved and commented on numerous texts lost in the West; the Greek phase of the Renaissance could largely be attributed to the reception of Byzantine scholars fleeing to Italy from the final Sack of Constantinople. Even the popular literature of the period like Digenis Akritas, an epic poem about the frontier written in a lower, Demoticized register, still heavily features Classical allusions. The lower-case Greek alphabet with diacritics was a product of the Byzantine written tradition; and written, courtly Greek of that period is heavily Atticized. But what is the great sin in reflecting back on the past? Or, if it is not generally wrong, what does Tolkien take as the wrong attitude towards preservation? I don't have the answer; fortunately, in a few classes we may, when we discuss immortality.