Tuesday, May 26, 2020

The Purpose of Death

There was one spot in the “Athrabeth Finrod Ah Andreth” that struck me that I did not feel we had the chance to really explore in class on Monday, that being the idea of Men being created for the task of healing the marred form of Arda that Finrod and Andreth inhabit into an Arda Remade. Furthermore, as we established in class, the only real difference between Elves and Men within the legendarium is the speed at which either party dies. We come to this fascinating situation in which Men because they die naturally in their 70’s and 80’s and are not meant to withstand the lifespan of Arda itself, are put in the position to recreate Arda free from Melkor’s corruption, or rather that that role necessitated a human lifespan.

To begin, I think it’s worth exploring Finrod’s explanation of the creation of Man. Finrod describes Men as being created by Eru Himself and outside of the realm of the Valar. With that high honor, it makes sense that their part is in the healing of Arda as the only being powerful enough to face Melkor/Morgoth is Eru alone. Only beings directly connected to Eru the way Men are could usher in the recreation of Arda. Furthermore, in the notes on the Athrabeth, it is mentioned that Finrod believes that when Eru does come to recreate Arda, He will do so “incarnated in human form,” due to his necessity as Creator to remain to some degree outside the Drama at all times.

This point on the dual nature of Eru ties in the necessity of human mortality as mortality places Men in a position with one foot out the door all the time. While Elves are constrained to the world of Arda, meant to live as long as it lives and cannot be removed from it, Men are merely guests which in a cosmological sense makes Men, like Eru. both outside the Drama and inside it at all times, although they have no knowledge of what awaits them outside of it. Men need to die in order to be of that dual nature of being both outside and inside Arda to play the role of healer for Arda as a plane of existence. Their purpose is not tied to Arda in its marred state, so their lifespans cannot be either.

Through this train of thought, we fundamentally come to the conclusion that lifespan is directly tied to the purposes of elves and Men. Men are meant to die so that they can maintain the separation necessary to usher in the recreation of Arda, but then what of elves who are bound to Arda’s lifespan? What is the purpose of immortality, or rather a lifespan defined by the lifespan of Arda itself? There are two salient purposes I see for the elves in Arda: a people to cultivate and appreciate Arda and a foil for Man.

The cultivating aspect is much more intuitive from the topic of lifespan as Elves are some of the only beings that can, in a cosmological sense, call Arda home and really get to know it. They have the length of life, as long as they are not interrupted, to see almost the entire life of Arda from the earliest days when Elves were themselves created to the end of Arda entirely. Their entire existence is tied to Arda so it logically follows that being in this position necessitates them to devote themselves to understanding Arda, appreciating it and creating within it, for how better to appreciate something than to utilize it to its fullest potential? As Finrod explains it to Andreth, what Man discovers in fleeting moments with wonder, elves find familiar and precious. Elves have the time to get to know Arda and so they each in their own ways strive to do so either through subcreation and handicraft or intellectual cultivation, as is the case with Finrod. Through these, elves uncover the possibilities of Arda and ensure that its fullest potential is exercised, and they can do that because they live as long as Arda does and can witness its entirety.

Another salient conclusion from the lifespan of elves is their ability to function as a foil for humanity. As the only real difference between Tolkien’s elves and men lies in their different speeds of death, elves provide a unique opportunity for humans to consider and appreciate their own humanity and subsequently their own mortality. We see this exactly with Andreth and Finrod as Andreth comes to learn more about why her people have to die by getting the perspective from someone who isn’t bound by human death. Elves and Men are the closest beings to each other in Arda, so it is logical to assume that they are meant to interact, and it is further logical to deduce that appreciating their mortalities and how it informs their respective purposes is itself another purpose of their creations. In essence, they were both created to be together. Now this may be counterintuitive to both elves and Men in Arda as they both tend to stay away from each other, but it cannot be ignored that they were created so similar.

In short, Tolkien created elves and Men in Arda to explore the concept of death and find meaning in it. He understood death as something beautiful and meaningful and through his elves and Men he had the opportunity to prove that to the Andreth’s reading who can’t help but fear the disruption and unknown that comes with something like death.

- Alyse Leonard

Aragorn and Arwen as (anti-) Tragedy

     To what extent is the story of Arwen and Aragorn a tragedy? It might seem reasonable to view the 'star-cross'd lovers' facing their deaths as the fulfillment of the tragic cycle, but the immortality of Arwen creates several complications. Is Arwen's hamartia simply her vulnerability to Aragorn? Could the meeting of Aragorn and Arwen be the crucial peripeteia, or is there no crucial moment where the storyline deviates in terms of their fortune? Is their ending cathartic, considering the range in possibilities for how they possibly could have died? Part of the problem with answering these questions is that the tale of Aragorn and Arwen gives rather little substance. We simply don't receive an adequate detailing of Arwen's emotional struggle to choose between Aragorn or her family in order to determine how the events of Arwen's life could be seen as 'good' or 'bad' fortune. But by looking specifically at the question of forsaking immortality, I hope to explore the tragic appearance of love between Arwen and Aragorn.
     I think it's crucial to first look at Aragorn, as his journey for love is less tragic and fairly straightforward. He sees Arwen, thinks she's pretty, does whatever he needs to do to marry her, marries her, has a child, and then dies. While his adventure to become the king of Gondor and Arnor has many twists and turns, and his chances of marrying Arwen seem quite diminished at numerous points, his options are always fairly morally obvious. He can either continue pursuing his goal of becoming the ruler of Gondor and Arnor, facing death in battle, or he can be a coward and hide from conflict, simply leaving himself to die later on with none of his goals accomplished. In this sense, it's hard to see Aragorn as a tragic character, but rather more of an adventurer. His treasure is Arwen, and he must unite Gondor and Arnor under his rule in order to receive his treasure. By pursuing his adventure, Aragorn has everything to gain, and very little to lose.
     While Aragorn is a fairly narrow character in terms of his love life, Arwen is much more complicated. Primarily, Arwen is unlike a normal treasure in the sense that she has the explicit choice to be a treasure or not to be a treasure. She had the option of turning away Aragorn, or even running away with Aragorn, but she rejects both of these options in a very morally ambiguous choice. While the circumstances are unclear, the choice between family and romance, and between mortality and immortality, is going to be a difficult choice in any case. This suggests that meeting Aragorn, and him falling in love with her, was itself a tragic peripeteia. Before meeting Aragorn, Arwen did not have the choice of paths ahead of her, but now the choice was explicitly hers. She could no longer live the life of a normal elf explicitly because Aragorn presented his love to her, which is fundamentally at odds with her immortality. 
     However hard the choice may be, the choice is not necessarily the choice of which is the greatest sacrifice, but rather it could be seen as a positive reversal. While immortality might be seen as a cage by the elves where their fëar are trapped to their hröar, having the sudden chance to choose immortality allows Arwen to weigh the pros and cons of immortality. Just as Eru grants death to Men as a gift, perhaps the tragic reversal for Arwen is positive in this sense, where Aragorn presents the possibility for her to receive the gift of death. 
     Both the immortality of Elves and the mortality of Men are in some way gifts from Eru, but which is the better gift? Or maybe they're both bad gifts, prompting one to ask which is the greater Doom? The elves don't seem to be particularly happy with their immortality, as they have to witness all the sorrows of Arda Marred and they believe that once the world ends both their hröar and their fëar will no longer exist. In contrast, Men are scared of their deaths, as they are scared of what lies beyond in the Void or if anything at all lies beyond, so they are more desperate to cling to Arda Marred. For both Elves and Men, their gifts from Eru can easily become a Doom. Is the existence of Elves also the existence of waiting for existence to end? Is the existence of Men the fear of whether your existence will end? Obviously this paints a rather bleak picture of the contrasting lives of Elves and Men with respect to existence, and perhaps it raises the question of why Eru would choose to place his Children in such conditions. Nonetheless, it is clear that immortality eliminates the fear of mortality, and mortality eliminates the sorrowful waiting for the end of immortality, but neither is satisfying in itself, leaving Arwen with a false choice.
      Maybe the choice between mortality and immortality was barely even present for Arwen, and the real choice was between romance or family. There is nothing very unpredictable about her choice, because no story shows a character choosing her family over her love. Love is nearly always the more relatable and powerful emotion in story-telling. Especially, Arwen had already spent hundreds of years with her family, whereas Aragorn had relatively little time left. Elrond clearly does not want to let go of Arwen, but perhaps this is partially due to Elrond wanting to extend his own immortality through having a lineage. Arwen does not need to worry about this issue, because she can recreate her immortality through her son, Eldarion, allowing her retain some aspect of both familial love and immortality. The choice to be the object of a family or the subject of a family is similarly not a particularly challenging question, especially in light of the lack of emotional depth described in the tale.
     At this point I'm inclined to say that the tale of Arwen and Aragorn is not a tragedy, but appears as a tragedy from the mortal perspective. In this perspective, Arwen not only abandons her immortality, but obtains the fear of imminent death due to her vulnerability to Aragorn's love. But she is merely exchanging one gift of existence, or doom of existence, for another, just as she exchanges one family for another. Ultimately, Arwen simply gains love with Aragorn. Neither her death nor Aragorn's death is tragic as they are both fated to die at some point, whether it be at the end of Arda or within a few hundred years. The real choice comes down to whether Arwen wants to die in love, or not in love, which is not a difficult question to answer in the end. Arwen does not merely die for love, but she dies in a qualified sense where she is debatably all-around gaining through her love with Aragorn.

-FK

Monday, May 25, 2020

The Meaning of Elven Characters: The Providers of Hope and Love

The interactions of Elves and men are central to the plot of Tolkien’s Legendarium and drive the development of the story. However, while they are both the children of Eru, the divergent fates of the two races also resulted in the pain and the Fall of men who sought to acquire immortality that is not granted to them. Specifically, it is the separation of one’s fea (soul) and hroa (body) caused by death that deeply troubled generations of the humankind. The suffering of humans therefore leads to two essential questions about Tolkien’s Legendarium: Is Eru wrong to create humans as Incarnates with physical bodies and what is the significance of the encounter of Elves and men? In “Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth,” Tolkien uses the conversation between Finrod, an Elven lord, and Andreth, a wise human lady, to explicate the nature of their divergent fates and shed some light on the meaning of the encounter between Elves and men. In this blog post, I will analyze this conversation and other related works of Tolkien to reveal that the author viewed death as a potentially rewarding but highly uncertain experience that would divide one’s fea and hroa temporarily. Meanwhile, Tolkien uses his Legendarium to propose that such uncertainty must be overcome by the power of religion and love which can grant humankind the necessary hope and companionship to face their fate.

In “Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth,” Andreth’s one major discontent with death is its destruction of the union of soul and body (“Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth” 317). According to Andreth, the body of a human is essentially an “inn” rather than a “house” like the body of Elves which forever contains the Elven soul (317). In her mind, such separation of soul and body is “unnatural” for Incarnates and responsible for the pain of her people (317). Indeed, the separation of body and soul is considered by many theologians as an unnatural state, and we talked in class about how Catholics would believe in the resurrection of human bodies during the Last Judgement. However, is Eru wrong for creating his human as mortal Incarnates that must suffer this separation of body and soul? In the conversation, Finrod argues that, in Eru’s design, the fea of a human has the power to revive his or her hroa, and these two components would join each other forever and beyond the confines of the earthly world and time (318). In his explanation, the fact that human beings are Incarnates with perishable bodies is not a punishment to this race, since Eru intends the soul to join with the body after death in the heavenly world implied by Tolkien. Similarly, the death that causes such separation of body and soul should not be regarded as entirely evil. Finrod points out that death is viewed by men as evil due to the lies of Melkor (310), while the separation of soul and body caused by death can potentially result in the eternal reunion of the two in the heavenly world. Thus, using Finrod’s voice, Tolkien justifies the design of Eru who did not create human beings as mortal Incarnates as their punishment. Instead, the death grants human beings the possibility to achieve another form of eternity, which the immortality of Elves is finite and will eventually terminate with the end of Arda.

However, why are human beings described in Tolkien’s Legendarium still so afraid of death? The answer is the uncertainty associated with death. In the conversation, there are multiple occasions when Andreth complained about the immense uncertainty faced by the human race as they did not have direct connections with the Valar and Eru as the Elves did. She was frustrated that she and her kinsmen could know their fate after death for certain, since such “Vision of Eru” is only within his own mind (318). Because humans did not even have the connection with the Valar as the Elves did (313), they faced the darkness of uncertainty which posed a huge challenge for them and greatly disrupted their ability to properly perceive the design of Eru.

This difficulty caused by the unperceivable nature of human fate leads us to the second question that I intend to answer, which is the purpose of Elves in Tolkien’s Legendarium. In my opinion, the existence of Elves helps humankind to develop hope and love which are two forces that can help people to conquer their fear of uncertainty. In our previous discussions, we agreed that the Elf-friend figures in Tolkien’s Legendarium essentially function as mediators between our primary world and the fairy world. To a certain extent, the Elves in Tolkien’s novels also serve as mediators between human beings and the One, as well as his agents in Valinor. Like the Elf-friend figures who connects our world with the fairy world by participating in fairy stories, Elves also directly interacted with godly powers to prove to human beings the existence of the Valar and the One. For instance, figures like Luthien could plead to Mandos who eventually revived Beren, and such Valar-Elf interactions served as the justification for the existence of higher powers. Therefore, although human beings did not have the intimate relationship with Valar and Eru as Elves might have, their connection to Elves allowed them to witness the power of the Creator and his agents. As a result, they should be able to develop the Hope described by Finrod (320). In fact, in his Legendarium, we can observe that it was the Elf-friend figures with frequent interactions with Elves who are the most faithful to Eru. In terms of the real world implication, I think Tolkien would recommend us to connect to God by developing close bonds with the pious and religious figures around us in our communities. Even this kind of indirect relationship with the Creator can help us to develop hope and endure the fear engendered by uncertainty, thereby properly accepting the fate assigned to us human beings.

Besides revealing the significance of hope in reducing the fear of death, the Elf-man interaction portrayed by Tolkien also informs us the importance of marriage in combating the uncertain darkness of fate. In the love story of Beren and Luthien, the Elven lady eventually gave up her immortality and chose to live with Beren as a mortal being (Silmarillion 222). Tolkien describes that it was their mutual love which compelled the couple willingly accepted their uncertain fate as mortals and eventually transcended “beyond the confines of the world” (Silmarillion 222). My reading of this romance and Tolkien’s own marriage is that Tolkien considers love to be another major power that heals human beings’ fear of uncertainty. In his letter to Christopher, he explicitly states that he identifies his marriage as the same as the union of Beren and Luthien, and it is indeed this love between him and Edith that supported him “to escape the shadow of imminent death” (Letter 340). While it is impossible to fall in love with an Elf in the real world, I would interpret this Elf-man union in a figurative way. The Elven figure represents a devoted partner who is willing to make sacrifices to overcome the distance between the two souls in order to form a union, just like Luthien and Arwen’s decision to forsake immortality. Tolkien certainly found himself an “Elven” partner in his own life.

In conclusion, Tolkien believes that the interaction of Elves and men is essential for human beings’ acceptance of their fate, since the Elven characters symbolize the figures who can mediate human beings with the divine power and serve as their partners who can support them to overcome the fear of death. Ultimately, by understanding how this relationship between Elves and human beings enables humankind to face death, we can better comprehend the significance of Elves’ participation in his story and why Eru designed human beings as Incarnates. As I intend to show, it is the guidance and support of Elves that assisted human beings in Tolkien’s Legendarium realize that their existence as Incarnates will not end through their deaths but rather persist according to the design of Eru. Thus, just like Tolkien did at the end of his life, the human race can finally acknowledge the benign nature of the Creator’s design and peacefully accept their assigned destiny.

-R C
Sources:
J. R. R. Tolkien Athrabeth Finrod Ah Andreth
J. R. R. Tolkien Silmarillion
Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien

Saturday, May 23, 2020

Game of Thrones and Lord of the Rings and the Metaphysical

Fantasy is often cast aside as a frivolous genre, and it has been for a long time. Fairies, elves and orcs cannot be found in real life, so their purpose is not rooted in reality, their purpose becomes cloudy. Professor Brown brought up how many people find it a waste of time. My own opinion in the past generally dismissed fantasy as a frivolous genre, and I for a long time would have agreed. As a Creative Writing major, for a while, when other students would write fantasy stories, I would dismiss their work as somehow lesser than the realistic fiction I would write. I felt like those stories were not able to convey the human condition in the same way. As it were, most of the celebrated writers only wrote realistic fiction or nonfiction. I’m thinking about Hemingway, Fitzgerald, Faulkner, Austen. Tolkien was not in my realm of great writers.
In class on Monday, I brought up something, which turned out to be an important point. Game of Thrones made dragons cool again, I typed into the chat without really thinking. But now, I believe that statement and want to extend it further into a discussion on how and why fantasy was finally accepted by all sorts of TV viewers, making Game of Thrones became one of the most watched and awarded shows of all time.
My parents at first refused to watch Game of Thrones because of all of its “fantasy nonsense.” I think specifically it was the dragons that put them off, as the rest of the show could be seen as more of a period piece. Dragons were the creatures of nerds, of DnD players. However, when they finally agreed to watch it, they loved it, dragons and White Walkers being an essential part of the plot and all.
I think about asking my parents to read Lord of the Rings. They probably wouldn’t but if they did, they would also be hooked as the reason why Lord of the Rings was so successful was Tolkien’s ability to tell a story and build a world. His craftsmanship extended far beyond what Martin’s did, creating an entire Legendarium as well. Frodo’s journey through middle earth is a story anyone can relate to, despite not being a Hobbit. The wrestling with good and evil, the love story between Aragorn and Arwen are all elements that feel human. Genre does not matter if the story is good. A good writer, even those realistic fiction writers I mentioned, all have to do what Tolkien did, which is create a believable world. I know this because I have been trying to create a small world of my own for my thesis, and have found it extremely difficult. Tolkien’s work translated by Peter Jackson, won them both an Academy Award. Style matters because they are doing something hard.
However, what makes Lord of the Rings so special is its attention to the theological. It’s sub creations beg for the answers to philosophical questions and metaphysical questions realistic fiction just cannot. The creation of beings foreign to our existence goes against what God made. Game of Thrones subverts what Tolkien created into violent turmoil, seeing human. Essence as mostly evil. Fantasy deals with the grappling between good and evil. Frodo’s journey is a hero’s journey, that ultimately ends in failure as he cannot resist the one ring’s corruption. Where in realistic fiction can one be forced to deal with evil itself, without the use of metaphor and allegory. Tolkien does not need to use these as a crutch, he simply can create his world. Fantasy, good fantasy, I now see is beautiful due to its own creations.

IG

Friday, May 22, 2020

Juuls and Trees

This was just a terrible pun at first but with the suggestion and encouragement of Lioje I somehow ended up actually writing off of it.

Tolkien, defender of trees, venerates the bucolic lifestyle throughout The Lord of the Rings. It is deeply engrained in the Shire: rural England mythologized with its low, simple buildings, extensive fields and woods, and of course the hobbits’ gardens. This is why, in addition, “The Scouring of the Shire” can really hit home. The devices of Sauron and Saruman such as explosives and battering rams, their “mind[s] of metal and wheels” are perhaps acceptable to us in war but are heartbreakingly destructive when turned on the innocent hobbits. So, his position on Machines and industrialism are clear. Does that mean we must forsake all plants and wilderness, living in a state of almost fear of nature? Of course not; for one thing Tolkien is more realistic than that. Moreover the Shire he loves is a farming community, and without nature we would end up in precisely the world of metal and rock we were trying to avoid. Still, I think that the way we may use nature bears examination. The matter of ents and entwives sums up the whole debate nicely. For the ents, the right course is to coexist and let plants live undisturbed, or if anything give them some gentle guidance for the plants’ own good. They “ate only such fruit as the trees let fall in their path” and wandered among the forests. The entwives, though, took delight in growing and ordering plants, creating a manicured garden and farm over a wilderness. For Tolkien the optimal situation is probably a balance where we only farm as much as necessary, nurture gardens so that we can appreciate trees for their beauty, and leave the rest wild. But farm we must, and therefore I will look at what he might say about utilizing plants.

The people who seem most noble and respectful in this, contrasting with Saruman and friends, are those who are immersed in nature. I will return to the title for an example. The hobbits love their pipeweed, and spend long hours cultivating both the plants and the art or culture of smoking it. But they also are fond of walking in the countryside and tending their flowers; they depend on the land and know its patterns. Tom Bombadil says of Farmer Maggot “’There’s earth under his old feet, and clay on his fingers; wisdom in his bones, and both his eyes are open.” We can presume that the hobbits managed the pipeweed and other crops quite well, before the influence of Saruman crept in, because it comes as such a shock when Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin discover the shortage of food, drink, and smoke under Sharkey. Nor is it just the Enemy and his servants who do not truly appreciate nature. My meditations on pipeweed reminded me of the herb-master in the Houses of Healing. Here is a man who uses plants extensively in his daily work without knowing them. He is too wrapped up in lore and scholarship to recognize the virtues of kingsfoil recorded in old wives’ tales, and Aragorn suggests he would find no value in pipeweed either. His view of plants is as tools, within the city-fortress. It is Aragorn the ranger, who has survived in the wilds and experienced the landscapes of Middle-Earth, that is able to give these plants their due. In a way, Aragorn, Farmer Maggot, and probably many hobbits fall into the Green Man character. Not perhaps as a nature spirit of vengeance (like the Green Knight?) or rebirth (Tom Bombadil definitely) but a quasi-green man surrounded by nature – like leaves surround a green man’s face – and in tune with it.

Before I end this somewhat meandering post, I will bring up one more example of Aldarion and Erendis (related in The Unfinished Tales). The story has been puzzling me: it is basically the same as the ents and entwives, but with gender reversed. Erendis loves wild forests, while Aldarion values them for their ship-building material. Nonetheless he is the greatest forester of Numenor, planting tons of trees and cultivating forests in both Numenor and Middle Earth. I am still not sure whether either of them are supposed to be sympathetic characters, but if we are to dislike Aldarion perhaps it is because he fails to embrace the quasi-green man attitude. He does not take time to venture in the forests and understand them beyond the scientific understanding of forestry, nor even much the fields and other parts of the island, because he is too focused on their use in exploring the sea. Another conclusion, maybe, can be drawn from the fate of Erendis (vague spoilers!). She “dwindle[s]” and “falls down dim into her own twilight” of bitterness and loneliness. I have to wonder if this is the ultimate end of ents too – it does sound a lot like huorns and Old Man Willow now that I think about it. Will they too all end up as sad trees? The “Treegarth of Orthanc” gives me hope that they have found fresh purpose and energy. And yet, in doing so they have somewhat abandoned their stand. They have become like the entwives, growing a garden even with the appearance of a wild forest. Maybe this is the other side of the green man, then. You must understand nature to rightfully interact with it, but you must also interact with it to have purpose and to understand yourself.

- ᛸᚻᚹ