Monday, June 8, 2020

Final Project - An Ending to Tolkien's The Fall of Arthur

VI
_____________________


How Arthur pursued Mordred to the setting of the sun

Arthur westward     in arms purposed,
high helms of traitors     hewed in victory
and sunlit shores     at Romeril secured.
For war wished he not,     and wept for his land
torn asunder by     traitorous intent.
Thriftless ambition     and treason high,
larger in fault than     Lancelot,
more was the malevolence     grown in Mordred.
Guinever’s fate     guessed he not,
freedom found      in her father’s lands.
Again for Ban’s kin     Arthur wished
yet Gawain in counsel     constant remained,
staunch bonds now broken    and brothers slain.
Treason he feared     yet more turmoil felt
for Gareth and Gaheris     he greatly loved
and loss still he felt     at Lancelot’s hand.

Arthur’s army     arose with the dawn,
waking early     and waxing in strength.
Arms and armor     adorned they with
greaves and gauntlets     glimmering in sun.
Bold was their purpose     for battle preparing
yet cold morning light     found Mordred not
for cunning was the caitiff,     in cowardice fled
of Arthur his king     he was afeared
and no less of Gawain      who in glory was highest.
Westward the traitors went     as the night waned
‘gainst the sun     in glory rising
in the east     where the enemy lay.

Gawain arrayed in gold     glorious as the sun
cursed the cowards     and his kindred sought
puissant and purposeful     they pursued the foe.
Counsel kept he not,     nor to Arthur cleft
but on great Guingalot     to war galloped.
Lothian’s men     the van lead
under strong sun     stormed they west
its fire following,     foes to slay.

Swords first struck     at the sun’s height
Galuth glinting     amidst battle’s gore.
Long fought Lot’s kin    true sons of Lothian,
grim Gawain among them     ever the greatest,
king’s kinsmen against     craven traitors fought
ere to battle arrived     Arthur and his men
who in caution kept     in camp too long.
Wrathful was Gawain     but in strength waning
as the sun low in sky hung     streaking red the clouds
bloody above as below     lay the battlefield.



VII
_____________________


The setting of the sun and with it Sir Gawain

The last light of day     leaked over the horizon
as grim Gawain alone     stood guard on a hilltop
dominion defending     yet in desperation standing.
Foes about his feet      fell dead to ground
even as the sunset sapped      strength from blows.
The bastion of Arthur     on all sides beset
great foes withstood      as his strength waned
for captivity cared he not;      killed would he rather
than fail in his fealty     which always was foremost
all as nearer drew Arthur     his nephew seeking
bravery to reward     and recklessness condemn.

Battle was ending,    the enemy broken,
Mordred retreating     mercy to beg
fleeing the fight     even as Gawain fell.
‘Cross river to Camelot     the cowards fled
whilst upon the water     King Arthur wept
his greatest knight Gawain      now forever going
yet his liege’s lamentation     the son of Lot stirred.
For paper he pleaded     and penitent wrote
a letter to Lancelot,     old love now remembered.
‘Come to King’s aid,      for I counsel pardon.
the bravery of Ban’s kindred     badly is needed.
The treason of Mordred     to your mettle will yield.
Your king would have called you     but my counsel he heard.
For this sin I have suffered     and now I am slain.
Call Bors and Blamore,     Bleoberis and Ector
With might and sans mercy     the traitor to meet.
Now truly this time     is your fealty tested
but I know now     our great knight
Lancelot will not      be lacking found.’

All this he wrote     then glory waned
and great Gawain from this world     was forever gone.
The sun had set     with only sadness to come.
Over his death     was Arthur much distraught
swearing to eat     for sustenance only
pleasure in food     forsaken in grief
and all gaiety gone     until Gawain be avenged.
Morn came again     and onward the marched
yet something of the sun     seemed in it lacking.
Faithless cowards fled     with true king following
Pendragon purposeful     and puissant in wrath
a full fortnight passing    as the foe retreated
until king came to Camlann     his crown to regain.



VIII
_____________________


Of Arthur’s dream at Camlann

In dreams Arthur dwelt     as dark overcame
the king at Camlann      keeping his force
saw in his sleep     a nephew slain.
The ghost of Sir Gawain     with glory shining
appeared to Arthur     ere battle one night
keeping counsel as living     but caution forewarning
not Mordred to fight     the following morn.
Lancelot his letter     in love received
and swiftly he sailed     in ships lily-leafed
Arthur to join     and just place reclaim.
Ban’s kindred in battle     their king beside
alone was the way     to wash clean their sin
and this force only     foes would overcome.

Thus Arthur awoke     in awe at his dream
spirits powerful of those past     victory presaging
allies at sea     aid bringing
sovereignty in grasp seeming     as shores flanked the foe.
But king in his wisdom,       crown in sight,
Sir Gawain’s guidance     gravely he bore.
Early he armored      and arms he bore,
Caliburn at his side     as true king should wield
sword at waist slung     scabbard long lost.
Messengers he sent,     with Mordred to treat
briefly the battle      he thought best to delay.
Caitiff in cowardice     and cunning agreed
seeing in stoppage     his bind to ‘scape
not to tarry in this trap     after treaty was made.
Both swore that surcease      should last a month,
both bound by this      unless blade was drawn.

Yet dark was king’s destiny      and death it sought.
Ill-fated Sagramore spied      a serpent afoot
and with shining sword     the beast he slew
A reaction in reason     yet cause of great ruth.
Time was turned back     and treaty forgot
this day was death     for Arthur destined.

Worry not for wise king     nor wish ought else;
for the king that will come again     this cost must pay
for none can return      that never had left.
Rex quondam, rexque futurus,     his return presaged
in the words     on his tomb yet written.

With the whistle of blade     in wayward hand
 Once more began battle on      great Britain’s shores.
Marrac and Meneduc     mightily fought,
Brian and Baldwin      battered their foes
yet by Sagramore’s side     at day’s end lay slain.
Of all the court       at Camelot met,
the table round      of regent high
only brave Bedivere     the battle survived
Alone with Arthur       the field assaying.
King through the combat      had Caliburn seen,
the blessed blade      Britain protecting.

Faithless was fate,     the faithless protecting,
Mired in blood      still Mordred stood
His blade blemished    with the blood of his country.
His enemy to end     and insurrection with him,
Arthur advanced      Gawain to avenge
and all men slain     by Mordred’s black hand.
Caliburn met Clarent,     clashing at dusk
Dead fell the traitor     but the duel had its cost
Cruel Clarent finding its mark      on Arthur’s crown struck. 



XI
_____________________


The departure of Arthur from the world of men

Dark drew nearer     as dusk began to fade.
Arthur on the field       had fallen
Bedivere knelt beside     bemoaning the death
of chivalry and great Camelot      on the fields of Camlann.
Arthur his gauntlet grasped     gasping through wounds
‘From Camlann carry me      and Caliburn bring
not long will I last      and a lake must you find
and into it Caliburn cast     ere I may cross
west and make my way     to that weird isle
Avalon called     that shall be Arthur’s rest.’

Bedivere took the blade     and along the brook
Caliburn he carried     yet thought to keep
the lake he found     but the blade left
in a hole hidden      hereafter to be retrieved.
Returning to Arthur     remorse not yet known
Bedivere to discover     his king he had betrayed.
Cold lay the king,     for Bedivere calling
‘tell me your tale     so your troth I may know.’
‘Caliburn I cast     deep into the cauldron
water washed o’er it     and only waves I saw.’
The good king cried out    ‘cur, you do lie
kingly Caliburn     you have kept.
Back, Sir Bedivere     or your king you betray.’

In ruth he returned     and sword he retrieved
but blade’s beauty        again left him bewitched.
To cast away the king’s blade     he thought a crime.
Again to Arthur      and the question was asked
and Bedivere lied     of what he saw in the lake.
Twice did he fail     and his troth break
but at last the blade holding     betrayed not his lord
and great Caliburn     into the lake he cast.
Amid fog and fen     his folly he saw
for waves on the water     white hand did make
as the blade it did catch      and singly brandish
then Caliburn disappeared     in the waters near Camlann.

To Arthur he went     and answered true
the Lady of the Lake     at last he had seen.
Arthur sighed      for too long had they stayed
And to the beach he begged      Bedivere to carry him.
Bravely he bore     his lord badly wounded
and on the shores of the west     a ship did he find.
Nine mirthless maidens      tearfully did man
The barge they had brought     to bear Arthur away
and foremost among them     was Morgan le Fay.
Into the water she waded      and loudly she wailed
‘truly too long      on land did you tarry.
Our utmost we’ll do     but unclear is your fate.’
Onto the barge     did they bear him
and in all speed     did they sail
over waves to the west     and out of the world.



X
_____________________


Of Lancelot’s return to England and subsequent departure

Lancelot at last     in Britain landed
to his liege he purposed     penitent seeking
but on field of battle     only Bedivere could he find
the bodies of comrades     alone burying.
Too late had he come     and liege failed
gone from the world      was Gawain his friend
and Arthur too     in Avalon slept
westward across the waves       his wounds to heal
ere he ever     to England return.

Beside Bedivere did     Ban’s kindred work
burying in earth      the bodies of friends.
Safir and Segwarides,     Saracen knights,
Esclabor’s sons     and Errac too
Griflet and Geraint        and Guingalain
the fair unknown      and Urien’s son Iwain
lastly Sir Lucan     did Lancelot bury
the Round Table’s remnants     laying to rest.
After this in abbey     did Bedivere abide
Ban’s kindred     to Benwick returning.
Lancelot alone     did they leave behind
toward Gales he rode     Guinever seeking.
The queen he found     but queer still she thought him.
Strange each found the other,      from self deemed they altered.
In grief they parted     Guinever to an abbey
Christ alone     would she keep
as wife     she would not.
Lancelot seeking last evils      across the land rode
Ere to Camlann he came again     where his great king fell.
A great bark he built      with Bedivere’s aid
And to sea he sailed      his king to seek.

This he swore     ere he sailed away
‘to Avalon will I go     Arthur to find
and with him return     else there remain
penance seeking     ‘part from the world.
Should I not find him     forever I’ll sail
but in faith I know     this time I’ll fail not
and with Arthur abide     in fair Avalon
until then is it time      and Britain’s need truest
then westward over waves     he shall wend.
If ever I’ll return      to England I know not
But I beside Arthur come I     or better not at all.’
And away did he sail     to the point of sunset
the hour of heroes    over horizon sinking
and never again in the land     was such a knight seen.

-Sam Sobel

Sunday, June 7, 2020

A Hobbit-esque Peek Along the Beam


“Let us celebrate the mythopoeic imagination of Albion. Let us celebrate the Makers, who made systems and were not enslaved by those of other men, but broke through to the Vision of what lies beyond Language, to the eternal symbols and the unchanging Light. […] Let us celebrate also J. R. R. Tolkien, who single-handed forged the Elvish languages and the myths of Middle-Earth and the lands beyond the Western Sea.” 
-       A.S. Byatt, “Babel Tower”

We have spent a whole quarter now debating whether or not Tolkien’s works can be considered “allegory.” Tolkien himself has given us somewhat contradictory signals in this regard: whereas he explicitly claims he “dislikes [conscious and intentional] Allegory” (Letter 131), he has included, as we’ve discussed extensively in class, undeniable allegorical references to prayer, liturgy and devotional practices in the Legendarium – like the parallels between Galadriel and Mary, and between the “lembas” and the Catholic viaticum, the coincidence of Christian holidays and major events in the plot, to name a few. Those parallels, however, are never fully developed or made explicit: they are rather more like glimpses of something larger than the ‘secondary reality’ of Middle Earth. As Tolkien says in letter 142: “Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision.” How then could Tolkien’s literary corpus not be allegorical but also be consciously Catholic at the same time? For much of this course, we’ve hinted at possible answers to this problem – as in the discussion on sub-creation and on the actual historicity of the Legendarium – but none more powerful than what we found in Lewis’ Meditation in a Toolshed. By introducing us to the ‘beam of light’ thought experiment and the epistemological problem of analyzing things by looking at them versus looking along them, Lewis has shown us the key distinction between simple allegory and myth. Even further, I propose, he has allowed us to understand Tolkien’s works at a “meta” level: the Legendarium, as a mythology, does not ‘reflect Christianity’ through allegory, because, even more strongly, it presupposes Christianity, which is the truth at its very core.
In the “Mediation in a Toolshed” Lewis presents the distinction between two types of experience: one when you look at a beam of light in a dark toolshed from the side and see only the specks of dust filtering through it, and another when you look along the beam and get to see the trees outside. Depending on the approach one chooses, he argues, one might catch or miss out many details – after all, there is no definite objective reference frame from which one can evaluate something devoid of biases, but at the same time facing things solely from one’s personal perspective can be misleading. He claims, however, that the "looking along things" approach has often been dismissed out of hand by academics that, too often, resorted to anthropologists and sociologists to understand religion, for instance, instead of considering the perspective of those who actually lived those religions from the inside. That is a mistake, Lewis argues, because sometimes objective, detached observations are impossible without inside experiences (i.e. a doctor cannot treat pain properly without having felt it before). Having said that, I believe that we can map Lewis’s important observation onto the differences between works that are explicitly allegorical (like his own) and those who are not, like Tolkien’s. As we've discussed in class, Lewis’s The Chronicles of Narnia is obviously an epic retelling the Christian myths through different names and settings, written from the perspective of a devout Christian. It is, undoubtedly, an invitation for readers to know the Christian mythology through the lenses of someone who looked both along and at it, an introduction to the “one true myth.” Yet, despite his effort to write allegory, Lewis doesn’t necessarily end up making the readers look along Christianity – to the contrary, many readers will simply read Narnia as a sociologist would look at a religious account: by distancing themselves from the true Christian experience. What I propose Tolkien does in his works is the very opposite of that: by not writing explicit allegory, but by creating a mythology that echoes and reverberates the true Christian myths, Tolkien invites the readers – even skeptical atheists – to look along the Christian beam of light, which permeates the Legendarium.
To check this proposition, we must look no further than what Tolkien himself wrote about his mythmaking. He states on Letter 165 that: “it [LOTR] is not ‘about’ anything but itself. Certainly it has no allegorical intentions […] it is a monotheistic world of ‘natural theology.’ The odd fact that there are no churches, temples, or religious rites and ceremonies is simply part of the historical climate depicted […] The ‘Third Age’ is not a Christian world.” Indeed, one will not easily find unequivocal Christian elements by looking at the LOTR: there hardly is any explicit reference to Eru in almost 1000 pages, and barely any mention of religious beliefs. This monotheistic religion that Tolkien speaks of is left implicit in LOTR: it is the background setting, the story taken as given by the characters, who at several points evoke the name of Elbereth, for instance. Where do we see the “consciously Catholic” aspect of the Legendarium then? In its very construction! Tolkien says on letter 212 that the difference between the Christian myth and his own was that in the former “evil was brought in from the outside” and it wasn’t clear whether (if at all) the Fall (“the rebellion of created free-will”) had impacted the nature of the Primary world; whereas in the Legendarium, the Fall took place before the creation of Eä – so the “corruption, therefore, of all things in it and all inhabitants of it, was a possibility if not inevitable.” That is a very consequential world-building decision because it means that the Christian struggle between good and evil, between God’s will and “created free-will” is embedded in the Legendarium, it is presupposed by it! 
Another instance in which we can see evidence of this echo of Christian myths in the Legendarium is in the ending of the long narrative arch of Frodo and Sam in LOTR. In Fellowship, before our heroes left Rivendell, Frodo tells Bilbo that he has thought of several possible grim endings to his book, to which Bilbo replies “Oh that won’t do! Books ought to have good endings.” Later, on the stairs of Cirith Ungol, Frodo and Sam discuss what kind of tale they’ve fallen into, and realizing they were still in the same tale as Beren and Lúthien, Sam wonders whether they too will be “put into songs or tales” in the future. Finally, after the quest of the Ring is ended, Sam sees his dream come true as the people in Ithilien sing high praises to him and Frodo for all that they had done – that was the culmination of the story he had long before found himself into but which he had up until then failed to understand. This joy of happy ending, “the mark of the true fairy-story,” is what Tolkien calls eucatastrophe in On Fairy Stories: it is what gives readers a “sudden glimpse of the underlying reality or truth” (Tolkien Reader, p. 88). That is only possible because the joyous turns in fairy-stories offer a hint at the greatest conceivable eucatastrophe, which “has entered History and the primary world”: “The Birth of Christ is the eucatastrophe of Man’s history. The Ressurection is the eucatastrophe of the story of the Incarnation. This story begins and ends in joy” (TR, p. 89). In other words, to find ourselves in Tolkien’s story – like Frodo and Sam found themselves inside the greater stories of the Legendarium – and to see ourselves experiencing their joy despite all the sacrifice they made is to be reminded (again, whether we’re believers or not) of the greatest myth of all: the story of Christ.
Thus, there is a very meaningful difference between Tolkien’s sub-created mythology and Lewis’s allegorical retelling of the Christian myth because as readers go through the Legendarium, they will inevitably experience (consciously or not) the “meta” themes presented by the Christian myth. That is, by finding themselves in the story of LOTR, readers actually look along the Christian beam of light, instead of possibly merely looking at it as in the case of Narnia. Tolkien himself points to this feature when he claims, on his comments to W. H. Auden’s review of LOTR, that “in my story I do not deal in Absolute Evil (…) Sauron represents as near an approach to the wholly evil will as possible (…) the conflict is not basically about ‘freedom,’ though that is naturally involved. It is about God, and His sole right to divine honor.” Thus, when readers empathize with and identify themselves in Frodo, Sam, Gandalf and Aragorn (all of whom bore certain Christ features), who fought to oppose a tyrant who “desired to be a God-King,” they are experiencing the Christian perspective, whether they profess a Christian belief or not. Of course, as we’ve discussed in class, one is welcome to side with Sauron and thereby be for the forceful imposition of created will (maybe Nietzsche would do it), but what matters here is that readers are exposed to the Christian dilemma either way. As such, the interpretation of the myth we're presented in Tolkien's works is, I believe, free, but the reality of the Christian myths behind them is inescapable. In this sense, Tolkien’s works are far more Christian or “religious” than those who are explicit allegories of Christianity but which fail to have this effect on readers – and that is the true power of his mythmaking. We see confirmation of this notion in letter 328, where Tolkien speaks of an unbeliever who told him “you create a world in which some sort of faith seems to be everywhere without a visible source, like light from an invisible lamp.” That is remarkably similar to what Byatt wrote about Tolkien in the Babel Tower, as seen in the quote that opens this post, and to what Sam and Frodo felt when they first visited Lothlorien:

“‘If there’s any magic about it, it’s right down deep, where I can’t lay my hands on it, in a manner of speaking.’
‘You see and feel it everywhere,’ said Frodo.
‘Well,’ said Sam, ‘you can’t see nobody working it. No fireworks like poor old Gandalf used to show.’” (LOTR, bk II, ch. 7, p. 361)

-->
-       LR

Friday, June 5, 2020

The Meaning of Worship: Sacrifice

For a book which Tolkien described as "fundamentally a religious and Catholic work," (Letter 142), the Lord of the Rings has no mention of religion, worship, a clergy, or gods. So how does religion and Catholicism work its way into the book? Tolkien himself asserted that the Lord of the Rings "is about God, and His sole right to divine honor," (Letter 183). This only raises another question: how do the inhabitants of Middle Earth worship God? That is, how do they give divine honor to God? Common to the heroes of the Lord of the Rings, yet not present amongst the villains, is sacrifice. Galadriel her home, Sam his quiet life, Eowyn her love, and Gandalf, Boromir, and Theoden their lives. Amongst all of them, each sacrifices something that comprised the nature of God. Each reduces their own honor and being for the betterment of others. In doing so, they recognize that they are ultimately not the recipients of divine honor.

When speaking to Frodo and Sam at the Mirror of Galadriel in Lothlorien, Galadriel reveals her motives for aiding the fellowship and what it will cost her. She reveals that the destruction of the Ring will destroy the beauty of Lothlorien. She reveals that she will willingly sacrifice the beauty of Lothlorien for freedom (The Fellowship of the Ring). Not only is she sacrificing her home, but she is sacrificing the closest place to heaven in Middle Earth; the descriptions of Lothlorien of gold and silver trees with gem like flowers and water (The Fellowship of the Ring) closely mirror descriptions of Heaven found in the Bible (Revelation 21). Galadriel, sadly, relinquishes the most heavenly place on Middle Earth to secure her and her people's freedom. In doing so, she accepts that it is not her place to permanently preserve or posses such beauty.

Sam takes on the burden of the Fellowship and the quest to destroy the Ring without complete knowledge of what he is doing. He has little knowledge of the world beyond the Shire (The Fellowship of the Ring) and does so more out of love for Frodo than a hatred of evil. Throughout his adventure, especially as he approaches Mt. Doom, Sam longs for the quiet and tranquil life he had in the Shire with his fiancé (The Return of the King). By the end of the journey, Sam has sacrificed nearly seven months after having departed from the Shire (Appendix B). As much as Sam longs in the moments along the journey and in Mordor for his home in the Shire, if he had stayed, the quest would not have been completed and the Shire would have been reduced and destroyed, just as Gandalf comments to Pippin on their way to Minas Tirith (The Return of the King). Sam's life in the Shire was one of sedentary and complacent calm. Little happened, and he valued that. Yet in casting off this slothful life. In accepting the burden of the quest of the Fellowship, he sacrificed the calm, tranquility, and peace of the seemingly idealic Shire to face the burdensome reality of the world.

The greatest sacrifice shown in the Lord of the Rings is to give one's life for another. Tolkien calls death "the Gift of Men" from God. While each of these three men does not chose death, they do not shy away from death when they are needed. Each also has different motives. For Boromir, it is an act of repentance for falling prey to the allure of the Ring (the Fellowship of the Ring). Theoden, as an elderly king, sees his inevitable death fast approaching; he faces a choice more of the manner of his death than the time. His death is a death as a result of him honoring his oaths and confronting evil in the slim hope that it might save those he loves (the Two Towers). In choosing a move violent and unpleasant death, Theoden permits his family and subjects to have a new and greater life of freedom. Theoden's sacrifice is not just his life, but his comfort, surety, and kingship. Finally, Gandalf gives up his life in order to saves the Fellowship and defeat the Balrog. His ultimate death not only kills the immediate evil of the Balrog, one of the last remnants of the evil of Morgoth, but he also serves the greater purpose of the destruction of the evil of the Ring. Gandalf's sacrifice is even greater as his spirit is greater than those of elves or men due to his nature as an Istari (Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle Earth). Gandalf's sacrifice is of power, spirit, and life.

While Eowyn was prepared and willing to sacrifice her life for Theoden, she is survives her confrontation with the Witch King and is instead faced with another sacrifice: love. From the moment she laid eyes upon Aragorn, she was convinced that she was in love with him (The Two Towers). Yet, as Aragorn explained to her, he was in love with and in love with another (The Two Towers). Scorned and faced with the Spector of unrequited love, Eowyn falls into a deep sadness and becomes determined to fall in battle if Aragorn will not return her love (The Return of the King). After succeeding in vanquishing the fellbeast of the Witch King but failing to fall in battle, Eowyn meets Faramir in the House of Heeling (The Return of the King). After many consecutive days of conversation, Faramir convinces Eowyn to let go of her one-way adoration and to instead accept a mutual love (The Return of the King). In doing so, Eowyn gives up the unconditional love and adoration which she gave to Aragorn. Aragorn, as a mortal man, should not be held in such high esteem.

The villains of the Lord of the Rings are so averse to self-sacrifice that they become uncompromising and weak through division. The kidnapping of Merry and Pippin gives an insight into how orcs deal with each other. Throughout the Hobbits' captivity, the Orcs argue yet reach no conclusion; no matter how many times they go back and forth over why the Hobbits are to be kept alive or should be killed, the two sides stick to their positions (The Two Towers). This inability to agree ultimately divides the large party of Orcs and allows the riders of Rohan to mow them down in the field, while the two Hobbits escape thanks to a treacherous Mordor Orc (The Two Towers). Notably, Tolkien's commentary on Gollum falling into the fires of Mt. Doom suggests that the sacrifice must be willingly made. Tolkien argues that Frodo claiming the Ring in Mt. Doom was not a moral failure, as he had no self control at that point due to forces greater than himself (Letter 246). Tolkien argues that one cannot claim or be held to acts or events which one has no control over. Therefore, a great loss beyond one's control is not an act of worship or sacrifice.

Throughout the course of the Lord of the Rings, it is the continual, voluntary sacrifices of the heroes that ultimately allows the divine plan of Eru to come to fruition. Some of these sacrifices are rewarded, while others must stand as a permanent loss. As a true expression of devotion, these acts must be willingly done and must reduce the honor, power, or being of the person. In this way, the peoples of Middle Earth show their devotion and play their part in the workings of God.

MDH

The Very Wine of Blessedness

“It is sad, as are all the tales of Middle-earth,” says Aragorn to the hobbits on Weathertop of the tale of Tinúviel. And he is certainly correct. A consistent feature of the tales told in verse throughout The Lord of the Rings is a deep melancholy, from the lament Galadriel sings in Lothlórien of her loss of distant Eldamar to Gimli’s chant of the mighty days of Durin long since passed to the ancient poem translated by Aragorn remembering sadly the greatness of Eorl the Young and the Rohirrim. The list goes on. In Middle-earth, lamentations of people, places, and times lost are fundamental to the characterization of the Free Peoples. But if this is such a strong feature of the tales, then it seems rather strange that Aragorn would tell one to the hobbits as they lie in hiding from the servants of the Dark Lord. One would assume that a tale fraught with sadness would be the last thing that they would want to hear in such a situation. But Aragorn believes otherwise, concluding his statement, “and yet it may lift up your hearts.” And it is the complexity of the apparent contradiction raised here that explains the power of Tolkien’s Middle-earth.

The contradiction lies at the very heart of all the stories in the history of Middle-earth, perhaps nowhere more poignantly than in the very tale of which Aragorn tells a small part. For Beren and Lúthien faced many perils and “many sorrows befell” them. And when Lúthien died, the Eldar “lost her whom they most loved” forever. And this tale is tied inextricably with the Fall of Gondolin, which tells of another union of Man and Elf. Gondolin’s fall is one of the greatest points of despair in all the history of the Eldar, as the beautiful work of the Noldor fell once more to ruin because of the pride of Turgon their king. And yet, from these stories of ruin and death arises the most beautiful triumph in all the Elder Days. For from the line of Beren and Lúthien came Elwing, and from that of Tuor and Idril came Eärendil. And when these two were wedded, the perfect union of the Children of Ilúvatar was realized. The Three Houses of Men, the Noldor, and the Sindar were all represented in the marriage of Eärendil and Elwing. And their journey to the West to plead at the feet of the Valar for the forgiveness of the Noldor and the salvation of the Children from the might of Morgoth Bauglir thus surpasses the despair of the tales before it and even the joy of the resulting march of the Valar to Middle-earth. Without the horrors and sorrows inflicted upon the Children in the tales leading up to it, the account of Eärendil’s quest and especially its success loses a great deal of its exquisite potency.

This is the beauty of Tolkien’s idea of eucatastrophe. At the very end of all hope, when the victory of the Darkness over the Light seems surer than ever, the transformation of despair to joy in a sudden moment of ecstasy is beyond words. And for Tolkien, this goes far beyond mere stories; there is a theologically grounded reason for humanity’s yearning for eucatastrophe. In “On Fairy-stories” he writes that “the Birth of Christ is the eucatastrophe of Man’s history” and that His “Resurrection is the eucatastrophe of the story of the Incarnation.” Thus, the story of God’s begotten Son is one that “embraces all the essence of fairy-stories,” which in becoming a part of our real world has raised “the desire and aspiration of sub-creation to the fulfillment of Creation.” We as children of God are embracing a part of our divine connection to the Creator in telling our own sub-created stories of eucatastrophe.

And here we can see also why Tolkien’s stories in particular are so devastatingly attractive in their eucatastrophic elements. He says that if a story can be told that is “primarily” true in its account of history, which at the same time retains its “mythical and allegorical significance,” then that story would elicit a joy that “has the very taste of primary truth.” Tolkien of course believes that the most “pre-eminently high and joyous” version of this story is that of the Great Eucatastrophe in Christ. But he leaves the possibility open to other such stories, which would look forward or backward to the story of Christ. And while it is obviously true that the history of Middle-earth is in fact not “primarily” true, Tolkien’s devotion to the elucidation of details great and minute within his world over the course of nearly six decades resulted in a history that is so consistent and real that it passes for primary truth. Readers can experience his world so completely that when the tale of Eärendil is told, they can without doubt taste the joy that he described.

But even the great power and poignancy of the eucatastrophe of the First Age of Middle-earth falls short of Tolkien’s most resonant account of the complex of emotions that stem from the eucatastrophic tale, which comes at the end of The Lord of the Rings. In a stroke of brilliance, he presents this through the eyes of the humble Sam. Through Sam the humble hobbit of the lowest stature and station, the reader experiences every newly revealed moment of joy with the greatest possible potency. As he walks through the assembled host of the now truly Free Peoples of Middle-earth, the joys build and build, as he sees the guards bow before him, hears the praising song of the gathered men, sees Strider of Bree sitting upon the throne of Gondor. And just when the emotional weight of these moments seems unbearable, Sam’s final wish comes true, as the minstrel sings of Frodo of the Nine Fingers and the Ring of Doom. All of Sam’s hopes have been realized, and he can only weep with joy. And the passage that follows, among the best that Tolkien ever wrote, can only be given in full:

And all the host laughed and wept, and in the midst of their merriment and tears the clear voice of the minstrel rose like silver and gold, and all men were hushed. And he sang to them, now in the elven-tongue, now in the speech of the West, until their hearts, wounded with sweet words, overflowed, and their joy was like swords, and they passed in thought out to regions where pain and delight flow together and tears are the very wine of blessedness.

In these two sentences, Tolkien manages to encapsulate perfectly the impossible beauty of the eucatastrophe, and in this moment, all the despair that has filled the verses of the story to this point are completely justified. The lament of Frodo for Gandalf in Lothlórien, of Aragorn and Legolas for Boromir by the falls of Rauros, of the future Rohirrim for Théoden on the Pelennor, all are made part of the eucatastrophe that culminates in the minstrel’s song.

And thus, with the ending of the War of the Ring, Tolkien achieves the end of sub-creative work in which he so fervently believed.  The Christian, he writes, “may now, perhaps, fairly dare to guess that in Fantasy he may actually assist in the effoliation and multiple enrichment of creation,” knowing that his work will ever be a piece of the Great Eucatastrophe. Tolkien’s stories have stood the test of decades, and will continue to resonate with readers for generations to come, because in them, he succeeded in fulfilling the most fundamental of human yearnings, making his works as timeless as the human condition itself.

   – Andrew Stump

A Perfect Ending to Lord of the Rings

Could there have been a perfect ending to Lord of the Rings? Could there have been a way to completely satiate the audience? Did Tolkien try to do this through the additive works he completed such as The Silmarillion? Is there even such a thing as a perfect ending? I find myself asking these questions after our final class.

The thing about endings is that they are rarely perfect, if the reader imagines beyond where the words stop. And I believe, generally speaking, they do imagine beyond where the words stop. I’d say the only perfect ending I have ever seen was in Andrew Sean Greer’s Less (a great read), but that is besides the point. I think Tolkien could have given readers a very clean, somewhat perfect ending if he had wanted to. If, at Mordor, Frodo was not corrupted by the ring and tossed it neatly into the vat of lava beneath him, remaining a hero in the truest sense and ended it with his glorious ride through middle-earth, being praised for his destruction of the One Ring. But that is of course not what happened; we looked inside the story and saw Frodo’s corruption. So when he gets on the ship, we do not know what necessarily happens to him. But that’s okay because endings do not have to be perfect.

However, what I was most struck by on Wednesday’s discussions of endings and readings was C.S. Lewis’ work “Meditation in a Toolshed.” He talks about looking at experiences verses looking through experiences using a beam of light. When you look at the beam, all you can see is the beam, but when you look along it you can see trees, leaves etc., whatever the beam’s light makes visible. Looking at is being on the outside and looking along is being on the inside. He talks about how this relates to experiences. I believe, alongside Terry Pratchett, stories come from the inside, so it’s important to be inside them to understand people. To understand the world, I believe people tell themselves narratives that they’ve learned through reading stories. Tolkien, I also believe was unconsciously framing Lord of the Rings around biblical stories just because the narrative is something that had been engrained in his head. Like love stories we come to see in movies today about meet-cutes with attractive women and men who play cat and mouse games until the story eventually resolves itself in a happy ending, the characters the whole time focused on the significant other. In a way, Frodo focused on the ring in the same manner, telling himself that his story is significant. I know this by looking inside the character, looking inside his motivations and desires. It's not hard to understand someone, even if it's a character, if you look along the beam.

Endings are almost never perfect because the story lives on. There are two endings according to Aristotle, where the story ends with a wedding or a funeral. Whether it's happy or it's a tragedy. But as far as human life goes, and life for all the creatures of middle earth, nothing is permanent. Tolkien's work may have ended technically with a wedding for Sam and Aragorn, making it a happy one but as life continues both happy and sad trajectories live on. "Nothing gold can stay."

[IG]